Software
Houzz Logo Print
ironcook

Update: So I chose a red paint...

15 years ago

hi all...

yesterday i took a chance and bought a quart of benjamin moore "red tricycle".

it is a nice color, but WAY TOO BRIGHT on the wall.

and my cabinet sample no longer looks ivory/pale yellow, but white! (in fairness, that's really the color it's supposed to be.)

florantha mentioned her red paint as being more "restful". i'm just not sure i can go that dark because it's an interior kitchen with no windows.

is it even possible to have a cheerful, light AND restful red? otherwise i'll have to go blue.

Here is a link that might be useful: Original choosing red paint thread

Comments (22)

  • 15 years ago

    Do you have one coat or 2? Did you use Aura?
    It may look different when the second coat is on.
    If using Aura, you will have a more accurate result after 1 coat than with regular BM, but it will look richer after 2 coats.
    I did a deep bright blue for the top half of our bsmt walls (and put in a darker floor and painted the wainscoting white) and the room was more cheerful than when it was a light beige. The brightness was more a factor than the darker shade. I'd try having them deepen the color a little if you are doing a second coat. That may be enough to tone it down.

  • 15 years ago

    thanks, dianalo.

    yes, we used Aura, and did two coats. it color did look much better after the second coat. it's just too bright... like neon bright!

    what do i ask the paint person to do to "deepen" the color and how much? (i've never done this before.) thanks!

  • 15 years ago

    Did you use a primer?

    I am a red freak and anytime I use red it has to have
    a dark gray primer or a primer that matches the color,
    otherwise it comes out dreadful. Now this is just me
    others might never have this issue.

    Now, why did you choose tricyle?
    Did you prefer this color over the other colors?
    Did you talk with a paint specialist?
    I ask because some reds need lighting or even a primer
    to create depth. And I have always found red tricycle
    to go on a bit bright, yes even a neon feel to the color.

    One thing you might be able to do is talk to the
    color experts where you got the paint. Ask how to create
    a deeper shade. I am not sure how much deeper
    If you want to stay in this same color family
    Red Tricycle is 2000
    Million Dollar red is a bit darker number 200.
    Or Ruby Red 2001-10
    Deffinitely talk to the BM folks. They can help make
    this better.

    My instinct says the color in that picture isn't
    tricyle. It really looks like Tomato 2010-10

    Thinking of you and knowing this is going to be great.
    Don't give up on your inspiration.
    ~boxerpups

  • 15 years ago

    I took a look at your OP and saw the inspiration pic.. i think that color looks bright but is actually quite a bit less saturated and darker than what you chose.

    ask your paint person to go less saturated and darker just a bit. Your color is very saturation (lots of pure hue and mid brightness - has no white "added"
    its so hard to speak in color terms without a color wheel to point to! sorry!

  • 15 years ago

    You should look at SW antique red. I have a great saleslady at our SW. She helps me pick my paints. I'm really happy with the color. It's a true saturated read.

  • 15 years ago

    thanks for the help! i will try your suggestions.

    i've been looking at gardenweb red paint and red kitchen threads, which i probably should have done beforehand. there's a lot in the decorating forum, too.

  • 15 years ago

    I lurked on your thread the first time you posted. Sorry! I would have advised against Tricycle Red. It just seemed to me that it was the lightest of all the reds and had a blue undertone that "weakened" the color. At the same time, it did not strike me as "restful" at all. IMHO, it was a "dull" red (if there can be such a thing) but it was certainly not "restful" (restful red???) :-)

    As you may/may not know, I am big fan of red. I have a red range and hood and many red accessories in my kitchen. I also have a red-walled dining room. Unfortunately, I don't remember the red of I chose for my dining room, but it could be "Million Dollar Red" -- or something pretty close to it. But here's the thing: when my dining room was being painted, it took a professional painter 5 coats for that color to look right! Red is just one of those colors that can be very hard to get right. . . . although it is so worth it when you do. IOW, if you really have your heart set on Tricycle Red, consider the possibility that just two test coats of it is not enough to get a proper sample.

  • 15 years ago

    Tricyle red sounds like it would be bright and cheerful!

    You probably need something with more black/gray in it...to make it more shaded and less bright. White makes it pink and black/gray should make it a deeper, softer red.

    Obviously, I'm no expert...just looking at the color wheel :)

  • 15 years ago

    yes(!)... i do so love your kitchen, martha!

    hee, hee... okay "restful" (red) was florantha's word!

    yeah, maybe i thought "dull" = "restful". but tricycle red is anything but dull! it's actually quite fun... in a circus.

    i just don't know if i can take red walls in the kitchen anymore... a red aga, yes. ;)

    thanks lavender... i may be coming over to the blue side. :)

  • 15 years ago

    Have you considered doing just one wall in red? I must admit that, after about 6 years or so of living with my gorgeous red dining room, I'm about ready to give it up. Why? Well, one for thing, that room has only one window, which faces onto a fairly dark section of the yard. And, much as I love red, it is an intense color -- especially when it's on all the walls of a fairly dark room! I think you are right to start thinking twice about doing that in a kitchen with no natural light coming in at all.

  • 15 years ago

    I have sampled SW's Antique red and BM's Moroccan red (sp?). I love them both, funny thing is that moroccan worked in my dining room and antique red in my sister's kitchen. We used a dark gray primer and 2 coats of BM. I love red and hope you find yours, lighting makes all the difference:)

  • 15 years ago

    With Aura, you really don't need a dark primer at all. 2 coats is as much as you will ever need as long as you haven't missed a spot while rolling.
    We went with a really dark purple (Purple Rain)on 2 brand new sheetrock walls and after 1 coat it truly was its finished color for the most part, except where it was rolled on "thin". Ours is a rich deep color and the tricycle is so much lighter. I think you should consider the tricycle to be your primer and just choose a slightly darker, deeper red. If you had done 1 coat, you could have doctored what you have left to go darker. You will need to add a carefully applied coat to change the tone if you do not like what you have now.
    Just make sure you test run what you will put on the walls and counters to see if it is less glaring when less of it is showing. It just may be too bare at this point.

  • 15 years ago

    hi again...

    okay, i am going to keep trying the red, but it will only be on one wall. i've mocked it up in photoshop, and it looks fine.

    it's just too hard to go blue the way the kitchen is situated anyway. i really don't want to give up my red sofa and dining chairs... i like them. :)

    anyone have any thoughts which way on the color wheel i should go, or just stay where it is and go darker? it seems like the majority of kitchens i see are toward the orange side. it has me wondering if there is something to that, or is it just personal preference?

    i'm will look into "antique red" when i get to a SW dealer, too. i also liked the kitchen linked below, SW "flower pot".

    thanks, in advance!

    Here is a link that might be useful:

  • 15 years ago

    This might not be helpful, but we did red in our bathroom and had such a darn time picking the shade. We actually used a warmer, slightly orange red called BM Navajo Red, which was recommended by two different color professionals (one at the BM store and another we hired for a quick consult for the whole house.) And it was the only sample my DH and I gravitated torwards when looking at all the large samples of reds. Most were just too blue/cool. Navajo Red is very warm and makes the Dove White trim look almost creamy. Have had a ton of compliments on it & even considered it for our kitchen... but went in a different direction with a griege color for very calm kitchen.

    Good luck - sometimes with color I have found that in the choosing that I had to go a little in a different color than what I imagine to get the right effect that didn't overpower. So a little orange on a red, a little gray or green on a blue or purple, a little yellow for a green, a little orange on a pink -- the "true" color just never worked for me on the wall, it needed something to "cut" the color (clearly I am no color expert, but someone who likes color on the walls.) Good luck.

  • 15 years ago

    sparklekitty... i should have posted sooner to say thanks for your post. it helped a great deal. navajo red was runner-up for a long time. you were absolutely right about going with something different than what is imagined when choosing red. i had trouble finding navajo red because it wasn't where i expected it!

    ultimately we chose a color that is less sophisticated! ;) and it is much more orange than i thought would be right.

    just to follow-up, the winner is: bm 1306 - habanero peppper!

    thanks to everyone for your input. red is very tricky! we tried "ravishing red", and it looked like tomato paste on our walls! but luckily, third try was the charm. :)

    p.s. i think i figured out what florantha meant by "restful" red. it must have to do with how bulls feel about a matador's cape! even though i loved "tricycle red" (brightness, notwithstanding), it made me very agitated in the kitchen!

    habanero pepper kitchen from morewaystowastetime.blogspot.com:
    (boxerpups has posted this, too!)

  • 15 years ago

    That habenero red is SO close to the red we have on our kitchen walls. We've been really pleased with the color because it's a warm, slightly muted version of red. Rich, but not blinding.

  • 15 years ago

    Red is hard, but that looks like a lovely one. I hope you enjoy it.

  • 15 years ago

    Ha cha cha! Nice red!

  • 15 years ago

    Ironcook,
    I am thrilled you found the right red.
    Now, do you have a photo? You know what a visual girl I
    am I have to see it to feel it and love it.
    Wait, I already love it because it has red but post a pic
    when you can.
    Truly glad you found a red that will work.
    ~boxerpups

  • 15 years ago

    ironcook, It's hard when your surroundings make you see red, isn't it? Glad things are better now.

    Have fun stormin' the castle...

  • 15 years ago

    Good for you!

  • 15 years ago

    I love jan's kitchen!!! I have seen too many white kitchens that looked a little plain-Jane. I like how warm it makes her kitchen, it really comes alive doesn't it?

    I forgot which cabinets you went with, white? Red would be perfect!

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner