Software
Houzz Logo Print
carriem25

The re-upholstery project - continued

14 years ago

I have picked some potential upholstery fabrics to redo my Morris-style chair and comfortable rocker. I also bought a new rug, and the consensus (from friends/relatives after a going-away party on the weekend) is that it stays!

The new rug:

The potential fabrics on the backs of the chairs, the rug in front:

Close up of Fabric 1 and 2:

Close up of Fabric 3 and 4:

My thoughts:

I love Fabric 1 (the blue-grey chevron chenille) - it is so soft and cozy. But my mom wasn't crazy about it, and said the colour is actually too close of a match to the rug and doesn't provide enough contrast. I also like Fabric 4. It photographed a little oddly, and is actually a tone on tone chenille with very little contrast in the pattern. I liked it because it was very neutral and will stand up to future redecorating. I'm a bit meh on Fabric 2 (dots) but I do like #3 (stripes).

Could someone please weigh in and send me in the right direction?

Thanks,

Carrie

Comments (15)

  • 14 years ago

    Would the rest of your decor work with using a different fabric for each chair? If so, I like #3 for the Morris-style chair (stripes replicate the vertical lines of the chair arms) and #4 for the rocker.

  • 14 years ago

    Drape or pin the samples to the front bottom of the chairs; the part that will be closest to the rug. It's hard to picture the samples with the current fabric competing.

  • 14 years ago

    I truly don't care for any of them with the rug - the first three have the same fine-lined scale as the rug - the fourth, the beige floral, doesn't have enough color contrast. They all look like background elements and you can't have everything be background.

    Maybe a deep solid fabric, with some richly patterned throw pillows? That would work well with your Craftsman-style chairs and the bay window.

  • 14 years ago

    I love #1. I very much like upholstering with chenille.
    I also like the stripe, but don't recommend stripes,
    unless you have a lot of upholstering experience.
    Stripes are not the least bit forgiving as far as getting everything
    to line up perfectly and match. Wavey lines look awful.

    good luck with the project.
    break up all the grey with nice sewn throw pillows
    on the back of your chairs...

    signed, pillow ma! :)

  • 14 years ago

    I also love # 1, and think it would look great, IMHO. #2 does nothing for me, and #3 is also nice, but stripes ARE hard to work with. If itâÂÂs going to be professionally reupholstered, then #3 would be my 2nd choice. I donâÂÂt care for #4 at all.

  • 14 years ago

    I'm going to side with bird gardener and throw in a vote for a rich solid, using your fabric selections for throw pillows. Right now if the rug is staying - the fabrics just don't hold their own, though I think they're great for a different application.

  • 14 years ago

    I do like the black and white pillow on the love seat in pic #1! that's a keeper!

  • 14 years ago

    I agree with your Mom, that one is too much like the rug. I also think a solid color with accent pillows. Are you going to do both chairs in the same fabric? I would like to see the Morris chair in a golden color and the soft chair in a pale blue.

  • 14 years ago

    I like the existing chairs - the hex shapes repeat the rug shapes, but the colors are more intense.

  • 14 years ago

    I took gracie's advice and have some new pictures.

    Fabric 1

    Fabric 3 (I didn't take a picture of the dot fabric)

    Fabric 4 (Less contrast in pattern on this photo)

    I didn't think about having the chairs different. They have to be side by side because of the layout of the room. Here is a very old picture from when we first moved in - only the couch, loveseat, chairs and big tv remain the same, LOL.


    My sense of symmetry can't seem to get past the chairs matching! Would they look okay not matching?

    The "black and white" pillow must stay, LOL. She is part of the reason that I picked that particular rug - the pattern is subtle when viewed as a whole, but variegated enough to hide the hair. I also have two teenagers, and this is our main living area that gets everyday use (and abuse!)

    lazygardens - unfortunately, the old fabric has to go. The chairs were recovered about 8 years ago, but they weren't adequately repadded at the time, and there are lots of pokey bits that are making the chairs uncomfortable. They are many-times handed-downs from dh's family, and we are sentimentally attached to them. I am planning on having them professional upholstered.

    If you aren't crazy about the fabrics, please, please please post a link to something you think would be better! I'm really looking for help!

    Thanks,
    Carrie

  • 14 years ago

    I absolutely love your rug!

    I don't know, but I'm just not feeling those fabrics. Maybe something with a bigger pattern?

    Like this: (click on the swatch for a bigger pic)

    http://www.fabricguru.com/p-robert-allen/lanes-tapestry-upholstery-fabric-spruce

    or this

    http://www.fabricguru.com/p-american-decorative-fabrics/tapestry-upholstery-fabric-blue-opal

  • 14 years ago

    Hi there. I love your rug. I think the first two fabrics coordinate especially well with it, tho perhaps they are a little tame. but perhaps you wanted to tone things down?

    I think its interesting that you are getting rid of the hexagon fabric and you bought a hexagon rug.

    I'm looking at upholstery posts because I'm about to reupholster a chair too.

    Kathy

  • 14 years ago

    I would do matching... and I adore the tone-on-tone chenille! Then I would do fun, mix and match pillows to really pick up the rug colors.

  • 14 years ago

    Most Morris chairs were leather. Since you already have leather, my suggestion is something solid with perhaps a cording in leather. A small print darker rather than lighter feels appropriate. Love Morris chairs and know how one can be attached to them.

  • 14 years ago

    I love the first fabric but I think your mother is right. It's matches the rug a little too well. I also wouldn't do them matching but that's just me; too many fabrics, too little furniture to cover lol. I LOVE both chairs and can't wait to see them finished. I would never have the nerve to attempt such a project.