Software
Houzz Logo Print
artemis78

Longest useful counter run?

16 years ago

We're struggling with how to split up a counter run, and can't decide how long a counter run we should ideally have---thought I would check in here to see what people's thoughts were on the most useful length of counter space. (I've got one book where a designer insists on at least 5 feet, and another that says the most a single cook can use as far as arm span is 36 inches---agh!) So I'm wondering---if you do have long counter runs, do you feel you get good use out of them? Do you have a run that feels too short? What are you planning/did you plan for length of counter runs?

The counter run that's frustrating us is 9 feet total (with a 36" refrigerator on one end and 5' of broom closet and mudroom space on the other). It needs to include a 36" range in the middle. We have a small kitchen that will only have about 12 LF of counter total (the other 6 LF are on the sink wall, split 30"/42" on either side of a 30" sink).

Aesthetically, the best thing seems to be to break it evenly with 36" on each side. However, I'm not sure this is the most functional, and we're definitely willing to sacrifice form for function here. If we split the space unevenly, the long side would be between the refrigerator and the range. It is directly across the room from the sink.

Would you do:

- 36"/36"

- 48"/24"

- 60"/12"

- Something else?

Thanks!

Comments (20)

  • 16 years ago

    What all will you want to accomplish there? Will you want 2 people working in the area? Will you do baking projects there?
    Can you post a layout?

  • 16 years ago

    One more question: What will sit out on the counter on that run? Toaster? Coffee maker? Mixer? ???

  • 16 years ago

    For me personally, I prefer more counter to the right of my range than my left. That MIGHT be because I'm right handed, or it might be because the sink is in that direction, or because my old house had almost nothing to the left of the range so I became accustomed to prepping on the right. I agree that a layout would be helpful.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks---I'll post the layout this evening.

    We would have the toaster oven and electric kettle somewhere along that wall, and coffee-related equipment (drip) would come out in the mornings and then ideally go back in the cab, but realistically might end up stored on the counter. Otherwise, not too much in the way of appliances, but this would also presumably be where someone might put a microwave in the future (we don't have one but want to make sure there's a logical place for one). Currently we're planning to have the mixer, food processor, etc. live on the counter by the sink.

    We will likely never have two people working simultaneously on this counter run, but there may be one person at the sink and one at the stove. (We have 8+ feet between the two counters, though.) Primary purpose of the stove counters would be prep related to the stove or oven, canning projects, landing space for fridge, any prep that doesn't require access to the sink, etc. We will also be storing canned/dry food in the cabinets above that counter and baking pans and dishes below, so I would imagine it will get used for things like prepping baked goods to go in the oven, cooling racks, etc.

    Not sure if that helps---the layout might make it clearest!

  • 16 years ago

    You need a good, clear counter run between your sink and your range. That will get the most prep use. It should be kept uncluttered by appliances.

    Yes, the layout will help.

  • 16 years ago

    Where's the dry food? Without knowing that, I'm just passing along what I do.

    I'd never have a mixer near the sink - too much chance of another person accidentally ruining whatever I was mixing with water, soap or just distraction. I would have a drip coffee pot live near the sink and the trash.

    I would offset the range towards one side or the other so I had a little counter (18") for tools and spoon rest and oils - maybe spices and a much larger counter on the other side that was used for most cooking/baking prep.

    Sometimes those projects need room - cookies is a good example, sometimes they need an assortment of prep stuff and bowls that could be stored there. So I'd make the other side 54".

    Eight feet between the two runs is a bit far.

  • 16 years ago

    Had this older version handy and did a quick mod to reflect the current layout we're playing with---only other change is that we've since widened the doorway to 5' instead of 4'. Hard to tell from the diagram, but the last cabinet on each side is a high cabinet---broom closet on the left side, cooler cabinet on the right side. Still exploring ways to move or shrink the broom closet on the left if possible, but not solved yet. I think the counter split on this version was a hypothetical 30"/42". The range is 36" and the hood is 42", flanked by uppers. (The circles and squares are lights.)

    The sink is on the opposite wall (room is 13' across), but I'm toying with putting a pot filler above the range to have a water source there, since we have to run a new line for the fridge anyway.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks---yes, 8' is definitely on the far side (especially since it's actually a bit more than that) but we struggled and struggled with an island or peninsula layout and couldn't come up with one that worked. We may have a narrow work table for the center that could be put away, but even then you pretty much walk into it when you come into the room, so it's messy. There will be furniture in the open areas---a bench on the left with coat hooks above, and a table with benches against the wall on the right, which could provide occasional project work space if needed.

    Hope that makes the question a little clearer!

  • 16 years ago

    I lean towards putting a little more space on one side or the other. But the real reason I'm responding is to say-- with that much space, I'd be looking at putting in extra deep cabinets/counters. Maybe extra 3in on both sides or even 6in on one. With short runs, a little extra depth could really help.
    -Karen

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Karen---we're definitely exploring deeper counters, which someone here had suggested for our earlier designs. It's tricky on the sink wall because we have a wall-mount faucet that we want to keep, but definitely possible on the range wall, especially since the range is a vintage stove that's deeper than many modern stoves, so an extra few inches to make the cabinets flush with it would be a good thing!

  • 16 years ago

    Depends on your work habits, I think.

    My primary prep space is a 18'' x 24'' butcher block cutting board, with a sink on the left side of the board. Everything gets done there, then moved off to prep and mix bowls to the right of the board, with extra bowls parked on the table in the middle of the room. So I want at least 36'' of counter, or I feel cramped.

    If I was a baker, or frequently used a large food processor or other appliance in prep, or worked with larger quantities of food, I might need a different space. As it is, if I'm making a mess of wontons and need a lot of space, I commandeer the whole table.

    If I were working in your kitchen, I would want the sink shifted a foot to the left, I'd set my board to the right of that, and then I might wish for an additional work table somewhere nearby.

    That is a considerable distance from the range to the sink, especially if you are struggling to carry a 16 qt stock pot, taking mincing little steps as boiling liquid sloshes way too close to your belly. Yeah, the rest of you have abs, I have belly.

    Remember the movie, "The Longest Yard"? Or the classic "A Bridge Too Far"? I make a lot of soup and stock, and there are sometimes heedless children ricocheting around, so that would be a problem for me. But, again, it depends on your situation.

  • 16 years ago

    Definitely the longer counter on the space between (or closest to) your kitchen sink and range. I actually use my island the most then 2nd is the space to the LEFT of the range (which is the side closest to the sink).

  • 16 years ago

    I think with your cavernous aisle, I'd use the potfiller the way erikanh did, and make a mini-prep sink on the side of the range, and then stretch that side of the countertop longer than the other, so you can do full prep there.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm a little confused by the very large broom closet. You're using it for other storage too? with your aisles, I'm really liking marcolo's idea of doing a potfiller with a tiny prep sink like erika has. It's brilliant... as is her entire kitchen. In that case, and if you can't/don't make the broom closet smaller, I'd do 48/24 with the 48 being between the frig and range. Ideally, you can steal another foot from the closet and do 60/24... especially if you do canning and baking.

  • 16 years ago

    It's tricky on the sink wall because we have a wall-mount faucet that we want to keep...

    Artemis--Are you worried about the faucet spout reaching the sink? If so, keep in mind that you can get different spout lengths--up to 13'' IIRC--for wall mount faucets. I know that Chicago Faucets does that & probably several other brands as well.

  • 16 years ago

    Yep, we're trying to fit dog food storage in there (with a container that needs a 24"h x 21"d by 12"w space---yes, VERY big dog!)---but trying to find another lower it can go into that won't be totally inconvenient so we can bring the broom closet back to 12" x 12", which would make a lot more sense otherwise. Only frees up 6" for counter space, but the shallow aspect will make a big difference, I think.

    I'll check out erikanh's sink---great idea, and we're already opening that wall for plumbing anyway, so might as well get enough in there to make it worthwhile. :)

  • 16 years ago

    I don't remember -- did you look at a big island with shallow storage on that wall? I would prefer a closer work space from sink to everything else, so I'd probably want to create a galley and do tall, shallow storage on that inside wall -- maybe even scoot the door that direction. My room is 13-1/2 - almost 14 feet wide and we have something similar to yours with an island and prep sink plopped in the middle. It works for us -- except when folks come over on the holidays and park themselves in front of the fridge or pantry - but that would be an issue anywhere.

    Back to your question -- I had 6 feet to put around my cooktop. I had it 48/24 and the plans came back 36/36. She wanted symmetry, but I wanted work space. My 48 goes between the cooktop and ovens and is prep space and baking area. The 24 is used for cooking, but especially for serving -- it is on the end near the table. What is different is that my end is open. The 24 closes in for me. when you put a tall or wall beside it. I like having the end open. Just throwing it out there for you to consider.
    I needed one side to be larger to work for baking and I find 48 a minimal comfort level for me. Yours should fit the work you need to do there and how you work.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks lascatx---yes, we did explore the big island layout a few months back (I think we've turned this kitchen inside out and upside down at this point!) but hit conflicts with the placement of the refrigerator, which has nowhere else to go but on that wall since we've committed to not touching load-bearing walls (and our house is stuccoed, which adds to the headache if we move windows and such). We also aren't replacing our stove, so it needed a solid wall to be up against (whereas if we were getting a new one, we could look at putting it in an island).

    I think we will likely have a narrow work table in the center of the room, but nothing permanent so I want to be sure the space works decently without it, too. We stayed away from the galley layout for a long time because of the width of the aisles, but one day realized that we have a wider aisle (9+ feet) now, and that's not one of the (many!) things that bothers us about the current kitchen. The pot full of boiling water issue is one I hadn't thought extensively about, though, since our range is currently freestanding where the new door will be, so I need to mull that over a bit...I was so excited to solve the filling of the pots that I forgot about the other end of the process! :)

    @ci_lantro, the length of the faucet neck was one concern, but we're going to try to grab a Chicago wall-mount before they're gone (they've stopped making them, sadly!)---but the bigger issue was the reach to the handles to turn the faucet on and off. They're just a few inches in from the backsplash, so with deeper counters you're stretching a bit far. (It actually feels just about right with our current 22" counters.) So we'll see....so many things to figure out!

  • 16 years ago

    I have a similar dilemna-my kitchen is much smaller (9x12.5') and galley style will have 1 wall with:
    from left to right
    30" base w/pull outs
    30" range
    30" base w/pull outs
    30" sink base
    24" DW
    then exterior wall

    at most i have 30" on either side of the range of counter space, 24" over DW to right of sink.

    Should i swap the sink & DW to get 5' of continuous run to the right of the range? that means the right of the sink will be the wall, awkward for a right-hander but we don't hand wash dishes anyway. it would make the DW more accessible and be loadable from 2 sides. Would this be a deal breaker for you if you were buying the house?

    Or would you reduce the cabinet on the left of the range to 15-18", add another small caibnet to the right of the range to get 45-48" of continuous space right of range, leaving the sink & DW as is? the symmetry would be off in this fashion, but perhaps changing the 30" pullout on the right to a draw base may visually work in the middle of smaller doors.

    Thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    @stacys, you may want to check your local code---I believe ours has minimum counter widths required on either side of a sink that would preclude a layout with the sink right next to the wall. (I'm still learning this stuff, though, so that might not be correct, and it's very possible that it could be California-specific!)

Sponsored
River Mill Construction
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Delaware County's Customer Focused General Contractor