Cabinet paint - laquer or enamel?

14 years ago

My apologies, I've gotta think this topic has been discussed several times before but I can't seem to find the right thread!

After spending some time researching between oil based and water based paint, I told my painter that I want to go with the new BM water based paint when he sprays the cabinets in two weeks. My cabinet maker threw me and recommended strongly that my painter use pre-catalyzed laquer (ML Campbell). His reasoning was that the laquer is much more durable, easier to apply (short dry time), and can be easily touched up by using laquer thinner to 'melt' the existing laquer to smooth over scratches/scuffs. I've seen the finish, and it does appear to be highly smooth and tough.

However, all the painted kitchens I've been tracking on GW I've noticed are using an oil or water based paint. So what's the real GW recommendation here?? Please help educate me as to why I don't want laquer finish? Many thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

beekeeperswife
14 years ago
When we painted our existing cabinets, I went with BM oil based paint. Satin Impervo Low Lustre paint.

However, the 2 cabinetmakers we have just dealt with on our new build use the catalyzed laquer. They both agree it gives the best finish and the strongest. Something about it bonding better?

YOu should post this question on the paint forum-you will get lots of technical answers there
CEFreeman
14 years ago
I'm a believer in Cabinet Coat.
It's an Insel-X product that is made for trim and woodwork. It's said to be a huge % more hard and durable.

I painted my cabinets with it and it's beautiful. It goes on like butter!

BM bought the company.

Christine
Related Professionals
Gainesville Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · West Plains Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Atlantic City Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Roanoke Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · South Bend Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Palm Bay Kitchen Remodelers · Bainbridge Kitchen Remodelers · Cincinnati Kitchen Remodelers · Lawton Kitchen Remodelers · Cedar Rapids Kitchen Remodelers · Boise Kitchen Remodelers · Pullman Kitchen Remodelers · Little Rock Custom Countertops · Mesquite Custom Countertops · Boise Custom Countertops
_justin_
14 years ago
All oil based paint will yellow with time. Don't use it if you want white cabinets. Water based paint will not change color over time but will not lay down as smooth. My testing found the best water based paint for doors and trim is is Muralo Ultra satin with 5% XIM extender added to it to slow down dry time and allow better leveling. I liked it a lot better than Ben Moore Aura with the Aura extender as it went down smoother.

My white cabinets were sprayed with Sherwin Williams conversion varnish which is one of the most common cabinet finishes. They look great and are smooth as glass and clean easily, even beet juice. I think the pre-cat lacquer is probably a great way to go. I'm not familiar with it but ML Campbell is well respected. Make sure it can tolerate alcohol and common kitchen chemicals, doesn't yellow with time, and is tolerant of moisture. I've had the conversion varnish bubble when pooled water was left on for several days, fortunately is was under the sink and won't be seen. A call to the finish manufacturer should straighten out concerns that your painter can't answer.
mobydog
14 years ago
I have been researching cabinets. All the cabinet manufacturers for painted cabinets seem to use the pre-catalyzed laquer for the durability and application of the finish.