Software
Houzz Logo Print
msavold

Radiant floor heating longevity??

16 years ago

Folks:

met with the electrician today to discuss putting in radiant floor heating under the bathroom marble tiles. His attitude was "I wouldn't do that...".

Apparently he's "seen a bunch of stuff" - and has had some experience - that says that radiant systems, regardless of manufacturer, fail after a few years. Blames it on the tiles 'shifting' when people walk on them and damaging the mesh.

This seems contrary to everything I've read (and what he was describing sounds like more of an installation error like no Ditra or similar).

Can anyone tell me about their long-term experiences?

Thanks!

Mauro

Comments (3)

  • 16 years ago

    It's a toaster. The simplest circuit possible. I think your guy is resisting. Do it yourself and remove him from the equation. You only need electrical resistance to generate heat in the places you want heat; you don't need his resistance generating heat and doubt in your brain.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks - the more I thought about it the more I'm coming to the same conclusion. I can't see how there can be enough flex in the floor to actually break the cord - the bloody tile would fail long before that, I'd guess.

  • 16 years ago

    I have electric radiant heat in my bathroom for almost 1 year now and I love it. I can't believe I used to walk on a cold floor and all my life. Forget bathroom mats and rugs a warm floor is priceless.

    My installation is in a 1-bedroom apartment in New York, Queens, on the 17th Floor and this building definitely shifts and moves as it is a 21 story building. The contractor I used was really good. I bought a 5 foot by 3 foot heating mat. The contractor laid down a thin coat of concrete over the mat. I didn't really want him to do this as I thought it would take the floor longer to heat but it really doesn't make a difference. We talked about putting the thinsulate, used for the tiling, directly on the heating mat at first but he also said he was not comfortable doing this and felt the mat needed to be protected, at least a little, in the concrete floor.

    I used NuHeat and their daily programmable thermostat. That is an absolute MUST. I set the floor to start warming up at 6am and when I hit the shower at 7am it's toasty warm. Don't go cheap on the thermostat. Some do NOT have timers and you have to manually turn it on. It totally defeats the purpose. Who's going to wake up one hour before they have to and turn on the heat, they go back to bed.

Sponsored
The Steele Group
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars1 Review
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio