Software
Houzz Logo Print
gone_fishing90

First design...Lowes - KM...comparable questions

16 years ago

So my wife and I had some time this weekend. We spent a morning with a Lowes designer to get an idea of our kitchen budget. The lady was very nice and did a good job for us. We picked out KM Wickstrom Maple Square. Her layout and ideas matched what we wanted. Anyway, she said we picked out one of the least expensive door designs. We did get some upgrades as far as 40" wall cabinets...full sized pantry, pots/pans drawers, crown, bottom trim, etc. Our estimate was $9609.10 with tax/delivery.

My question is, how would KM pricing compare to other options out there?

Comments (10)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lowe's and HD are running specials, although Lowe's expired
    sunday. But I think you can get Lowe's to match HD's discount which is still going on. Based on the amount that you are spending, your discount would be $1200. Ask for it.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Just went thru this at the big box stores. I priced Kraftmaid Piermont & Englewood doors at Home Depot, and Thomasville Camden door- Home Depot vs Diamond (same as Thomasville) Caldwell at Lowe's. Also Dynasty at a private supplier.

    Dynasty - most expensive
    Kraftmaid-medium
    Thomasville/Diamond - less

    The big box store pricing included some pretty agressive year-end promotions. I ended up going with Kraftmaid because of more flexible size options and a problem with appliance panel sizing, plus I just loved the ginger sable glaze :)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If your design is already in her system, she can price out other cab makers Lowe's carries. We were surprised that our design came in less for Schuler (Medallion) than KM. Also, make sure you are clear if your door style is full overlay or not - depending on what you want.

    We liked our gal at Lowe's also, but we are still looking around.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here's our game plan...we will continue to save money and aim for a summer renovation. During the next few months we'll check out Brookhaven brand, HD, and a few other local places. This will give us a good feel for what we want to do and actual cost. Once we have that we'll keep an eye on HD/Lowes for another sale like this one.

    Thanks!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    also, i would check out if your door design center panel is veneer...and decide if that matters or not to you.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The doors we picked do have veneer panels...Is that bad?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Veneer center panels are not bad. The best way to keep them from warping is to use plywood with a veneer. It's also less expensive.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There are discount coupons to be had on EBAY for the big box stores. It saved us a lot of money...

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We also have spent extensive time with a KD at Lowes. Chose Wickstrom maple with the upgraded all-plywood box - and not too many bells and whistles (trying to keep a lid on the budget). The first bid came in at $15k. Then we did some research with KraftMaid (the Wickstrom door is probably the cheapest Maple style they have) - and found out that the flat panel door styles are all veneer. So we stepped back (because we DO NOT want veneer) in our kitchen. We built our home 20 years ago and went with a lower quality cabinet (Starmark brand) (a trade-off with wood floors throughout the first floor...) and the issues we're having with the finish around the sink area and where the UV hits the cabinets - as well as the quality of the finish itself has made us determined to go higher quality this time around. The second quote with a solid wood raised panel Maple (Portsmith) went to about 20k. They are running a promo now that 'discounts' the 20k by $3500 - so it's a decent savings. But then I started to do research on the quality of the finish - because I was starting to notice some 'issues' on the display kitchens with KraftMaid at Lowes as well as the sample doors they had in their door-style displays. Our builder pointed out that when finish is sprayed on a door - and then, over time, the middle panel 'shrinks' - you get a raw wood reveal of about 1/8 to 1/4 inch all around the perimeter of the middle panel. We went back and looked at the door-style display area of KraftMaid, particularly for the Maple styles (which we're pretty locked into) and yup there it was - plus my husband did a quality comparison on the cabinets in the display area and in the door-style areas for KraftMaid, Diamond, and Schuler. So now, we're seriously considering going with Schuler - because, by his determination, the finish was MUCH better than KraftMaid. Plus at my last meeting with the KD at Lowes (we've spent a total of about 8 hours with her - and she has been GREAT - no complaints there) - she was the one who cautioned me that when the cabinets arrive on site - it will be easy to start 'nit-picking' the finish and then she pointed out some finish 'issues' with KraftMaid on their displays - issues which she said were 'acceptable' finish issues - like two cabinet doors on a 30-36" box being completely different colors - because, she said, the wood absorbs the stain differently - and that got me thinking that if the KD was already making excuses for things that I did not think were 'nitpicky' but really, major issues, (I do not a crazy quilt look to a wall cabinets that should look uniformly the same color) - KraftMaid was probably NOT a good choice. This will be the only (and last) time I redo this kitchen - it needs to last AT LEAST another 20 years - and we're putting a big investment, not only into the cabinets, but into appliances, granite countertops, electrical rewiring, and floor refinish (wood oak floors). I do not want to hassle with a cabinet company about crappy final finish - seriously - I'm just not going to do it - I'll send the whole lot back before I go there. I just don't even want to anticipate that this will be an issue. So, I know the KD at Lowes is not going to be happy - but we're going to ask her to redo the entire design with Schuler. I'm sure it's going to be 20-25k before the promo discount they're running now - but my sanity and time are worth it. (My kitchen is about 13'7" north wall, and an 11' east wall and an 11' foot west wall - with the south being totally open to the rest of the house - so we have cabinets on 3 sides and a 6' x 2' island in the middle.) For us, all plywood construction on the boxes is mandatory - all solid wood on the doors mandatory as well. If anyone out there knows of a comparison matrix for the major cabinetry companies - it would be a vast help - as a purchase of this magnitude (these KDs act like spending 20k is an everyday occurrence for the average homeowner - NOT). You would think these cabinet companies would be offering major incentives to get your business - like free hardware or free glazing or free speciality finishes - but nada. The other thing is that we can't start the demolition and rebuilding of the kitchen without the cabinets being delivered (I refuse to be 'down' in my kitchen for any longer than necessary - so no one is raising a hammer until the cabinets arrive on site). So, the cabinet choice is the hinge that everything swings on - but it's really a LOT of legwork that the consumer has to do themselves researching the quality of cabinets and what fits their budget and goals for their kitchen. This isn't a fix-and-flip project for us. This our house and our home for a long while more. The decision is important. I'm not redo-ing this kitchen ever again.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I sell both KM and Medallion (Schuler) and Medallion is nicer. Also, if you price apples-for-apples, Medallion's Brookhill door should be about the same (or less!!!) than KM's equivalent (solid raised panel) doorstyle.

    I have a small kitchen layout that I use to price out my cabinet lines....to help me see what the best value is for my clients.

    $3885 - KM solid maple, raised panel door w/ 5 piece drawer head in standard construction

    $3577 - Medallion solid maple, raised panel door w/ 5 piece drawer head in standard construction

    So you might pleasantly surprised! KM's higher end, solid doors aren't as competitive as their lower and middle priced doors.

    I'm not saying that ALL of Medallions doors are going to be less...I've just found the Brookhill door to be less than KM

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!