Software
Houzz Logo Print
bellsrus_gw

kitchen island dilemma

18 years ago

Ok - I need help with a decision about my island. When we first started thinking about building a house, I made a list of things I wanted to have in my kitchen. One of those top priority things was to have a very large island with no sinks, cooktops or anything else in it.

When our KD came up with his design, he made the island 2 levels. The angle on this photo is skewed so the near cabinets don't look right, but it should give a good idea of the island shape and size. {{!gwi}}

The island is about 18" deep on each level, for a total width of about 36". The island length (if I remember correctly) is about 84" long. The lower level is 30" high, the upper level is 36" high (regular counter height).

So, for those of you who have used a 2-height island, do you like it? Would you prefer a flat surface? I do a lot of baking and wanted the island for baking pans and cooling racks. I will probably use my stand mixer on the lower side of the island and for rolling out dough.

Help please!

Thanks!

Patti

In case I did the photo incorrectly, here is the link to my blog with photos of the kitchen design...

Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen design with photos

Comments (12)

  • 18 years ago

    One question that I want to ask... how tall are you? I am 5' tall and much prefer a 30" height island for prep. When I redo my next home, I plan on a LARGE island where at least part of it will be 30" high for prep, baking, and whatnot. I will also have a 30" to allow for informal seating but at standard table height.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm actually 5'5" so standard counter height works fine for me.

  • 18 years ago

    Patti, in my last kitchen, I had a long island and ended up very frustrated at having to walk all the way around it, back & forth, as I was working in there. My sis had a long one,and ended up hating hers, too. If I had a huge kitchen, I might have opted for two smaller islands with a walkway between them for this reno. But I don't, so I went with a peninsula instead. Just more food for thought.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with the above post. It doesn't look user-friendly.

  • 18 years ago

    What's the 30" high side for? If for baking and prepping, for me at just under 5'4", that's too low. I prefer about 33".

    The other problem is in having 2 heights on this particular island makes both sides about worthless. The idea of an island, usually, is to have a deeper, broader space on which to work. Usually if you want to roll out cinnamon rolls, larger batches of cookies, etc. a regular 24" counter can be limiting...18" is obviously worse. Also having a work island means people can gather around and work together from different sides. Not with yours, though.

    Your original plan to have a clear, level island was a good one. I'd go back to that. But do make sure it isn't a thorn in your side by being between you and everything you want to get to. It's not bad to walk past it, but you don't want to have to constantly maneuver around it or walk in circles to accomplish tasks in your kitchen. It looks like it might be a problem to get to the fridge when working at the range.

  • 18 years ago

    Totally agree with rhome410 on all counts, especially that 18" is not deep enough for serious dough work, go with one height - it's much more flexible.

  • 18 years ago

    I went with one large one surface with nothing in it as well - we're just over 6x3. I wanted it for not only prepping large amounts and resting out cookies and having a good space for lots of helpers, but also when we're serving buffet style it will work and also when the kids need to have a large work surface for projects etc. But mostly, I wanted it to use to wrap christmas presents.

    So think LONG and hard about what you're going to use the space for and then decide. don't let a KD talk you out of something or into something that just won't work for your life.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a 3 level island. We have a 42" high by 18" deep by 8' long section that backs up to a 36" high by 31" (not sure how that happened!) deep by 8' long section. These 2 sections form a rectangle 8' long and 4'1" wide. At one end we have an 30" high table section that is rounded on the outer side. This makes the island 12' long. It turned my kitchen into a galley shape which is great for me. The 42" high part is seating - mostly for DH and his laptop. I did not want that height but he did so we did it. I never use it as it is hard for me to climb onto the barstool and uncomfortable once I am there. The 18" deep would never do for any kind of prep or dough rolling. On the prep side (31" deep) I left an opening under the counter so I can slide a stool under. I can stand or sit to prep or roll or chat with DH. I am 5'4" and this height works great for me. When I roll out bannock or other doughs I need every bit of the 31" deep. I have an undermount sink on the prep side which makes clean-up a breeze. The 30" high table section is for the grands when they are here. I have found it to be very handy for wrapping gifts and cutting shelf paper and it makes a great desk for me.
    My next island will be 2 heights - one very large and wide 36" high section with sink and one table height section at the end.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the advice, everyone!

    I've been seriously thinking about sticking with my original plan to have one flat surface and you've about convinced me I was right in the first place.

    Also, I don't think having the island between the refrig and the stove will be a big deal for me. I tend to get all my ingredients out before I start cooking or baking and in this kitchen all the ingredients (from refrig or pantry) will end up on the island. I will either use them on the island if I'm baking, or at the cooktop if I'm making dinner. On the rare occasion when I forget to grab an ingredient, it shouldn't be a big deal to go around the island to get it, but thanks to those who brought up the potential problem.

  • 18 years ago

    Patti, looks like you already got your answer. I just wanted to chime in -- just in case :-). Two-level islands like the one you had are typically used as a prep/bar seating area. Since your island has a refrigerator on the other side, and no planned seating, the taller portion would be worthless. I think in that kitchen plan, flat single level would work better.

  • 18 years ago

    shawneeks - thank you so much for sharing the picture of your kitchen. I really love it. It is very close to the look we're going for. Would you mind sharing the stain on your cabinetry and the dimensions of your island?

    It just looks like such a nice warm kitchen!

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner