OOps I almost forgot, the canopy bed would be just a four poster bed, so the metal that goes around the bed at the top won't be there.

I vote for #1!
FW

Do you have other furniture that it will go with?

I was just going to order the bed and dresser without mirror. At the moment I don't have any other furniture to go with it. I was looking at these as night stands.

http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Hand-painted-Cherry-Chestnut-Bombay-Accent-Chest/3928247/product.html?rcmndsrc=4

I am not sure if I would get one or two. I don't like everything to look predictable.

Any and all help and suggestions are appreciated. My husband doesn't want to look anymore(ha ha!!!)

Both of those beds are beautiful. If I could choose I would love that first bed, but the canopy metal is awesome and I would go for that too. You don't need to put a canopy on it...just gorgeous, and the black satin accent chest on that O site would look great. Just MHO. Have fun shopping!!!

rboyz2, Do you have a large bedroom with high ceilings? Both of those beds are quite large, and if you haven't seen them in person, and carefully measured your space, you might be surprised when one is delivered. Just playing devil's advocate here to make sure you know how much room they'd take up.