Software
Houzz Logo Print
daculaman

HVAC Replacement in Georgia

16 years ago

I presently have a 12 year old contractor grade Comfortmaker split system in my home. Come to find out, it was not correctly installed to begin with. Installer used too small of a lineset for the 4 ton system. Actually "pinched" the lineset attachment point on the unit itself to downsize it to fit the lineset in the home. I have received quotes from two companies. One firm sells Carrier and one sells Trane. Both dealers priced several systems for me and the carrier dealer also priced a dual fuel hybrid heat pump.

I'm trying to decide on the "traditional" A/C-furnace combinations or the Dual Fuel Hybrid. Any input as to which will be the best system over the life of the system?

Carrier Systems:

1. Dual Fuel is an Infinity 19 series 16SEER/13EER/8.8 HSPF, Puron refrigerant two-speed heat pump, 5-ton evap coil. Furnace 135Mbtuh, 80% AFUE, two stage heating, variable speed blower Infinity furnace, infinity control thermostat, 3/8x7/8 refrigerant piping. $10,000. (plus $1,500 tax credit)

2. Infinity 21 series two speed condenser, 4 ton 17SEER/13EER Puron refrigerant, 5-ton evap coil. Furnace 110Mbtuh, 80% AFUE, two stage heating, variable speed blower, Infinity furnace, Infinity control thermostat, 3/8x7/8 refrigerant piping. $9,400. (Plus $1,500 tax credit)

Two other systems including a Comfort 17 series ($8,485.) and Comfort 16 series systems ($7,900) and the tax credits for each.

All Carrier systems include 3/8x7/8 refrigerant piping, equipment pad, removal of old system and cleanup.

Trane

1. XL16i/XV95 system 16SEER two stage a/c, 95% variable speed furnace. Model #'s 47TX6048, 47X00049, T-UH2C100A9v $10,747. ($1,500 tax credit)

2. XR15/XV95 system 15SEER a/c, 95% variable speed furnace. $8,567. ($1,500 tax credit)

3. XR13/XV95 system. 13SEER a/c, 95% variable speed furnace. $8,385. ($1,500 tax credit)

Trane prices also include new refrigerant lines, equipment pad and removal of old system and cleanup.

Trying to decide if I would be happier with a heat pump or "traditional" a/c unit. can you advise as to which units would be most efficient, and provide best comfort?

Comments (4)

  • 16 years ago

    I would ask for more info.
    Ask they Carrier dealer why they haven't quoted a higher efficiency furnace.

    And ask what size furnace you need. They have a larger furnace in #1, and smaller in #2. Is this so that the full systems will be tax credit qualified, (may be needed for the AHRI matchup)

    Ask the Trane dealer why they haven't quoted you a heatpump. Don't they have a heatupum that fits your needs and is tax credit qualified?

    If you need a third option, find a dealer to quote York, as they have a very good number of heatpump matchups that are tax credit qualified.

    This is my personal opinion.

  • 16 years ago

    In a climate like Atlanta you could probably do pretty good with just a straight heatpump. I would go highest efficiency single stage with backup electricity or nat. Gas.

  • 16 years ago

    If you're about to spend that much on HVAC, you might consider a more holistic approach. It isn't that old of a house if the house is 12 years old also, but you maybe could benefit from air sealing or insulation improvements. Think about it, if it saved a 1/2 ton on the sizing and operating costs for the life of the new unit, that'd be decent money. Also, the high-performance replacement system really won't do that well if the house isn't highly efficient (sealed, insulated) too.

    The point behind going dual fuel is to take advantage of the high performance of the HP using relatively inexpensive electricity until it gets colder than the HP will put out enough heat to keep up. Using natural gas as a backup is usually cheaper than electric strips, but you really ought to include all the overhead costs of having a NG account (if you don't otherwise) when you compare the costs.

    We have a dual fuel setup in ATL and have enjoyed it for the past 5 years. The one thing that would be a driver for getting the 2-stage Infinity is the ability to dehumidify w/ the 1st stage in the summer.

    The only other thing I can think of is to make sure that the mfr warranties on all the equipment are comparable. May not be the case for the Infinity, but the Performance series Carrier had different warranty length depending on the specific model the last time I looked.

  • 16 years ago

    daculaman

    unless one is an an all electric situation, I have always thought that for Ga location/climate, an 80% two stg VS furnace paired with a high eff HP was the sweet spot for HVAC.

    However, the majors including both Trane and Carrier force you in certain situations to have a larger evap coil with an oversized 80% furnace to get the tax credit on the outside condenser whether AC or HP. I don't like this.

    What size is your home?

    my suggestion to you is to consider a properly sized 3 stg Infinity 95% furnace-probably the 58MV(B,C)080-20 paired with the matching AC condenser of your choice. This would give you a three stgs of heat with a blower rating to handle a 4 ton condenser.

    I think in your situation that may be a better choice.

    Trane does not offer a smaller furnace with a 4 ton blower rating.

    IMO