Software
Houzz Logo Print
wvbill_gw

Would someone please confirm my thought process?

18 years ago

I have a 10.5 year old dual split Rheem system. Recently found a leak in the upstairs unit's coil (2.5 ton Criteria II). The replacement coil would be $800 and most likely another $150 for a switch on the compressor.

Got quotes on two Lennox and two Rheem systems (92 or 94 AFUE and 13 or 14 SEER) that, depending on the system runs from $6,600 to $7,700 with new line install to cover the change from R22 to R410, new thermostat, 1 year maintenance and 12 months SAC. Warranty is 5 parts and labor 10 compressor on the bottom and straight 10 on the top system.

As much as I hate shelling out the extra $5-6K on a completely new unit, replacing the coil on this unit seems to me to be asking for problems down the road with a furnace or compressor issue.

Finally, I know there are fans of both Lennox and Rheem, but if you have any comments throw them my way.

Thanks,

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    A compressor installed costs much more than $150--usually looking in the $1000 range for the compressor installed (and that's not the whole outdoor unit). I assume the furnaces are also 10.5 years old? Can you please provide the model numbers for the Lennox and Rheem units? At 10.5 years old, it may not be a bad idea to replace the system with a high-efficiency matched system to provide comfort and efficiency. Please clarify what type of system you have--I believe you have one condenser (air conditioner), one coil, and one furnace, correct?

  • 18 years ago

    Correct. One separate 2.5 ton system for the upstairs.

    The 13 Seer quotes are

    Lennox G51MP-36B-070 92% furnace and XC-13-030

    Rheem RGRB-07EMAES 92.8 furnace and RANL-030

    14 SEER

    Lennox G61MP-36-074 94% 2 stage and XC14-030

    Rheem RGRL-06MAES 95% and RAPL -030

  • 18 years ago

    You could replace the coil if you installed/replaced the thermal expansion valve (TXV), but there are advantages of going with a new unit--warranty, comfort, efficiency, etc... Your current units are getting up there as far as age goes. I can't tell you how this repair will do or how much longer the system will last. You'll have to weigh the options and benefits, and of course everybody has a budget. Rheem and Lennox make fine products, so I'd focus on finding the better contractor. The Lennox G61MP would be my choice since it has a variable-speed blower (efficiency and comfort--I wouldn't go without one). You can ask the Rheem dealer for a similar product to the G61MP. Making sure that the system is properly sized is key to any installation. How were these units sized? Based off the old size? Manual J load calculation, which is the proper way? One thing that you did not provide is the coil model number for each setup, so I cannot tell you the actual efficiencies of the setups. I believe the Lennox G61MP model number should have a 1 or 0 after the 7, not a 4.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Ryan. We build the house and the contractor and his subs did the load calc. It has not been redone and since the old system was spot on would it be advisable to redo the calc since nothing has changed for the upstairs by way of windows or additional space.

  • 18 years ago

    If you know a Manual J was done and you had no issues with the old size, a new Manual J isn't really necessary.

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County