Software
Houzz Logo Print
bigfish44

New furnace

19 years ago

If I up grade from a ducane 80% furnace to the new two stage vari speed american standard will this lower my propane bills alot. I have a six year old home approx 2200 sq. ft my ducane seems to cycle on and off alot and I keep thermostat at 67.Iplan on staying here 15-18 years would this be a good investment.Im spending $500.00 a month and were having a mild winter here in N.J..thanks in advance Tom

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    Yeah you might save a bit. $500 a month sounds really high for a newer well-insulated home. If you do get one of those fancy new furnaces do yourself a big favor and install surge protection for it.

  • 19 years ago

    Is there a big difference between the two stage vari. speed and two stage non vari. speed blowers (Except about $1000.00 price difference.) Do you really save enough on gas to justify the cost. thanks Tom

  • 19 years ago

    No, The cost will probably take about 8 years to break even. At 14 years old the system is at replacement time. This does not include the higher maintenance when the variable speed dies.

    Wait a few years and see how the industry goes. I think in your case this is throwing money away. Unless you have significant installation problems.

  • 19 years ago

    Your cycling has nothing to do with your system and everything to do with your thermostat. Also, if you're thinking of going to a new furnace why use propane. Oil would always be cheaper on a BTU basis.

  • 19 years ago

    Well, I would say that any up-grade from a Ducane would be an improvement..LOL

    But, seriously, I would recommend the American Standard 2 stage /w/ variable drive AUD100R9V5.Just don't forget to order propane kit for unit and 2/stage thermostat.

    Here is a link that might be useful: american standard

  • 19 years ago

    bigfish

    A couple of comments and observations.

    First, propane is probably the most expensive heating fuel available and most likely will only get more expensive. You must do a careful analysis of alternatives including electric (heat pump) and oil. I suggest you look at warmair.com which has a very useful energy fuel comparison calculator. Find out the various rates from your utility for oil, propane, and electricity.

    An 80% AFUE propane furnace is a big mistake for your area/climate unless there are installation issues for a 90+% AFUE propane furnace.

    A $500/mth heating bill is absurd. You should seek out an energy audit that sometimes is provided at no charge from utilities.

    A furnace system that shortcycles could be the result of several reasons including an oversized system. You should insist that your quoting dealers survey your home and provide a Manual J heat/cool load calculation for correctly sizing a new system. Get this in writing and review carefully with the dealer.

    A properly sized 2 stg furnace will save you $$$ and will run in low stgs except on those very cold days. Now to var speed blowers which I believe is a great feature. Var speed is all about better comfort and will save you dollars. Here are the reasons. Var speed blowers are quieter than conventional blowers; var speed blowers when used in AC mode provide better dehumidification; var speed provides improved room-to-room temperature constancy; var speed are less expensive to operate than conventional AC blowers; and finally with a good filter cabinet, var speed can provide better indoor air quality.

    My idea would be look at a high eff heat pump system first and then possibly a dual fuel system. You want to eliminate propane or at least total reliance on a propane furnace for heating. NJ electric utility may offer special rates for winter heating. I suggest you look into this.

    And finally now is the time to have your ductwork inspected and identify and correct any hot/cold spots within your home.

    BTW, AmStd make a very reliable var speed two stg furnace as well as high eff heat pumps with var speed air handlers.

    IMO
    Good LucK!

    Here is a link that might be useful: energy fuel comparison calculator