Software
Houzz Logo Print
sonorous

Reseaming Granite Countertop

13 years ago

We had out kitchen island granite installed, but now I am thinking that the seam is a little too dark. I asked if the installers could come back out and lighten color of the seam for me. I thought it would be an easy request to accomodate. But I got an email saying that if they come out and break the seam to create a new one, chipping and cracking could occur, thus making the seam more unsightly.

And it would be difficult to replace the granite (we have a huge island with two large slabs pieced together) if chipping or cracking does occur. I do agree that trying to find a replacement for the granite, should a problem occur, would be another headache we are not willing to endure in this loong kitchen remodel.

Does anyone know what would be involved in changing the color of a seam to lighten it? A DIY website makes it sound so easy: just use sharp razor blades to remove the old seam. Is the granite installer rep just being just unwilling and/or overly cautious? ...for instance, people can and do die in car accidents everyday, but we still all get into our cars and drive daily...

If removing entirely the old seam could be problematic, are there other ways of lightening the seam? Perhaps just removal of part of the seam enough to add a lighter color on top? Or just add a different color to the top of the already existing seam?

Any info or suggestions or even experiences would be greatly appreciated!!

Comments (9)

  • 13 years ago

    We had out kitchen island granite installed, but now I am thinking that the seam is a little too dark.

    Is the seam so bad, so ugly, so conspicuous that half the visitors who walk in shriek "OMG THAT SEAM IS UGLY!", or is is just you who notices it because it's not exactly the seam you envisioned?

    Is getting it fixed is another headache you are willing to endure in this loong kitchen remodel?

  • PRO
    13 years ago

    I am a fabricator.

    I'd suggest to live with it unless you find it really objectionable. It is possible to dig out the top of the seam and backfill with lighter epoxy but some additional chipping is quite possible and you could easily find the lighter color MORE noticable than what you've got.

  • 13 years ago

    I'd learn to live with the 'perhaps a little too dark seam'. We had so many issues with our granite installation(s), that I could only wish that it had only been a little too dark! I understand that when we have put our hearts and souls into a project we are really hoping/expecting that it turns out perfect, but as Lazygardens so aptly put, the risk is not worth the possible benefit, and as oldryder pointed out, it could even end up worse! I am living with a crack in one of our pieces (and we hired a fabricator who did reinstall the whole peninsula to fix a terrible seam and the source/cause of the crack). NO ONE has ever noticed the crack or in fact the HORRIBLE seam, so really the horrible seam couldn't have been all that horrible! LOL

  • 13 years ago

    They dug out my seam. It wasn't that bad. FWIW, I don't think the new seam looks that much better. I think it is hard to match the white in marble sometimes. In the other area where there was a vein, they did a much better job stippling the colors of the seam. But you would have to weight the risk of further damage.

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you everyone for your replies! Like most of you said, I am probably the one who notices it the most. i never even noticed or thought about seams until I started my own kitchen remodeling. So most people don't think about it, unless they know to look for one.

    It's not that terrible. But we did end up having another seam near our cooktop, and that one turned out so well. The color is lighter and a much better match. So I keep thinking about and looking at the other seam.

    I don't want to take any drastic measures, but maybe just taking a bit of the top off like oldryder mentioned and back filling.

    oldryder, is it possible to not take any of the existing epoxy out and just cover the existing seam with a lighter color?

    finestra, so you didn't have any chipping or cracking at the seam when they dug out the seam? how did they dig the seam out?

  • 13 years ago

    There was no chipping or cracking. He used a straight razor blade to scrape it out. He may have only taken off the top layer.

  • 13 years ago

    linelle,

    Of course, you are right, and good on you for not hurting your friend's feelings. But, even when I asked close friends/family who have no problem sharing the 'harsh truth', it turned out they didn't think it was very noticeable. And to tell the truth, 5 years later, it is a total 'non-issue' for me, though I literally lost sleep over it at first!

    I want to caution sonourous that if your particular fabricator is giving you those warnings, I would really hesitate to use them to fix the seam. If he had said, sure, no problem, we'll come in and fix that right away, I'd be more confident. Sounds like finestra may have had someone more experienced with that kind of repair. Just because she had a positive outcome, is no guarantee you would.

  • 13 years ago

    Yes, even if people do notice, most are too polite to say anything...

    The person who said there might be chipping and cracking is not actually the installer, but more of a sales rep I have been speaking with. So I don't know if he really knows first hand what it is all about. The installer who actually came out was pretty good and careful.

    ANd it can be a totally different experience for me, but it is good to know that it doesn't have to be a bad experience either.
    I will speak to the actual installer and hear what he is comfortable with doing. If he is not comfortable with reseaming, I wouldn't pursue it.

    Thanks for the info!

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!