Software
Houzz Logo Print
hlewis_gw

Adequate Ducting for 5 Ton package unit

16 years ago

I have a 5 Ton Goodman package unit with gas heat. The HVAC guy upgraded this from a 3 Ton because he said the 3 Ton wasn't big enough to cool/heat the area it was setup with. (He sized the original 3 Ton unit.)

The unit goes to three rooms primarily:

  1. 12x15 w/9ft ceiling, 1 vent (14 inch opening)
  2. 16x20 w/vaulting ceiling from 8ft to 16ft, 3 vents (14in opening)
  3. 8x10 w/8ft ceiling, 1 vent (8 in opening)


    The ducting is:

    18in RA

    18in SA

    the individual vents are supplied by 7 in ducting off the SA. The SA terminates in a 4th room which is 16x20 w/1 vent (14in opening, but 7in supply duct).

    Total square feet to heat/cool: 900 sq ft.

Needless to say, the room cannot be cooled. Heat appears to work OK, but unit runs a lot during the winter. Cooling wise, the unit runs continually from about 10a to 9p and never gets the temperature below 79. I'm in NE Texas and temps today were 92. It will eventually catch up and cut off about 1a by getting temps down to 76.

I'm afraid I'm going to burn out this unit and the installer is no help. He says everything is OK and the room just isn't insulated or the unit still isn't big enough.

I'm guessing I need to replace the SA and RA to get adequate airflow.

Thoughts?

Comments (8)

  • 16 years ago

    I'm thinking 5 tons is oversized (for just 3 rooms, sounds like way too much; I have 3.5 tons for a single family home here in the DC area). Ductwork is almost certainly inadequate to some degree, as most all homes do have deficiencies in the ductwork. Did he just increase tonnage without changing ductwork?

    Just to be clear: he sized the original 3 ton, then said he needs to take it out and put a 5 ton in, now has no excuse for the poor performance of the system? I think you need to find another guy who knows a little bit about Manual J and Manual D calculations to size the system and ductwork (respectively).

  • 16 years ago

    This might get you the deer in headlights look, but....

    Ask him to measure the total external static pressure (TESP) of the system, and for both return and supply, to get an idea of whether the ductwork is undersized. I'm sure it is to some level, but this may be your "proof" per se. Too high a reading indicates resistance to airflow. A 5 ton that is not moving enough air will not last very long.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks! Yes the same guy installed both. This was also a NEW installation so he put in all the ductwork as well when the 3T was installed. He now refuses to even look at it.

    He says he increased the size of the return ducting, but he was only here for about an hour and ever unloaded/loaded anything from his truck, so I know he didn't.

    i have ro replace part of the return right at the unit anyway because he put the whole thing in on a slope, with no water diverters, so I have soggy ducting on the return due to rain...thus mildew issues too...

    The unit is going on it's 2nd year now...We're in a small town, and none of the local guys want to do anything with another ones work...

  • 16 years ago

    3 tons, now 5 tons, just to cool 900 square feet? Am I reading that correctly? If I am, something is grossly wrong, no matter what kind of climate you are in.

    Tell us more about the structure. Is this a mobile home?

  • 16 years ago

    It's a wood frame structure, built about 1970-71. Wood floors, ducting and return is all from below. Two layers of wood siding on outside walls. There are 4 windows in the big room, 2 on each side; mid size room (12x15) has 1 window; smallest room has 3 windows and lots of sun exposure on West side. Whole thing was reinsulated above and below and in walls in 2005 - w/batts. Each room has ceiling fans.

    Unit is on one end of building and rooms are in a straight line, so total run length of main SA is about 40-50 feet. The funny is that the 4th room (16x20) has 7 windows, 14ft ceiling and is currently NOT sealed by any stretch of imagination and it stays cooler than anything else.

    I've always argued that the ducting was grossly undersized, but the installer/HVAC company kept disagreeing...saying the unit was too small due to the one room with the vaulted ceiling. Another installer/company said it was on the low end of acceptable for a 3T unit - now it's running a 5T unit.

  • 16 years ago

    That is all pretty bad. I wonder if you pressure the installer to fix it by going to the manufacturer who will have to eat the warranty claim if he doesn't.

    Is this really loud? Your vent size is inadequate even compared to the inadequate usual practice.

    What is your grill size on RA - give it in sq inches. You need about 700 and I bet you don't even have 300. You do know that even rule of thumb sizing would put you at 2 tons and even that might be oversized?

  • 16 years ago

    I'll try the mfger. But, not holding my breath...It's a little loud - at least more than I would have expected, but not terrible...It's just always seemed to never have much pressure on air coming out of the vents...even the one at the end of the run.

    The RA is 20x20 (400 sq inches), but that the filter size which fits the hole. There's a good 3inches all the way around to get to the Round ducting.

    I thought the 3T was more than adequate when he originally sized it. He put in a Carrier unit then but changed it out for the Goodman 5T when I wouldn't leave him alone about it not working properly...

    Thanks!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    For 900 sq. ft. a 5 ton is a lot. if it is not cooling there is definitely a problem somewhere. 5 ton should be plenty for what you described.