Software
Houzz Logo Print
charlieinnj

Interior paints reviewed by Consumer reports

16 years ago

Passing this info along since so many of us are always debating painting, etc. I have to admit that although I use it a lot, I've never ben a big fan of Behr's paint. But I've recently began using their new "Ultra" and I've found it impressive. Apparently so did Consumer Reports because they rated it as the best performing paint in their recent reviews of interior paint.

-----------------------------------------------------------

Consumer Reports' March issue features the biggest interior paint test ever of more than 50 paints. For the first time, Consumer Reports found nearly all top-scoring

paints to be among the lowest in volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are linked to pollution, smog, and respiratory problems.

Nearly all the top-scoring paints in Consumer Reports' tests contain no more than 50 grams of volatile organic compound per liter, a fraction ofthe 380 grams once common in the most-used low-luster paints.

Greener paints are becoming more popular and can mean less work -- paints that scored Very Good or Excellent in Consumer Reports' hiding tests provided thorough coverage with just one coat, something only two low-VOC paints managed in the last round of tests. But Consumer Reports notes that low-VOC paints aren't necessarily odorless, so consumers should plan on adequate ventilation.

"Paints have advanced in their ability to perform and be green," said Bob Markovich, senior home editor for Consumer Reports. "Our tests demonstrate that painting no longer needs to be expensive and time consuming as long as the consumer invests in the correct paint for their

project."

Consumer Reports' scrubbing, staining, and mildew tests put Home Depot's Behr brand the top performer in all three categories: low-luster, flat and matte finishes, and semigloss. Behr Premium Plus Ultra ($33), showed impressive one-coat hiding, stain resistance and other strengths, making it Consumer Reports' top paint overall.

Low-luster and semigloss versions of Kilz Casual Colors ($22, Walmart) are formulated for indoor and outdoor use. Both versions did well at hiding during tests and evaluations will be done on their outdoor performance

soon. Consumers who are willing to shell out up to $45 per gallon for maximum fade resistance for a sunny room can consider Benjamin Moore Regal. But tests show little reason to consider others in that price range.

But Consumer Reports recommends that consumers proceed with caution when purchasing green paints. Freshaire Choice ($39, Home Depot) and Mythic ($48) claim to have zero VOCs and to be as durable and cover as well as

top-quality paint, but Mythic was mediocre at hiding and Freshaire Choice scored no better than Fair.

Don't buy strictly by brand. Several Dutch Boy and Sherwin-Williams paints wound up near the bottom of Consumer Reports Ratings, despite being industry icons. And because manufacturers frequently tweak formulas to improve performance, cut costs, and comply with tougher

regulations, the paint consumers loved last time might not perform as well this time around.

Comments (8)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's fortunate that you posted here instead of on the Paint forum. *eyes rolling* (not at you, lol)

    You'll still get a heated debate, here, but nothing like you would over there.

    I've got a sample of their Maple Glaze that seems to be a dead ringer, colorwise, to a paint that FC recommended for my office.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    LOL....I know people will always have strong opinions and that's fine. My experience with their new paint has been with painting my Living room with their 'ultra' paint. I'm painting a medium brown color on the walls and I did the entire room in two coats. I was planning on painting the celing in the room the same color and after the fact, the HD person had mixed the gallon in Behr's standard stuff. I ended up using the entire gallon on just the celing and had to do three coats. So to me, I definitely noticed the difference in how the two paints cover.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Love it. Thanks for posting this and I agree with Parma this will be a hot thread no doubt!

    I have to say I agree with the article and have for some time now. I was a big BM purchaser for many years but not any more there prices are unwarrented beyond words. I will say no one formulates colors like BM - my whole house is BM colors but that is the extent of it. I have gotten great quality, durabilty and coverage with Behr and I find that BM paint is alot of 'hype'. Even if it were better then Behr it is for sure not almost double the price better..heck its just paint! But it is a personal choice to what someone wants to buy and what price point so to each their own. I am glad that alot of other paint brands are starting to step up their game.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I look at all of the old cans of Behr paint lining my shelves before I knew that anything else existed. There are no new cans.

    I guess despite how bad you may have thought something was you should try it again later on in case there are improvements.

    But then I go back to my basement, look at all of those Behr cans and think 'Nah - I'll stick w/ what I know to have been working well for me for the past few yrs.'.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm not a SW person but saying SW and Dutch Boy are "icons", umm, SW I'll give you, Dutch Boy, eh, not so much.

    In addition to BM, I have tried P&L (hated it), F&B (liked it, but not an additional $30/gal worth of like) and C2 (liked it a lot), but I keep going back to BM Aura, I am flat out impressed with the self leveling aspect and the fact that you can recoat in an hour (and when the woodstove is cranking, it's dry in *minutes*, not that I recoat that soon, but I think you could). My dad had a painting biz, and he would only use BM, so I think part of my prejudice is being loyal to his memory and part convenience, living in the boonies, BM is the closest place to buy real paint.

    Thanks to charlieinnj for posting the article.

    sandyponder

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think Consumer's Reports has rather different standards than do we enthused decorators. To be honest, scrubbing, staining, and mildew aren't my top three considerations.

    Fine Paints of Europe is the best paint I've ever used, and BM comes pretty close.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Last time I repainted the interior of my home (too many years ago to admit after seeing the frequency of paint re-do posted here :-)I consulted consumer reports to find the best paint. They raved about and recommended Lowe's brand (is that Behr?) so I drove to the nearest one (30 miles) to buy it. It was horrible, horrible, horrible to paint with - thin, runny, didn't cover, etc. I haven't repainted, not because it has held up so wonderfully, but because I was so traumatized by the experience. I'll never listen to CR again for paint recommendations as they obviously have different standards. I'm going to listen to the folks here, most of whom I think have similar expectations as me.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Olychic, Lowes sells Valspar, Behr is at HD.

    I used a custom colored Behr in the two-story LR and kitchen in our old house. We lived there for seven years and before we put it up for sale, we had all the walls washed. Cleaned up beautifully and looked brand new. We were on a budget and it suited our purposes well. We had light coming in from all angles and, in a situation like that, maybe the full spectrums aren't as important as they would be in a room with one directional light.

    I used C2 in the main bath and loved it, Ralph Lauren suede in the MB and got so many compliments. Powder room had a short lived line from Lynette Jennings (don't recall who made the base). Her palette was just lovely. I think the color was Thyme and I sure liked it better than the Svelte Sage I have in the hall bath now.

    There's a paint for every budget and expectation.