Software
Houzz Logo Print
green712_gw

Trane, York or Carrier?

16 years ago

Good day. I am in Raleigh NC, 21 yr old house, need all new hvac, would appreciate advice about the following estimates.

2,000 SQ FT, all 11 windows 2 sliding doors, front door replaced with Energy Star models in 2007

Currently 3 tons. All quotes sized 3 tons except last one

two tons. The first 3 are from same contractor.

1) TRANE XR15 outdoor unit: 4TTR5036

Gas Furnace: TUD1B080DA9H31B

Coils: 4TXCB004CC3HCA

price: $5333.00 SEER 16

2) TRANE XL20 outdoor unit: 4TTZ0036

gas furnace: TUD080R9V4K

coils: 4TXCC007CC3HCA

price; $8705.00 SEER 17.75

3) YORK CZH036

furnace: YPLC080B12MP12C

coils? MC42B3XHI

price: $ $7864.00 SEER 17.25

York (only) providing lifetime warranty on compressor and heat exchange. Seen lots of bad reviews on York due to apparently sub-standard parts made in China. But he was really big on the York. (obviously salesrep influence)

**************************

4) CARRIER

furnace 58CVA090

evaporator CNPHP4821

condensor 24APA736

PRICE $7,400..SEER 17

**********************

5) TRANE XL15I

furnace XV80

coils: 4TXCB

$8663.00 or for the XL16I, total would be $9213.00

This last contractor sized for 2 tons due to new windows and doors, which made sense since I have read it should be taken into account, However, everyone else kept it at 3 tons and I told everyone about the windows and doors.

Questions:

1) Is it worth it to get a heat pump with gas furnace here? (dual fuel?)

2) Is it worth the $$ for a separate zone for second floor? Everyone prices about 2K extra. Thanks in advance for any insight.

Comments (5)

  • 16 years ago

    Go with the first quote wouldnt advise duel fuel in your area. If later you feel you need the second zone you can always add it later just my opinion stay away from York the only other brand I would look at is Rheem .Carrier is ok how ever they have had leaky Evap coils in the past.

  • 16 years ago

    green

    ask yourself these questions.

    how long do you expect to be in this home?

    how did current three ton AC perform? any comfort issues for top floor either cooling or heating?

    you are in a perfect climate for a heat pump with nat gas backup. plus you have reasonable electric rates.

    I would not even consider going down in size of the outside condenser without a properly performed load calculation to support it.

    You do want a new and correctly sized refrigerant lineset. I would also include a 4-5" pleated filter media cabinet.

    Now to the systems listed. Option #1 packs alot of punch and value. That is an XT80 gas furnace with the high eff blower motor. here are the numbers below. a little light in cooling BTUs, but it does qualify for tax credit.

    3432940 Active Systems XR15 TRANE 4TTR5036E1 4TXCB004CC3 *UD1B080A9H3 33600 13.00 16.00

    I would get an upgrade price on the XR15 heat pump version. Also you might consider the XV80 two stg 80% VS furnace.

    Regardless, I would want a good matching thermostat like Trane's 803 or the identical and probably less expensive HW equivalent.

    IMO
    Good Luck!

  • 16 years ago

    Hopefully quote 2 would include the communicating furnace (model number is incorrect if so) and the 900 thermostat to tie it all together. Likewise for the Carrier using the Infinity thermostat. Quote 1 is a good value but lacks a variable speed motor which is nice to have for efficiency and improved comfort. Lastly, the dealer quoting 2 tons is probably more correct than any of the others. Might be looking at a 2 or 2.5 ton unit--who knows without doing the PROPER calculations to determine anything.

  • 16 years ago

    #2 doesn't look like a communicating furnace though.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for all your replies. On quote nbr 2, I see what you guys ryanhughes and baldloonie are referring to as to the proper communicating furnace. Trane says for XL20i the furnace is supposed to be XC95, higher efficiency and the contractor put it with only an 80 pct efficiency furnace. Maybe he was trying to hold down the price but, really we want matching systems. Trane's website seems to be the most user friendly and informative of the bunch, and I will definitely take all your suggestions into account.