Software
Houzz Logo Print
houseful_gw

Which is the better compromise?

18 years ago

I have figured out that I need a 3-foot on-center wall to accomodate a 24" pantry door with 3.25" molding. In order to get the 3 feet, I have to make an adjustment on one or the other adjacent walls (L-shape kitchen with pantry in corner of L). I either reduce a 15" drawer to 12" or shrink my cooktop wall from 7' to 6'9".

My cooktop wall will be a focal point all by itself and because of my lack of space now, I am really looking forward to that 7 feet. With a 36" cooktop, shrinking the wall will cause me to need fillers. Not the end of the world but...

The drawer will be between the DO's and the DW. It will hold kitchen towels, pot holders and such. But 12" especially in a framed cabinet is really small. I will have plenty of storage elsewhere so I can afford to lose inches somewhere but not sure which one to pick.

I haven't chosen a cabinet line yet, so I really don't know whether they will be framed or frameless. I am leaning toward Kraftmaid so let's assume framed. What would you do?

Comments (6)

  • 18 years ago

    I think you'll be sad if you lose your cooktop wall. It feels like that's what is more important to you (and I can't argue with wanting that space!).

    Potholders and towels will fit in a pretty small drawer--just get deep drawers so you can stack those neatly folded towels as high as you have to! And if you have to put them elsewhere, so be it. You sure can't put the cooktop elsewhere!

  • 18 years ago

    What are the kitchen dimensions?

    Perhaps a pantry wall would be a better solution vs a corner pantry?

    6'9'' w/ a 36'' cooktop doesn't leave much counter space on either side of the cooktop. Also, if the cooktop wall is the focal wall, you'll have that big corner pantry competing with it.

  • 18 years ago

    You can have a cabinet on one side of the cooktop 3" larger than on the other side and not use fillers. I have a cabinet on one side of my sink that is 3" different than the other and if you didn't know, you'd think they were the same.

    But I also think a smaller drawer is often more useful than you think. I have 15" drawers (frameless) in my hutch that hold a lot.

    Check the useful size inside before you make a final decision on the option or the cabinet line. A 12" frameless drawer with undermount glides will have a drawer box that is about 9" wide inside. The framed cabinet would be that less the width of the face frame and possibly the glides if they are side mounted (my last ones were and we lost a lot of drawer space).

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the help. I think I will go with the 12 inch drawer and keep the length of the cooktop. Being so starved for storage has me made me a bit greedy I guess, LOL! I actually have a 7-foot cooktop area right now, but it's also home to the coffee pot, grinder, toaster oven, and cookie jar. I'd still be happy with 81" if it was uncluttered. I just don't want to waste money on fillers if I don't need to. I also realize I have enough odds and ends that will fit nicely into those drawers. I could have gone asymmetrical, but now I don't have to worry about it.

    The kitchen is actually 15x20, but the work area is like a galley/L combo since the back of the island has seating and is then open to the living space. There is no other wall for pantry. Plus, I do better organizationally with walk-ins than cabinets.

    I have poured over hundreds of pictures and I never really noticed a corner pantry attracting my attention more than a nice cooktop area. I suppose if I was building my dream home I'd be more concerned about it. With this remodel, I just need lots of storage and good function.

  • 18 years ago

    Definitely go with a 12 inch instead of 15 inch! You will miss this space less I think!

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Cpang,

    I'm hopefully going for a cabinet quote tomorrow. Hope I don't faint, LOL!