Software
Houzz Logo Print
rileysmom17

a washing machine like a Camry

18 years ago

What would be your pick for a washing machine like a Camry? Mid-market, good features but not excessive, 300K if well maintained?

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    The Speed Queen top loader comes to mind.

    Not sure any FLer would meet that very high standard.

    Camry's status is based on a 25 year history, and even they have had their bumps along the way. Only Miele appears to have a similar reputation for longevity, but it's not a mid-market product. When people say that their [INSERT FLer BRAND DU JOUR HERE] has been solid for [INSERT 2 WEEKS to 4 YEARS HERE] it's good information but a long way from being a valid comparison with Camry class reliability and excellence over multiple generations of the product.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd say the Whirlpool, Kenmore, Roper and the recent Maytag direct drive top load washers. These washers have a reputation of being reliable with proven technology.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not sure being compared to a Camry is such a compliment. Have you seen recent issues of Consumer Reports? Toyota vehicles no longer receive automatic "recommended" tags. While I don't doubt the problems various models (including the V6 Camry and the Tundra pickup truck) have been experiencing will be addressed, that's probably cold comfort to the customers who have them.

    I have had several Camrys as rental vehicles and personally didn't care for them (my present favorite is Ford's "new" Taurus). I only wish it were as easy to take washers and dryers for a test spin.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a 99 Camry V6, which I bought on the advice of a mechanic who said it was the cheapest car per mile driven, which thus far has been true. The newer models seem more plasticky. I don't trust Detroit. Back to washers... I want a top loader. Not on the list: Miele, Bosch. I am 'coming down' from a Whirlpool Calypso. It is a little over 4 years old, starting to make various funny noises and strange pauses during some cycles, and I am cutting my losses. No good money after bad. I do want an HE machine without a central agitator. Key desirable feature: the ability to remove dog hair and not send it straight to the pump to clog it. Anything have a cleanable filter?

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think there is enough long-term experience out there for HE TLs. That technology is still fairly new so it is tough to predict durability.
    Stiftung Warentest (the German equivalent to CR) performs long-term test running 1840 cycles on the washers they test. Miele, Bosch/Siemens, AEG and a few others are always doing well on those. Whirlpool is among the good to mediocre ones and Samsung and LG washers had mechanical problems after around 1000 cycles. Sorry, no info about TLs since they are not available in Germany.

  • 18 years ago

    I've read a lot here about removing dog hair and wonder whether anyone has tried simply vacuuming it off (I know it's an extra step; separate discussion on what kind of vacuum to use) before washing. Fortunately our dog's hair (he's a Havanese) seems well attached and responds well to regular grooming.

    Would anyone be more inclined to purchase a washer with, say, a five or ten year warranty? Hyundai and other car brands have tried that in an attempt to increase sales. Perhaps an an appliance maker will someday do it too.

    A used car will almost always be the best bet for overall low cost. I'm not sure that would also be true for a used washer. Does anyone know how German auto testers rate the Camry?

    I do trust Detroit and put my money where my mouth is. I'm at this website to see whether I also trust Benton Harbor.

  • 18 years ago

    Manufacturers just REDUCED warranties from two years to one, and they did this as an entire group, except for Speed Queen which still offer three years.

    Front loaders remain a very expensive way to wash clothes. The idea that the average consumer will save money by purchasing a $1000 FL that only lasts three years without expensive repairs is ridiculous. Energy would have to cost three or four times what it does today.

  • 18 years ago

    curiousshopper,
    sorry for disagreeing with you (again), but your statements are just not true. First off, there are lots of FLs out there which last much longer than three years without expensive repairs. Even if you needed repairs, an extended warranty would cover those and the machines would run for at least 5 years or would have to be replaced. There are lemons among TLs as well and spending just $400 or $500 on a washer doesn't protect you from mechanical failures. Our cheap TL needed a new pump after three years of usage. Then figure in the cost for new clothes because some items got destroyed by the agitator...

    At the current energy and water rate I am saving at least $15-20 per month in water, energy and detergent costs compared to using a traditional TL. After three years, that would make up the difference in cost between a TL and FL. But even without any savings I'd much prefer a FL over a TL. It cleans better and gentler.
    Besides, try telling people who live in drought areas like NC that it isn't worth saving water! What do you think happens to the water prices if whole states had to buy pottable water???

    The HE TLs are probably a good compromise if you can't or don't want to go with a FL. They do cost about the same as a FL though and so far it looks as if they have at least as many mechanical problems as some FLs.