Software
Houzz Logo Print
neela_gw

Best dining room set under 10K

20 years ago

Looking to spend around 10K for an English Traditional (chippendale chairs etc.) dining room + 2 arm + 6 side chairs + buffet. What's the best I can do in terms of manufacturers? Willing to order from NC obviously. Am I missing out on any really good manufacturers narrowly on the price? How do Hickory Chair/ Harden/ Councill/ Hickory White compare to each other? Can I get better for the money. Thanks a lot.

Comments (11)

  • 20 years ago

    Check consignment shops, used furniture stores and the like.

    You can get excellent 1920s-1940s stuff in that price range.

  • 20 years ago

    Also auction houses and antique shops.

    Lazygardens is right. They just don't make wood like they used to (stretch that time frame into the 50's and 60's as well). A lot of dining rooms never got used, so you can find stuff in excellent condition. Breakfronts and buffets don't seem to hold their value, so good deals can be found.

    The most difficult thing (for me) to find has been chairs.

  • 20 years ago

    Harden and Council would be upper end although Council went bankrupt a few years back and I have not physically seen their furniture in a while.

    HC and HW are upper middle lines and comparable in quality. HW is an easy Best Buy both for reasonable MSRP and aggressive discouting available thru the likes of lexfurniture.com.

  • 20 years ago

    My brother and his new wife needed to furnish a lovely new home in Colorado and then later in Savannah. He goes regularly to auctions and says that the dining rooms sets are the best buyl Its wood--tends to look great if its been well cared for.
    His furniture is spectacular. Google "auctions" for your area and you will get results.

  • 20 years ago

    Check out ebay too. Many antique stores list their inventory there. You don't have to buy using ebay, but checking it might give you a good list of antique stores to visit. For 10K you'll be able to find a high quality set if you go the "used" route. In a nice furniture store ten thousand will probably get you above average quality.

  • 20 years ago

    Try amish or mennonite builders in you area. Also look for local craftsman. You should be able to find solid construction withing the price you are looking at. Stay away from anything that is veneer on the table. It may look nice but will often have problems in the future. You do not need to go to NC to find nice things.

    Good luck,
    Bob

  • 19 years ago

    Just because furniture is made by the Amish does not mean it is quality. I have seen some Amish made junk.

  • 19 years ago

    I think you can do that without going the used route ... I bought a table and 6 side chairs from Statton for $7,000... add 2 armchairs at another $1,000 and a buffet for $2,000 and you're there.

    I didn't buy my cabinet from Statton, but I did price a server at $1,700.

    Retail on the table and chairs would have been $12,000.

    Not that I'm against used furniture, at all, because I tried very hard to find some. I just couldn't do it, and didn't have enough time to look any longer. If you can find it, it's a great deal. Especially tables ...

  • 19 years ago

    There are still PLENTY of premium makers out there (i.e., 'they don't make them like they used to'. You have to get off the path of buying a "brand name" that is advertised in the magazines though.

    The best furniture at the most reasonable prices in the USA is cottage-industry, not pipelined through North Carolina. There are some remarkable pieces available at prices slightly higher (but not ridiculously) over 'brand name' heavily-advertised units.

    Just think about this..instead of spending money on advertising, samples, setting up a dealer base, marketing and front end personnel these small-time wood artisans put it all in the wood.

    Yes, you have to work harder to find them, but they're out there. As a businessman, the strict forum rules here prevent me from posting links, so I can't point you in a particular direction, but I'll encourage you to dig around and find them on the web. Even the smallest shops have simple web sites these days.

  • 19 years ago

    dcollie,

    When you say "cottage industry", do you mean a company like Robert Bergelin? If not, please share with us a couple of examples. Thanks.

  • 19 years ago

    'Cottage Industry' is indicative of small wood-working shops that are passionate about their work and have a lot of pride in workmanship of their products. Many of the best cabinetmakers will go to craftsman shows, such as the Designer Craftsman Show in Valley Forge, PA held every year. (link to the promoter's website, below)

    I'm not familiar with "Robert Bergelin" but went to their website to try to get an idea of what they sell, but I can't make a determination of their workmanship from what they show there.

    Everyone claims to be "handcrafted by artisans" (As they unload their container from China!) but the real key is for you as the consumer to get educated on what makes a quality piece and then examine the item before you buy. When I get some time, I'll post a list of things to look for when buying furniture (going to be a long post!)

    The rules for business owners are extremely strict here, and whereas consumers can make specific recommendations, those of us in the trade cannot do that or risk being banned from the list. Sorry!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Designer Craftsman Show