Software
Houzz Logo Print
susanw2_gw

Adding AC to Hydro Heat System-Help w/ Quotes

16 years ago

I live in north central Massachusetts in a ten year old house with Hydro heat. First floor is 1600 sq. feet, 2nd floor is 1120 sq. feet, 3rd floor is 1120 sq. feet. Second and third floors are on same heating zone. Third floor is only semi finished and is not currently being used and the heating vents are closed. When the house was built, the air conditioning was "roughed in"-the refrigerant, drainage and thermostat lines were brought down to the basement, but never finished.

The ideal location for the condensers is behind the garage. The problem is the length of the refrigerate lines-the run from the attic to the condenser is about 120 feet, from the basement to the condenser is about 94 feet.

I decided to complete the air conditioner system and have received 4 quotes.

Here is what I currently have:

BASEMENT AIR HANDLER (for 1st floor)

First Co.

 Model # 36MBXR-3HH

    Rating: 120V - 1PH - 60 HZ

    Heating - Hot Water, 180 F max

    Cooling - Refrigerant 22

    May use First Co. Flow Control

    Module Model 940-3 CV

  First Co.

    Fan Coil Unit 27 JF

  US A/C Products - Evaporator Coil

    Model: USM436AP

    Part No: 81436AP-M

    Nom Cap:  36000/30000  BTUH

    The orifice size should be matched to the outdoor unit capacity as shown below:

       Unit Capacity 36,000 BTUH - use orifice #70

       Unit Capacity 30,000 BTUH - use orifice #63

       Refrigerant 22

       Coil Design Pressure 300 psig

Â
ATTIC AIR HANDLER (for 2nd and 3rd floors)

    First Co.

     Model # 30MBXR-3HH

     (remaining label same as above)

    First Co.

      Fan Coil Unit 27 JF

    US A/C Products - Evaporator Coil

       Model: USM330AP

       Part No: 81330AP-M

       Nom Cap: 30000/24000  BTUH

The orifice size should be matched to the outdoor unit capacity as shown below:

       Unit Capacity 30,000 BTUH - use orifice #63

      Unit Capacity 24,000 BTUH - use orifice #59

Also:"Piston orifice is already installed in this unit"   and  " Horizontal drain pan is in place"

Peerless Boiler WBV-04-150-WPC with a Superstor water heater

Here's the information on the 4 quotes I have received:

QUOTE #1Â

American Standard condensing units: one 3 Ton and one 2 1/2 Ton at 13 seer efficiency rating with R-22 refrigerant. To be placed out back of garage. Will furnish material and labor ( does not specify what!) except for electrical. Condensers carry 10 year warranty on parts. All other parts and labor are guaranteed for 1 year. Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â $5,925.00 Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â ( This quote make me uncomfortable because it lacks details and does not include electrical)Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â

QUOTE #2

Install new RUUD ACHIEVER-13 (#UAND-036JAZ) Condenser (in basement) for 1st floor and WEATHER KING-13 (#AJA30A01) Condenser (in attic) for 2nd floor. Installation shall include: high efficiency outdoor condensers placed on level Ultra clad condenser pads at rear of home, R-22 insulated refrigerant line sets, ACR copper fittings, PVC drain pipe and fittings, we will nitrogen charge and evacuate system to 400 microns before adding correct amount of refrigerant, new outside 220 volt electrical whip and disconnect, low voltage wiring from 2nd floor to condenser, all electrical wiring included, complete system start up, safety checks, walk through of new equipment. Ten year compressor warranty and 1 year other parts and labor. $6,275.00

(This installer was honest in saying that he would not install the units behind the garage because of the distance.)Â

              Â

QUOTE#3Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â

Add Central Air Conditioning System to existing air handlers:

Base system Two(2) Aire-Flow 13 SEER Condensing units $5,413.00

Complete installation includes:

Installation Labor

Refrigeration Piping

Condensate Removal System

Low Voltage Connection

New Electronic non-programable Thermostat

One Year free Service Labor on all New Components

Manufacturer's Warranty

Start up and Testing

High Voltage is included(we will provide licensed and insured electrician)

Upgrades:

Change to Two (2) Lennox XC 13 Elite Series $7,259.00

Upgrade to One(1) Lennox XC 15 Signiture Series Condenser $12,978.00

with One(1) new variable speed Lennox Air handler for second and third floor Plus One (1) Lennox XC 13 Elite series Condenser

(This combination qualifies for the $1500 tax credit)

(Although there are many options, this installer did not spend much time at the house and did not seem very interested in the job)

QUOTE#4

One Trane 3.0 Ton, 15 Seer High efficiency outdoor Condensing Unit (4TTX5036A1000A) (XL15i)

One Trane 2.0 Ton 15 SEER High efficiency Outdoor Condensing Unit (4TTX5024A1000A) (XL15i)

Insulated Refrigerant piping (10 year warranty)

Condensation pipingÂ

Electrical and Control wiring

7-day programmable Heat & Cool thermostat w/fan option

Pre-cast pads to set outdoor unit on

Permits and fees

All associated materials and labor

Complete system startup and explanation TOTAL: $7500.

Additional Options:

Evergreen ECM Variable Speed blower motor (replaces air handler old motor) +900

Installation of heat pump system (instead of just an AC system). Includes heat pump thermostat. Can utilize system all-year round for gas savings (4TWX5024A1000A) +1200

AprilAire automatic whole-house humidifier (at time of install) +$1,100

Locate units next to garage (instead of behind house) + additional piping & labor +$1,200

THOUGHTS;

Quote#4 thought outside the box. He suggested that the coils in the First Co Air Handlers be replaced changing the refrigerate to R-410A. So when the day comes that the heating system needs replacing, the condensers would already be converted to R-410A and would not need to be replaced.

He also feels that that the R-410A is better suited to address the problem with the length of the refrigerant lines since the pressure will be higher. (There is an extra $1200 charge for the added refrigerant lines). He also is using a 2-Ton size in attic to cool only the 2nd floor with the idea that if the 3rd floor space is used latter there are better options available.

After reading this forum I asked him about the Trane XR15 condensers. The verbal quote was -$800 per unit (-$1600 total) vs the above XL15i units. He felt the cons of the XR15 units were noise (we both agreed that with the units being in back of garage it would not matter) and lack of a weatherguard top which allows leaves to get in. (there are many trees nearby).

QUESTIONS;

1. I am leaning toward quote #4. He seems knowable and willing look into alternative installations for me. Does what he says make sense? I'm a single female with no air conditioning experience!

2.Compare the Trane XL15i vs XR15. Is the XL15i worth $1600 more than the XR15? How important is keeping the leaves out of the top of the unit and how could I compensate for this?

Not knowing what was important I included everything. Sorry if it's too much. Would appreciate what direction to go in. Thanks.

Comments (5)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Without the variable speed motors, probably won't get much over 13-14 SEER out of the XL15i units. Hopefully they are installing matching indoor coils for the outdoor units, unless they are approved and warranty-guaranteed matches. You can probably look at the 13 SEER outdoor Trane condensers instead. Or the XR15, and I do not think the XL15i's are worth $800 each unit. They are mechanically very similar if not identical, just slightly different apperance, little less warranty, and a little more noise.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for your response! It's my understanding that the indoor and outdoor coils will be matching. Dose it make sense to switch to the R-410A refrigerant? Which of the Trane 13 SEER condensers would you recommend? All of the info I have gathered is rather confusing!!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ask for an AHRI reference number proving that the coil proposed or coil to be reused is a rated match. Your dealer should know what this means. R-410A is fine so long as the indoor coil is rated for use with it. I get the impression that they aren't installing new matching coils, just connecting to what's there. Could be fine, but want to make sure by asking to see an AHRI certificate. Trane's XR13 or XR15 for a little more efficiency would be my pick.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I now see that it appears the dealer you feel comfortable with DOES plan to install matching coils and R-410A equipment (both good decisions in my opinion). However, not sure how there will be "better options" for cooling the third floor later on. Can you explain his reasoning behind this? If it's all one zone, why not do it right now? I could be completely confused on his methodology here.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry, I thought by matching we were talking about the refrigerate R-22 verses R-410a in the coils The coils will be First Co. Evaporation coils matching the existing air handlers I have. Apparently there is no AHRI reference number because First Co has not done any of the necessary testing. The dealer had told me this and that the system would not qualify for the tax credit.
    The third floor does not heat well with the present arrangement. All of the dealers have told me not to expected much cooling on the third floor. I did not question him as to what the "better options" might be.