Software
Houzz Logo Print
furboyz

Would like assistance with a bid comparison

16 years ago

We have to replace both our upstairs and downstairs ac/heating units. Currently we have two bids that are similar and would welcome any feedback as to which is better out of the two. Both are suggesting the same furnace and thermostat, warranty, etc. We live in Texas so AC is more important to us than heating. Both proposals did give us calulations.

Thanks in advance for your help. It is greatly appreciated.

1. Trane XR13 2.5 ton upstairs, 3.5 ton downstairs $9,830

2. Trane XR15 3 ton upstairs, 3.5 ton downstairs $10,850 (qualifies for tax credit but is not as important to us for tax reasons). This is 16 SEER

Comments (10)

  • 16 years ago

    I would definetly go with the 16 seer for the extra money. Its totally worth it in my opinion. Considering you'll be doing alot of cooling and it takes care of your heating needs I"m sure it will pay for itself. Don't forget about the tax credit. That is very significant savings.

    Have you considered other brands? You could probably get an off brand thats just as efficient and good for alot less money. I recently purchased a Luxaire unit that I"m happy with. Luxaire is part of York. Get a higher end model. They are very quiet and efficient. Great warranty. Even there lower end units have demand defrost. My unit has a jacket around the compressor.

    Also ask your contractor if the price includes a txv valve. That will increase system efficiency.

    Are your bids including air-handlers? I paid significantly less for my heat pump system. I didn't replace the air handler though. I just replace outdoor unit, inside coil, all new copper linesets and wiring, and new honeywell focus pro wireless dual-fuel t-stat.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you for the input. I was thinking the 16 SEER was the better deal. For some reason we had 4 bids for other brands that were coming in over $18K but they all wanted to replace our concrete slab outside, which doesn't need to be replaced. The two Trane come in the lowest. It could also be the area we live in that Trane happen to come in the lowest right now.

    We have to replace everything with our heating and ac. So it does include the air handlers. Due to the heating being the old pilot light system and having to match everything to code we are upgrading eveything at one time. Actually, it is coming out to be more cost effective now for us to do it that way and this time of year for us. 9 years ago we had a home warranty ac unit installed that has failed and was not the right load, we have learned through this bid process. The rest of the system is original to the house which is 19 years old. We also learn from our bids, our heating and ac guy wasn't doing a good job maintaining. Really..it hasn't been done. We had shut done the heat last year, which was good because we were told by everyone we could have had a fire! So...we are at that place of needing to replace everything.

  • 16 years ago

    Are you planning on replacing your air handler, or at least changing coils? You may not realize 16 SEER if a non-matched coil/air handler is used. Ask for an AHRI certificate for the equipment you are buying.

    Are you replacing units that use R22? If so, most contractors recommend a new lineset. Many new units using R410A require larger tubing.

    V

  • 16 years ago

    we are replacing a 32 yr. old gas furnace and a/c in our 1750 sq.ft., two story townhouse here in the bay area (sf). we have been quoted the following, installed:

    goodman #gmh95 and 3 ton a/c with 13 seer for $5,000

    rheem #rgrl 95% and 3.5 ton (rapl 14) a/c with 14 seer for $4500.

    both are with new coils and a pump for the evaporation to the drip line.

    we are leaning toward the rheem furnace as it seems to offer a bit more and is less. $500 is not going to make or break the deal, we just want a decent furnace. we've heard good things about both...any thoughts from this forum?

  • 16 years ago

    deputy

    the best advice I can offer is to have dealer perform a Man J load calculation. The SF Bay area with its moderate climate is unique in that it usually indicates low heating and cooling load which translates to small furnace and small AC. Add a townhouse type residence and this usually makes HVAC footprint even smaller.

    what size furnace and AC are you replacing? oversizing is to be avoided at all costs. what size furnaces are being quoted? what is more important for your location-heating or cooling?

    I would prefer a two stg furnace with VS blower for quiet operation. Neither the Goodman or Rheem furnaces quoted are var speed.

    A little research shows average winter temp at 49 deg fah and av summer temp at 73 degrees fah. those are averages not the extreme.

    In your case, sizing is very important.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes-

    thanks- a little more homework for me to do this weekend. both are two stage, but, as you pointed out, not with a v/s blower.

    as for average temps, the furnace is the most important, as we use the a/c maybe 3-6 weeks a year. with the larger blower in both furnaces, we were hoping to get better cooling in the upstairs. of course, if we installed a ceiling fan in the stairwell to push the hot air down it would help.

    again, thanks. first time i've been to this forum-pretty cool!

  • 16 years ago

    The GMH95 stages based on a timer, so no real opportunity to get the most comfort out of it with a 2-stage thermostat (which would allow the thermostat to signal when 2nd stage heating is needed). As tiger said neither are variable speed, which is nice to have. I suspect that at least the Rheem bid has an oversized air conditioner. Don't be afraid to get another quote or two. Doesn't sound like these quotes are very detailed or thorough though they carry attractive prices compared to most. Brand isn't the big factor here but I would prefer a Rheem unit over a Goodman unit.

  • 16 years ago

    Furbyz:

    Can you explain this statement?

    "2. Trane XR15 3 ton upstairs, 3.5 ton downstairs $10,850 (qualifies for tax credit but is not as important to us for tax reasons). This is 16 SEER"

    Subtracting the $1500 tax credit makes this the least expensive system.

  • 16 years ago

    deputy

    I know this thread was hyjacked but I would be willing to bet a pitcher of beer that both quoting dealers have you oversized on both cooling and heating.

    get a load calc performed.

    here is a link that a homeowner can perform himself for $49. well worth it.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: HVAC Calc

  • 16 years ago

    I would be a little cautious of the HVAC Calc - most load calculations can easily be done wrong - with just a one or two bad inputs. I have fixed quite a few with errors.

    I have suggested elsewhere these helpful forms -

    and below an excellent document for helping compare bids - which factors in more than just the net cost in $ - the hidden costs.

    After that the Verifying Manual J leaflet can help you determine if the load calculations were done right. I am would be suspicious that they came in different by 1/2 ton - somebody has a mistake / or is padding.
    http://www.acca.org/Files/?id=68

    Here is a link that might be useful: Residential Quality HVAC Installation You Should Get What You Paid For