Software
Houzz Logo Print
titanbass

Rafter Insulation in Attic

19 years ago

I have an unfinished attic space off an upstairs bedroom. The house is 1 1/2 story. The attic space rafters slope down to the front of the house. The floor is covered with plywood. The living room is under this attic space. Originally, there were only old batts in the rafters. I added batts to the wall of the bedroom. Then, I pryed up the plywood and added batts in the floor. Now, there is insulation on the bedroom wall and in the ceiling above the living room. The batts in the rafters are probably 40+ years old and seem to be deteriorating. There does not seem to be any type of rafter vent under the insulation. Now the questions:

  1. Do the rafters need to be insulated since this area is not lived in?
  2. If the rafters needs to be insulated, should I take out the old batts and replace with new batts? It does not appear that I can to the rafters. I would compress the batts.

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    Need more info.
    What state (or climate) do you live in?
    Do you have problems with ice and snow on the roof?
    How old is the roof? Do you have asphalt shingles?
    What repairs have you made to the roof?
    Do you have vents in the eves?
    Do you have a ridge vent, gable vents, and/or other ventilators in the roof?
    Does the old insulation have black marks on it?
    Yes, I know this sounds like a pain, but hang in there!
    Your questions will have answers.

  • 19 years ago

    -I live in Ohio.
    -I am still getting ice dams in the gutters and not enough snow staying on the roof.
    -The roof is approximately 5 yrs old. Yes. Asphalt.
    -No repairs since buying the house. 3 1/2 years ago.
    -No eve (soffit) vents.
    -No ridge vents. Only gable and roof vents.
    -There are no black marks that I can see.
    Thank you

  • 19 years ago

    Copy this and paste it to your browser address window:

    http://www.extension.umn.edu/distribution/housingandclothing/DK1068.html

  • 19 years ago

    You need a cold roof. To make this happen, you have to stop all air flow from living space to attic, and you should insulate your living room ceiling and bedroom wall to R38. To stop the air flow, look at every fixture in the ceiling and find every pipe and electric wire and other penetration. Some penetrations may be found by searching the insulation on your ceiling for black marks. The insulation acts as a filter and catches particles from the air flowing through. Seal every hole with a fire resistant canned foam product. Dap makes one that is water soluble.
    When all holes are sealed and insulation is done, I think you should strip the insulation from the roof and leave it bare.
    But know this: I have no experience with ice dams. I am not qualified to give you any advice regarding attic and roof insulation. However, I do know that it is critical to seal all penetrations through your ceiling and bedroom wall. This includes the door!
    Copy and paste this to your browser for more info:
    http://www.umass.edu/bmatwt/publications/articles/ice_dams.html

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you for the information. This has been very helpful.

  • 19 years ago

    you may want to check out www.corwinsmartventilationsystem.com
    They have a couple patented products that optimize roof and attic ventilation. The Corwin Smart Clip works with 1' foam placed in between the rafters/trusses from the soffit to the ridge vent. The Clip forms a 1' channel between the foam and roof deck. Most relevant to you, it prevents escaping warm air from reaching the roof deck and melting snow. (obiously, you want to minimize the amount of heat lost from the living space like Airsome suggested) The warmer air follows the foam up to the ridge vent and out of the house.
    For the system to work properly, soffet and ridge vents are needed.
    In the summer the radiant heat from the sun is captured in the 1' air channel and vented out the ridge vent. This will keep your attic about 30-40 degrees cooler and save about 20-40% in your cooling bills.

    Hope this helps

    Here is a link that might be useful: Corwin Smart Ventilation System