Kiley I think it's size is jut fine for the area you have. I like the idea that it's square too.

I was going to suggest a wider frame but I'm not sure there's room. Have you checked that there's enough room for the framed mirror once it's mounted? (I can just barely make out the light fixture above the sink.)

hmmm...I think it looks a little too big. It looks like you have a smaller light bar.... i think it's the shape of the mirror. However, i don't think it would look that bad. If it bugs you i would change it. Have you considered or looked around for any oval type mirrors?

I think it should be a little wider or perhaps like Meg suggested, a wider frame. I know your hubby wants plain, but it could use just a little beefing up I think.

i think it looks fine. In Lowes they have these kits you can buy to frame the mirror. It comes in beveled glass, and different colored woods. The corner pieces are sold seperately. It really dresses a mirror up and would be a nice accent fror your mirror

Good Luck

Here is a link that might be useful: wood trim kit

Msjay: I have never heard of that before. I wish I would of known about that in my last house. Next time I know!

Its something new. I go to Lowes and Home Depot about 2-3 times a week if for nothing else but to browse and I only saw it recently in Lowes. Never in Home Depot. The mirrored ones look really nice!