Software
Houzz Logo Print
love_flowers_gw

drawers or regular cabinets

18 years ago

For Storage purposes should I opt for the regular cabinet with 2 shelves or should I go for drawers?

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    drawers.

    Anywhere its even remotely feasible, use drawers, with full extension slides. Anywhere that drawers won't work, (perhaps due to wanting to store items taller than the drawer might be, or perhaps under the sink with pipes and stuff in the way) use rollout trays behind the cabinet doors.

    Regular cabinet with two shelves? Nowhere.

  • 18 years ago

    Drawers. Drawers. Drawers. I love them! I read in one of my kitchen design book that Cornell University did a study in the 1960s that concluded storing most items in drawers was the most ergonomic, but it's taken 40 years to catch on.

    My cabinetmaker thought I went overboard and I told him he was behind the times. I did, however, include a few traditional lower cabinets "just in case," and I am making use of them for taller items such as heavy wooden trays and bread machine.

  • 18 years ago

    Drawers!

    Just think about trying to pull something out that is stored in the back of the bottom of a lower cabinet. You are way bent over or on the floor, and you have to pull out the stuff in front of it first. If that space is not being used, it's wasted.

    Now think about pulling open a bottom drawer--I'm assuming full extention glides. The entire space is useable! Drawers are better than pull out shelves, IMO, because stuff won't fall out of a drawer the way it could on a shelf, and there's no cabinet door to open before you get to the shelf.

    For tall things, we are using a walk-in pantry and space in an upper cabinet.

  • 18 years ago

    Drawers - however be careful not to go overboard. Drawers will typically cost more than cabinets with shelf / door. I know when I initially laid out our plans - I drew drawers pretty much everywhere based on feedback here and one of the KDs took that and followed my lead pricing out mainly drawers. The other couple KDs I got bids from changed some to shelf / door cabinets. the drawers were definitely more expensive and after working thru what would go where, we decided all the drawers were overkill. We are leaving them in most of our big 27, 30, 36 wide cabinets - but changing some of the smaller 15 wide ones to shelves.

  • 18 years ago

    DRAWERS!!! I love mine. I had no idea that they were so much better than cabinets. They store more and they are so much easier to access.

  • 18 years ago

    Our plan includes banks of drawers but also some shelves, adjustable with a pullout for the bottom shelf -- we felt that it gave us more flexibility for storing larger items.

  • 18 years ago

    I am doing mostly drawers. I had them two kitchen ago & they are really so much better than cabinets. I will only have one traditional cabinet in this reno, besides sink bases. That cab is 42" wide and the center shelf will be a pull-out for my heavy mixer, cuisinart, etc. The bottom will not have a pull out and I will store my seldom-used appliances, etc. there. I am planning, however, two shallow cabinets with fixed shelves, one counter height and 15" deep at the end of the island, which will store our everyday pantry stuff like cereal & snacks. The other will be 60" high, 16" deep and 42" wide which will serve as my pantry. It will be tucked under a high window and look like a separate piece of furniture.

  • 18 years ago

    [whisper]Pssst... over here-- listen, I don't dare say this too loud or CODO [Cult of Drawers ONLY] will get me. But the truth is there is more than one right answer to this question. I know, its blasphemy, but there is actually a good case to be made for having a few cabs with pull out shelves, especially for heavy items like small appliances, canisters full of flour, or heavy pots and pans. Pull outs allow you to access the sides of such items, even get a hand underneath, instead of reaching down into the drawers and pulling them straight up-- can be a problem, especially if you have joint issues.

    If you think about it, pullouts are just drawers behind doors. But that lets you re-configure them, adding or removing shelves as your needs change, or simply adjusting height-- can't do that with a plain drawer stack.

    Now, I never suggest cabs without pullouts-- I'm not that much of a heretic-- and I'll readily concede that drawers are great for many items, especially light stuff or things that could tip over on a pullout with low sides.

    Keep this to yourself though. CODO isn't as scary as the Church of the Single Bowl Sink, but you still don't want to attract their attention.

  • 18 years ago

    DRAWERS! My brand new cabinets were just installed. We have a combination of drawers and pull out shelves. What a mistake - spend the exta and get all drawers. I wish I would have listened to everyone on this forum who recommended all drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    Oruboris, Thank you!!! I've been trying to figure out why pot drawers made me uneasy. I grew up with pullouts and love them, but the doors are always a hassle so drawers made sense. I thought it was just the peering in, which seemed silly, but thinking it was silly didn't make the feeling go away. Thanks for the explanation and food for thought.

  • 18 years ago

    You also loose more space with drawers than with pull outs. Most pullouts in a base cabinet I believe are 22" deep. Unless you are going custom, in which case I believe you can get larger drawers that better utilize the space, this is how much you loose: in a 24"w x 24"d base cabinet, with interior dimensions of 22 1/2" x 22 7/8", the interior drawer space is 19x18". Of coarse, I have framed, not framless, cabinets and they are stock, not custom. But if you are looking at similar cabinets, consider the convenience of drawers (only one thing to pull out, not open door, then pull out) along side the loss of space. I did loose more space in the cabinet with drawers than the ones with pull outs. Obviously, some people do not have space issues and for others it is the biggest issue they have. If I were to do it again, in the same space, I would probably go with tall drawer-like pullouts (you can buy them 6" deep) rather than drawers.

    Ducking fast...

    Sue

  • 18 years ago

    drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    I've got 20 drawers in the new kitchen and I wouldn't want to miss any of them. the only place where we opted for cabinets instead was along a wall where the lower cabinets are only 15" deep.

  • 18 years ago

    OK, but what is the relative price difference between drawers, pullouts and fixed shelfs? We met with our designer last night and mentioned we wanted all (or mostly all) drawers. The first response, "That will be expensive." "How much?" "A lot!"...

    OK, how much more?