Software
Houzz Logo Print
hald_gw

Spanking dogs - need advice

20 years ago

The posts about discipline leads me to ask for advice. We have 4 terriers in our house, 3 recues and one from a pet store. They are a Westie, a Fox Terrier (male), and 2 Terrier mixes, 3 males and 1 female.

The male Fox terrier from the pet store is the behaviour problem. He seems to have a mental disorder or syndrome. He attacks the other 3, sometimes for no apparent reason. He appears never to have been taught to play with other dogs or humans. I have tried to teach him to play but he becomes too aggressive; trying to play with him around the other 3 is out of the question as it always leads to a dog fight. He is terrified of children. He is obessive: he carries a tennis ball on our morning walks; I learned he would focus on the ball and it would prevent him from attacking the other 3 dogs.

I'm 54 and have owned many dogs. The FT is the only one I've ever had that has had these kinds of problems. His behaviour can occur out of the blue, in a split second, and both before and after the incident he is calm and lovable. I think he is schizophrenic. I think he was in a cage at the pet store too long. I think he is probably from a puppy mill as he has odd physical traits such as flat teeth and thin hair.

I've tried various kinds of discipline including a shock collar (not effective as he didn't appear to feel the shock - I tested it on myself so I know it was working and I shaved his neck so the collar made proper skin contact). Chaining him to a pole for a couple hours and talking sternly and loudly seems to work for a couple days, then he is back to being growlely again, and then attacking.

Also, I need to be clear, much of the time he is a wonderful loving dog. He is about 4 years old.

Any advice?

-Hal


Comments (8)

  • 20 years ago

    I think some dogs are simply meant to be 'only dogs'. Have you considered rehoming him? If all else has failed, that might be your only option. Sorry you are having such problems.

  • 20 years ago

    Oh, and no, I wouldn't spank him. I think that would just add to his problems.

  • 20 years ago

    Weed's right.

    Hitting that dog would make it worse.

    It does sound like he needs to be an only dog.

  • 20 years ago

    I don't think spanking a dog ever works. If he were mine, I would have him evaluated by a dog behaviorist and/or vet.

    Unfortunately if he was not properly socialized when he was young, I am not sure he will ever be able to play nice with his siblings. He might do best in an only pet situation.

  • 20 years ago

    If he isn't neutered, I'd get that done right away, it should help.

    I agree that spanking is a bad idea.

    Terriers often don't play well with others, it is a breed trait.

  • 20 years ago

    Hitting a dog in any way is simply not the way to go. They don't know why they are being hit and it hurts them, making problems worse. Tying the dog up outside is not going to help either.

    Take the dog to someone who can zero in on the problem. There are so many reasons for your dog is doing this.

    SG

  • 20 years ago

    Does the dog know you are the boss? Is this dog the same age as the others?

    Spanking doesn't work, but have you tried a dominance roll on him? Immediately after he attacks the other dogs, you grab him and roll him on his back/side and hold him down while hovering over him. This is not designed to be physically harmful, just mentally reinforces that you set the rules. You do need to be angry when performing it or the message will not be instilled. There should be no talking, but a deep, sharp and fast growl wouldn't hurt (seriously, it works well).

    I have one small dog in my household and all of the others know that to mess with him is like messing with me. They never even try it.

    I did have a foster dog (about three times his size) that attacked him once...I got over there as fast as I could and grabbed this dog by her shoulders (allowing the little one to take off), threw her to the ground and threw my body on top of hers with one hand on her neck and shoulder so she couldn't bite if she wanted to. The cat even got involved and gave her a few quick swats to the nose. She, very quickly, became submissive. I stayed until I could stand over her and she was still on her back and submissive. Needless to say, she never went after him again....steered clear, in fact.

    Terriers can be more stubborn and less responsive to dominance techniques, but enough times and the message will begin to sink in.

    You know, puppy mill puppies are removed from their mothers at very early ages. The mother doesn't even train her puppies until they are somewhere between 6-8 weeks old. After she has taught them to play nice with others (if she is a good mom), she will then wean them. This correction, if it doesn't come from mom, must come from the new human parent.

    Part of insuring that you have a well behaved dog is not allowing them to "mature" to the point that they don't need you to make these important decisions (to attack or not) for them. This is the reason that dogs become dangerous when they are turned out and become wild...they no longer need humans to make decisions for them...they don't even need us for food.

    You need to be in charge before anything will change.

  • 20 years ago

    I agree don't spank the dog.

    Your terrier may not have been socialized well as a pup, but that doesn't mean he cannot be trained to behave well around other dogs. But he probably will always need to be "watched" extra careful.

    Terriers generally respond much more to "tone of voice" discipline than physical discipline. Practice your praise tone and your discpline tone and watch the reaction of your terrier, I think you will know what I mean.

    You may want to just keep working with him on praising his behavior when he plays nice and then correcting his behavior (with tone of voice or a gentle leash correction) when he doesn't. And keep him seperated from the others dogs when he is not under full supervision. Its important to put him in situations where he can be praised, because you don't want to be correcting him all the time. He needs some praise too.

    And terriers like to fight and growl...I had a terrier once who growled every time she ran up or down the stairs. It freaked me out at first, but once I figured out her patterns it was quite charming actually. It was like she felt she had to growl to conquer the stairs.

    Do you have a crate for him? As puppy store (mill) dog, he may feel comfortable in a crate and need one as his own place of refuge. You can give him a crate and never close the door...let him use it, as he pleases.

Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional