Software
Houzz Logo Print
cuse69

New Carrier System Quote

16 years ago

Trying to evaluate a quote for a new Carrier system. Presently in NVa, 4000 ft2 home on 3 levels with 8 yr-old 2 zone split system of 2 each Lennox 70Mbtu/hr G40 (Merit) furnaces and 2 each 2.5 ton seer 10 AC units (builder units). Plan to replace basement unit (services finished basement and main floor) for improved comfort and opportunity for state and Fed rebates/tax credit. I will run the attic unit as is and wait for future opportunities or failure. Present system runs OK with somewhat cool basement in winter, no other heating or cooling issues. Basement has separate return duct.

New system, Carrier Infinity 80% 2 stage variable speed 90mbtu gas furnace 58CVA090, Performance 3 ton 2 stage HP, 25HPA636, Carrier coil CNPVP4821 (tin plated) Infinity stat SYSTXCCUID01-B, system performance 15.5 12.6 9.1.

Contractor will reuse existing line set as the basement is finished and difficult to replace, new pad, new disconnect box, EZ Flex filter (I also have a Trion 5" pleated filter inline if I prefer with the current system). I will reuse existing AprilAire 700 humidifer. Also included is 10/10 labor/equipment Carrier extended warranty and 2 year contractor maint. plan (2x per year checkups).

Quote is $7950 before Va rebate/ Fed tax credit.

Is this a reasonable price?

Is this a solid system?

Will control system have any issues due to second zone doing its own thing so to speak? There is an open 2 story entrance vestibule between main and 2nd floor and an open staircase between basement and main floor and another open staircase between main and second floor.

With electric rates at about 10.7 cents/kwh and gas at approx. $1.15/TM delivered does a duel fuel system make sense? What changeover temp. is recommended with this cost mix and NVa. temperatures? (Incremental cost of HP vs. AC condenser was $160 after Va rebate for HP).

Thanks for your comments and recommendations.

Comments (8)

  • 16 years ago

    for what size area both living area and basement?

    basement is finished? basement is below grade? basement has any insulation qualities?

    what size existing system?

    adequate supply and return ductwork in basement?

    I would ask dealer for option to zone basement separately from main floor.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes...

    The basement is walkout with a portion underground (house is built into a hill. Sheetrock has insulation but I am unsure of R factor (not original house owner). House is corner unit of attached homes so it only has 3 exposed sides. Basement is 1100 ft2 with one double door to exterior (with glass storm door) and approx. 55 ft2 of low e double pane double hung windows. Both door/windows have NW exposure and deck overhangs windows. Basement is entirely open as a single room.

    Current system explained above with a 70Mbtu/hr single stage gas furnace for heat and 2.5 ton single stage compressor for AC (builder's grade). Also there is a AA 700 humidifier and 5" Trion filter. This serves basement and 1600 ft2 main floor. Separate system in attic serves 2nd floor.
    Basement has 4 ceiling drops and 1 floor level 12" flex duct return (about 6' run into side of main return duct). Furnace in in small utility room in center of basement.

    I hope this helps a little.

    Contractor sized new 2 stage furnace at 90Mbtu/hr primarily to qualify for tax credit as there was no Carrier Infinity match for Performance 16 HP at 70/80Mbtu that qualified. When he quoted straight AC/furnace system the furnace was spec'd at 70Mbtu. This leads me to believe the issue is more one of distribution than heat load. The offset between basement in winter is approx. 5 degrees. Just enough to discourage using.

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes...

    Also, how would my contractor zone the first floor, the duct takeoffs are not accessible without taking down sheetrock?

    What about increasing the return size to 16 in. or adding an additional return?

    Thanks

  • 16 years ago

    cuse

    supply air and return air must at the very least be in balance. if return air is too small and not located in best area, then this can contribute to reduced comfort, unnecessary noise, and sometimes premature equipment failure.

    dealer should check supplies to basement to see that they are sized correctly. at the very least, you need damper control either electronic or manual to balance airflow between basement and main floor. if that means tearing up a section of sheetrock, then it can't be helped. a new system by itself can not overcome temp problem. now is the time to address this issue.

    and reusing a refrigerant lineset is OK if flushing procedure is followed but even more important it has to be sized correctly. if not sized correctly, this would be an unacceptable shortcut.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes... and any other pros out there...

    Thanks, I will have him review the possibilities. Additional return air is easy to accomplish, the use of damper control much more difficult. Are there any devices that could be installed at the register end of the duct or do the dampers need to be at the supply end? Also, with the new system I will have a larger and variable speed furnace that could supply higher airflows. Increasing the air return in the basement probably will help.

    What is your opinion of this overall system quality, advisability of dual fuel in Northern Va (zone 4?) and price?

    Again thanks for the advice

  • 16 years ago

    cuse

    I've said all I can say on damper control.

    However, as I understand it, furnace will be located in basement. if direct venting to outside is a possibility, then you could drop HP and 80% eff furnace and go with Performance 17 AC paired with 95% 3 stg Infinity 58MVC furnace. I have no idea how close furnace location is to an outside wall.

    3483865 Active Systems PERFORMANCE 17 PURON AC CARRIER AIR CONDITIONING 24APA736A30 CNPV*4821A**+UI 58MV(B,C)080-20 36800 13.00 16.50

    just a thought.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes...

    Direct venting would also be difficult. Furnace is located in a portion of basement that is below grade. Direct venting would require running vent above 35 ft. of sheetrock ceiling and then through exterior brick wall. I know the numbers get better, but installation costs go up considerably.
    No way to cover the added costs with additional energy savings in a reasonable time. Plus the equipment costs would also go up (additional cost for furnace exceeds the additional cost for HP vs AC, $160 after Va. rebate).

  • 16 years ago

    cuse

    that answers that suggestion. however, you and dealer need to figure something out about controlling/balancing supply air to both basement and main floor.

    IMO
    Good Luck!