Software
Houzz Logo Print
funkyart_gw

Spanning Styles - Is this too cottagey?

13 years ago

My plan for the new, smaller circa 1960s ranch house was to embrace it's era and best use the space by combining my existing traditional and somewhat euro cottage pieces with a few well placed, well selected MCM pieces. It hasn't really worked out that way. The MCM pieces I am drawn to are just way out of budget right now.

The house itself isn't too MCM other than in scale and size so I'll likely drop the MCM component until I see a piece I love and can't live without and then work with that.

So my real dilemma is that I find that *I* am leaning more cottage than I'd expected to. I think the cottage look is very comfortable and pleasing and it surely fits my lifestyle.. but I don't want too "cute" or "precious" a look and I fear is that in a small home it will quickly go that direction. I feel that I need to constantly reel myself back in and edit, edit, edit.

So here's where you come in.. I am charmed by this table and chairs. The price is very good and the size is perfect for my dining area (which will also get a loveseat or sofa). I have not seen it in person but I talked to the store owner this morning who said the chairs are a cream with a faint hint of yellow.. and she loves it and wanted to put it in her home (of course, I wouldn't doubt that they say that about all their pieces).

It is clearly a cottage look-- and it will be in a room adjoining both the kitchen and the living room. Is this going to influence the overall vibe of the house too much?

Comments (27)

  • 13 years ago

    I need to ask you to use your imagination here.. this is an old photo and I won't have new ones until the painters are done next week.

    My grandmother's table/chairs are gone.. the carpet has been lifted to reveal basic orangey oak wood floors. Curtains will be replaced with fabric blinds. Loveseat or sofa is planned for under the windows on the far wall.

  • 13 years ago

    I find cottage style to be warm and welcoming. I like it best when it is done in a rather spare fashion and with bright colors, but that's just me. I like the table you posted. I'm not as much a fan of the Windsor chairs, but again that's my personal preference. Because of their turned stretchers and legs, they read too country for my taste.

    This post was edited by Fun2BHere on Tue, Feb 26, 13 at 10:53

  • 13 years ago

    Fun2BHere, I think you hit on what I wasn't saying well. I want to bring in the cottage look sparingly. I hadn't picked up on the country look until you mentioned it.. and no, that's not where I want to go.

    Back to the drawing board.

    Here's another table I've eyed for years. I am not so much a fan of the shaker style but I think it blends well with other styles. I'd pair it with either painted or slipcovered chairs. It is substantially more money but it is handmade. (It's cheaper if I get a painted base vs. tiger maple)

    What do you think.. would it balance well with cottagey chairs?

  • 13 years ago

    I agree with Fun2BeHere.

    Of the two, I would have kept Grandma's furniture and painted it.

  • 13 years ago

    I love the new set you have your eye's on. For one thing, they're very nice and a good color, plus because of the style of the chairs they will make the room appear larger and airier. Is that a word? :)

  • 13 years ago

    The tiger maple table looks like you can take it in a bunch of different directions depending on the chairs you choose. If you intend to eventually end up with MCM, though, I would probably look for a teak table. Most of the MCM-style teak tables have simple lines that can work with different chair styles until you can buy the MCM chairs you really want.

  • 13 years ago

    Yes, my thinking with the tiger maple is that it can go many directions but that it is handsome enough to keep the look from going too precious.

    If/when I do go MCM, I will go with the Matthew Hilton extension table. I absolutely drool over that table (below).

    I think I need to cool my heels. Budget dictates that a CL or consignment store table is preferable. If I just don't find what I want, I'll spend the bucks but I am not ready to jump on a 2k table just yet.

  • 13 years ago

    Good lord.. I just sat back and looked at the three tables I linked. I am schizophrenic!

    The truth is, they all appeal to me-- especially the last two. I need to spend more time on houzz and the blogs to see how others are marrying their schizophrenic styles.

  • 13 years ago

    I think the tiger maple shaker table will work with a lot. Traditionally, tables like this were put with chairs we would consider "cottagy" now. GreatWindsor has a section of "Cottage Furniture", actually. You would see it with shaker chairs, or perhaps even Windsor chairs.

    This table would also actually work with modern chairs. They also offer it in cherry, I think, if you are afraid of working with the tiger maple.

    The Matthew Hilton table on the other hand, will only work with a handful of chairs, all modernist, because it has a very insistent shape.

  • 13 years ago

    I think you need to back up a little and think about what the three design patterns (cottage, Shaker, and MCM) have in common.

    I suspect that what you want is the warmth and familiarity of the cottage style, and the more streamlined, unfussy quality of both Shaker and MCM designs. The most obvious common threads are utility and simplicity.

    What if you started this process by keeping your traditional furniture, but editing out the patterns that say cottage - replace printed fabrics with simple cottons and linens in solid colors, remove things that are unnecessarily shapely or decorated with motifs, stick with useful things that are plain and functional, take away anything that you chose to amplify the cottage theme, and leave materials and surfaces bare where you can.

    Then see what you have, what you still want to keep, and what you feel the need to replace.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks, Pal.. The MH table doesn't really work for my space... style or size. Still. I love it. I've returned to that shaker table so many times over the last 10 yr. I should take that as a sign.

    If I buy this table, I'll need to wait on chairs-- but what kind of modern chair are you picturing? A modern spindle chair?

    Should I be afraid of working with the tiger maple? It's definitely my preference over the cherry. I know it is busy but there isn't room for other pieces so it would be pretty much the only "movement" in the room other than textiles.

    I was surprised when Great Windsor added a cottage line. I don't care for the tables or the paint technique. What really surprised me were the newest styles of tables-- large and chunky echoing RH. I suspect they're struggling.

  • 13 years ago

    Bronwyn, you hit the nail on the head. I love the sleek, simple and functional pieces--and I think they are especially sexy in warm wood grains. I also love the easy going and cozy look of layers fabrics and objects. I prefer burlaps, linens and velvets to cottage patterns-- but I prefer them in the muted cottage color palette. This has remained steady for years.. I just get confused when trying to bring it all together without looking like it's a garage sale! :)

    I have cottage textiles to edit out-- I never went full on with the cottage florals. I will keep the rugs (traditional) for now and while I do have a few semi-cottagey quilts, and duvets, I don't think they pose a problem. My throw pillows aren't cottagey but they are tired so I'll be replacing them. I guess I am not in such a bad starting place as long as I keep my focus.

    The big, looming issue is... I gave my dining room table to my nephew so I don't even have something to use "for now". I've been looking on CL for months and just have not found anything that I like.

  • 13 years ago

    I keep failing to thank you all.. I appreciate your generous suggestions and patience!!

  • 13 years ago

    Have a look at some of the
    "Modern Cottage Style" Google images to find what appeals to you.

    The book "New Cottage Style" may be worth studying as well.

    IMO MCM is not easy to mix with other styles, especially Cottage.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks, Luckygal! I have done many searches-- but loved going through them again. In fact, I have the New Cottage Style LR photo saved in my inspiration folder. LOVE it.

    I am trying to find a cheap but nice table and chairs and shoe horn it into my vision. It's causing me more frustration than needed.

  • 13 years ago

    This is what I would like to do in my own house, but this table is just too small for us:


    ($199 from Ikea)

    and pair it with Danish modern chairs that come up on CL . . .sometimes you can get some real deals (once I saw 6 for $200).

    {{!gwi}}

    (3/$150)

    Inspiration pic:
    {{!gwi}} I like the inspiration chairs a lot more . . .

  • 13 years ago

    Oh, oops . . .now I am reading more carefully . . .
    one of my other ideas for my own kitchen is to pair an old (antique) pedestal table w/modern chairs, preferably MCM vibe. Not made out of wood. Would that work?

  • 13 years ago

    Hi Anele! I like those inspiration chairs too.. and I'd originally been looking for a great old antique/vintage pedestal table (I'd still prefer one) but while there are a ton of heavy oak pedestal tables on CL around here-- most are low quality, new construction. I just don't like them and I don't want anything so big and visually heavy.

    I have seen some great rooms done around those tulip tables but something about them doesn't work for me. I think they may be too cold. It may be that I end up picking one up though until I get a real table. It could easily move into one of the two offices or the basement once I buy another... or who knows, perhaps I'll warm up to the look ;)

    Hey-- have you seen the much larger oval ones in the same style? Not sure how many it will seat but it may work for you and your family.

  • 13 years ago

    I love that shaker table! I cant imagine that you could go wrong with it and if you have been eyeing it for years, chances are you should get it.

    luckygal-- thanks for posting the modern cottage pictures. I loved looking through them.

  • 13 years ago

    Funky, I have not seen the oval version! That may work!

    I know what you mean about the tulip table being cold. I agree-- I am not sure what you decided about flooring, but for myself, I am keeping my eye out for a busy but warm, old Persian rug for under my kitchen table. I have seen deals (they go very fast). I think that would warm things up a lot. I think any wood chair would warm things up as well.

    I also love the other tables you posted! I think in your OP, the table would work but then I would do lower profile, sleek chairs.

  • 13 years ago

    I love the shaker table--simple without being stark. I think that style is so flexible too.

    Since you like an eclectic approach, I am linking a lovely eclectic dining area with a warm wood table and modern white chairs.

    Here is a link that might be useful: [Eclectic dining area on Houzz[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/sfgirlbybay-shabby-chic-style-dining-room-san-francisco-phvw-vp~26568)

  • 13 years ago

    Crl.. love that look but I just havent found the awesome old farm table that would make the look work. I am shocked that I havent found one but my space is small -- there are plenty of large ones but not so many smaller ones.

    I do think I need to just bite the bullet and buy the table I love. I may need to wait a bit (just starting a new job after a year of unemployment) .. but they discount the tables on the showroom floor so I may just find a deal that pushes me to buy now.

    Anele - the table I saw on DWR is very expensive but there are many knockoffs at more reasonable prices-- though not Ikea prices. http://www.thefind.com/furniture/info-oval-tulip-table

  • 13 years ago

    funkyart,

    Hi, my name is Tricia and I'm usually on the Cooking Forum although I've been reading here for the past few months since we were flooded out of our home from Sandy.

    Anyway, I've been reading this thread and thought I'd jump in and make a suggestion. You might try searching for your table by looking for a "Tavern Table". They are smaller and might work well for your space.

    I've given a link with some examples. I do not represent this store. I have purchased from them before and have been pleased. But, I've nothing to gain by posting the link.

    About 3/4 of the way down the page there's a nice Connecticut maple Queen Anne, c. 1760-1770 that's a nice size for a small dining space. The top is 28.5"x41".

    If you're concerned about clicking on a stranger's link - Bumblebeez can vouch for me. :)

    /tricia

    Here is a link that might be useful: Examples of Tavern Tables

  • 13 years ago

    Tricia-- what *beautiful* tables!! I am in PA so it's a bit far to go-- and more so, they are a little more than I'd like to spend (the shaker table falls in the lower end of the 2-6K price range).

    I have looked at tavern tables and you are right-- they are a great size for me. I can go up to 54" round/square but would prefer 45-48.. the space is 9 x 10+ but because of the door and kitchen access, I can't crowd the space.

    Thanks for the link!!

  • 13 years ago

    I'll chime in with a suggestion - how about Wishbone-style chairs, based on the Wenger design. We bought 4 through Overstock.com for the dining table in the guest suite at our lakehouse.

    They have the sleek, uncluttered look you seek, but they're very comfortable and can even be used when you need occasional chairs in a small space.

    We were also not wanting to go country or precious. They were very affordable from O.com, and come in stained wood or painted finishes, depending on what you choose for a table.

    Just a thought.

  • 13 years ago

    Oh, amck! I love the wishbone chairs-- there are two for sale near me for a pretty good price. This is the direction I'd go if I were going to get the MH extension table.

    But are you suggesting them for the shaker table or another style? I am not sure I can picture them with the shaker table.

    This post was edited by funkyart on Wed, Feb 27, 13 at 11:47

  • 13 years ago

    You know, I'm not sure I'd pair them w/ the Shaker table. They came to mind when I saw the photos of Danish chairs someone posted above. Then I looked at the rectangular tavern table tricia posted and thought that would be a nice match.

    We paired ours with a zinc topped rectangular table (now discontinued) from Home Decorators. It has a chunky dark wood trestle bottom and our chairs have that same shade stain and natural colored hemp seats.

    Others who are more savvy may be able to lend their opinion, but because of their round back shape, I like them better with an angular - square or rectangular -rather than round table.