Software
Houzz Logo Print
ojs2005

Help - Am I getting bad advice for my return line?

17 years ago

We just install heat/ac in my house. the first floor all has floor supplies and then 2 returns in the floor by the front door, and all the duct work goes to a furnace room in the basement.

the HVAC the return line is basically open completely into what will be my dropped ceiling for my very large basement (at least 40' long and 15' wide just the hallway). he is telling me that he does not need to connect this metal duct opening that is over the entrance to the furnace room directly to the 2 openings in the floor of my foyer for the air return line to work -- that this air can be pulled through my dropped ceiling into this open hole at the entrance of my furnace room. note that one foyer opening is in the ceiling about 7' away from the ducted return line over my furnace room and the other is in the ceiling about 15' away. s

so basically, this one opening would be sucking air not only indirectly from the floor openings, but also the entire space in my dropped ceiling in the basement -- and i don't understand how we could get proper suction for the first floor (not to mention, we'll be sucking the heat from the basement as well.

this sounds totally wrong to me -- shouldn't there be a metal channel directly connecting these floor returns in my foyer to the machine in the basement? or am i over-reacting? any thoughts would be much appreciated.

thanks.

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    ojs

    the return line has to be connected to the back of the furnace as well as the two floor returns in the foyer. keep in mind, a ductwork system is a closed loop system. it can not be open.

    just curious, where is your filter located to protect your blower motor/evap coil and to help indoor air quality? returns are necessary for good airflow movement and recirculation.

    any idea why the return registers are located next to frt door? it would be preferred that that they be centrally located preferrably in a hallway.

    IMO

  • 17 years ago

    The area above a drop ceiling is often used as a return air plenum.

    It has far less air friction than using ducts.

    You could have a problem regulating how the air returns without some way to restrict flow though.

  • 17 years ago

    wouldn't that area pick up dust and those nasty fibers found in ceiling tiles...sounds like it should be a closed system.

  • 17 years ago

    Brickeye is right that the idea is that the ceiling is used as a return plenum. It's often done in commercial installations.

    The issues I have are:

    1. is the basement heated? If so, the probable air leakage from the basement shouldn't be a problem. If not, it's a problem.

    2. Is the house airtight, particularly around the joist pockets and sill plate? If not, this is a bad idea.

    I don't blame the contractor for not wanting to take apart the ceiling to put in return duct. But using the ceiling for a plenum should only be done if it doesn't create other problems.

  • 17 years ago

    thanks everybody. Seems people may have differing opinions -- here's some more info if it's helpful:

    1. Right now, there is no ceiling up, so nothing needs to be torn down to put in the return duct to the foyers, so that's a non-issue from an installation perspective...i'll be dealing with reinstalling dropped ceiling once everything is done.

    2. the return duct openings are located in our foyer on either side of our front door

    3. The basement is heated, but i can tell you that the ceiling is not the cleanest and there is a lot of debris fromt the construction we just went through

    4. I don't know where the filters for air quality would be...they are on the grills of the returns upstairs, but that doesn't seem to be the plan here...any recommendations?

    5. I'm not exactly sure what a "joist pocket" and "sill plate" is, but I seriously doubt my house is airtight anywhere. it was built in 1904 and we are just now thinking about blowing foam insulation into the walls because of the lack of insulation throughout the house.

    Any further thoughts would be much appreciated. I don't want to create an issue unnecessarily, but this seems like a really important decision.

    THANK YOU

  • 17 years ago

    Are you saying that you have cold air returns cut in the floor ustairs but no ductwork to connect them to the furnace. If I understand you, then where the return duct goes on the furnace what does he have? Did he cut the opening in the furnace so the blower can pull the return air in. tigerdunes is correct. The ductwork should be connected to the furnace. If he is just dropping everthing into the basement then he still has to cut the opening in the bottom of the furnace and put a grill over it to pull the air back to the furnace. If it's done that way it will pull in anything that's in your basement besides the first floor. I believe what they mean by a joist pocket is this. What you can do is some cases is what we call "panning the bay". The joist pocket is the distance between the joist in your basement. For example if the space between two joists is 16"x8" deep, if you attach a piece of sheet metal to the bottom of the joist that will box in the bay and give you a 16x8 trunk line, but it still must be connected to the furnace return section of the furnace in order to work. You should have some type of filter in your unit between the return opening and the blower or they can install a 4" media filter in your return opening on your furnace to take care of all the returns. It's difficult to explain everythng but if you have any more questions I'll try to explain.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you spot09. correct - The machine in the furnace room has a metal duct that cuts through the wall of the furnace room and then is just open on the other side of the wall that is in the hallway of may basement (though it would be above the dropped ceiling)... and then there is nothing between this metal opening above the door, where there would be suction, and the openings in the ceiling (i.e., the floor of my foyer) to pull the air to it -- so it would be pulling all of the air around it....including everywhere in the dropped ceiling. there is no distinct "shaft" for the air between the holes in my floor to the opening of the duct over the wall in my furnace room. seems really weird to me to do it this way....but i'm a first time home owner so what do i know :-)

  • 17 years ago

    Given the info above, I would vote for installing duct work for the returns instead of using the ceiling as a plenum.

    My first concern would be that the ceiling-as-plenum idea would encourage air infiltration. BTW- you may want to consider using E85 spray foam on the entire rim joist/joist pocket/sill plate area before you install that ceiling. (the sill plate is the first piece of wood on top of the foundation. The joists are the beams that support the floor) This area is a source of air gaps that cause a lot of heat loss. See http://www.doityourself.com/stry/airleaksbasement

    It would be much easier to seal this now with the ceiling down than once it's up.

    The filter is going to be near the furnace, not in the grate.

    RE: Insulation in the walls. Just so you know, it's best to insulate first, and then size the furnace /AC properly. Otherwise you end up with equipment that's too large, expensive to run and not as comfortable as you would like.

    Hi density blow-in cellulose in the walls is another option that would be cheaper than foam. It also does a good job at sealing air - although not as good as foam. If you go foam, use the slow-rise closed cell polyurethane type with an R factor of 6-7 per inch. (same stuff as for spraying rim joist area). All of the insulation mentioned qualifies for the 30% tax credit up to $1500 for the property.

    Here is a link that might be useful: E85 DIY spray foam kits

  • 17 years ago

    ojs

    it would seem to me that with your installer's strategy and without any filter protection at the furnace, you will ruin your blower motor and evap coil with all kinds of trash. I hope you have not operated the furnace yet with this type setup. I can not imagine what the installer is thinking. post back if I have misunderstood or if installer actually has some type of filter protection at the back end of the furnace(return area).

    IMO

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you everybody - i'm glad to see i'm not crazy, even though they may think i am. thankfully, the system has not even been tested yet since we're doing this in conjunction with a reno on our first floor that is winding down. i think sometimes people don't like it when homeowners try to think these things through and question what's being offered. all of your input is much appreciated.