Software
Houzz Logo Print
jnh896_gw

white or off white trim? Help!

15 years ago

Hello,

I have cross-posted this in the paint forum as well. We are building a new home that is a "production builder" not custom, but the on-site project manager is flexible with some of the choices. I consulted with a decorator/designer about pulling together our furniture and accessories in the new house. She suggested that we consider painting the trim a warm white rather than the stark "builder white." Our wall color is a medium tone from the Duron Antebellum Whites collection  it is now called Tuscan Tan, but was formerly Sienna Sand. Our hardwood floors will be a medium walnut and the kitchen cabinets are a dark cherry, almost an espresso. The kitchen granite is Tropic Brown. The carpeted areas are a neutral tan color.

I know so much of this is a matter of personal taste. I donÂt hate white trim, but I have seen other trim choices that look great in custom homes. However, we donÂt have much time to make a decision.

If you have an "off white trim" what did you do for your outlets and light plates? I do not like the look of decorative wall plates or painted wall paints if the receptacle or toggle switch remains white. (Again, just personal preference, not meaning to offend anyone elseÂs choices.) I am afraid that the "cream" outlets and plates supplied by the builder may look dingy or too dark. Also the HVAC vents are in the ceiling, so they will be noticeable. And what about other mechanicals, like the thermostat? I think it might bug me if the mechanicals are "stark white" and the trim is "off white?" Oh, and the blinds are already ordered and canÂt be changed and they will be white. (Those eventually will be changed but we did have to get coverings since there are privacy issues in the neighborhood.) And there are decorative white tile accents in the secondary baths.

We do have a two story foyer and open family room so the ceilings are quite high. I am thinking that we should paint the ceiling the same as the wall color to bring it down a bit visually. I feel like I may be making a faux pas by having "builder white" trim (which almost has a blue/purple tint on the fan deck) when everything else in the house is warm tones, so I am not sure which choice may be the lesser of the evils. I just read the thread about "soulless" decor with great interest. I am trying to be thoughtful and personal with the choices we make, even in a production home. So, no flames about our granite and two story open floor plan please. :)

Picking out the "off white" trim color is not the issue...we have that selected and the builder is willing to do it. I'm just not sure that I will like the end result with all the other "white white" items in the house.

Opinions, please? Thank you!

Comments (10)

  • 15 years ago

    We ended up matching our trim to our cabinets which are Nordic White and not only using it in the kitchen, but throughout the house. This was the advice of a certified color consultant/designer I met with to choose paint colors for the house. So far, only the upstairs is done but it looks beautiful.

  • 15 years ago

    For all of our trim and doors, I chose to use a soft creamy white that has a slight yellowish tint to it. I love the way it looks. The one we used is Behr's Pot of Cream and IMHO it's perfection. While refurbishing the foreclosure home we bought a couple of years ago, we've added crown molding and replaced every door and piece of trim in the house. Everything is now painted with this same white and I'm tickled with it. It's not something anyone else notices, but I love how it's nice and crisp but easy on the eyes.

    There are hundreds of whites and when you put them directly next to each other, yes, you can see their differences, but once you pick one and put it on the trim and doors, it will just look white and really only you will probably notice.

    Our floors are walnut and oak and I've used cool colors and warm, regardless this Pot of Cream white looks great with all of it. I've even painted furniture with it and plan on eventually painting our kitchen cabinets with it too.

    In regards to the switches and covers I have just used standard white of each. None of them sit next to the trim and they all blend, but there are light switches you can paint to match. The vent covers I'd leave alone.

    If it were me, I'd never opt for builder anything. Take the designers advise and pick a soft creamy white.

  • 15 years ago

    All my walls(2610 sq ft home)are painted a warm medium tan, w/trim color, doors too, being 4 shades darker. I knew I didn't want the standard white or stained wood, and had seen a very expensive home in Wilmingtom, NC with this done and loved it. The house was under construction, and the paint cans were setting in the garage, so I 'took' a sample of each on a piece of cardboard and carried it around for 5 years. I finally got the chance to use the colors 2 years ago when I built my house. The builder and everyone else loved it! ;o)

  • 15 years ago

    I can identify with your dilemma! It would be difficult for me to see cream colored trim with stark white switch plates but as the others have said you can paint over them.
    I think the cream colored trim would look nice but I think the white would too; either way it will look beautiful!! You know you could choose an off white which would be just a little lighter than the cream but not white; tough decisions :)
    Good Luck!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your replies.

    lukkiirish - there will be some areas of the house that have that "picture frame" or "shadow box" trim below the chair rail where the plates and trim will be together. Can't move the electrical although the builder probably would do away with the picture frame trim if we asked him to.

    Patty cakes - we talked about doing dark trim and doors as well. How did you address the ceiling? Did you choose brown or black switches and outlets?

    I'm on my way to the store this afternoon to paint swatches on sheetrock, buy some outlet covers, and take it over to the house and see how it looks. I'm glad we did this production home before we tackle a custom home! So many things to learn!

  • 15 years ago

    SW's Dover is quite nice. As is BM's White Dove. I like White Dove if your walls are pale, but prefer the Dover with really strong wall colors. Whichever paint place you go to, they should be able to match the other company's paint colors w/o any problem.

  • 15 years ago

    I come from a very different mindset than Lindac, I believe that though beautiful and great for inspiration, magazine photos for the most part are for show and do not typically reflect real life. Switch plates and vent covers are just part of every day life and it is acceptable to have them in white. I actually prefer them that way. I think it's a crisp and clean look and does not interfere with the design of a room in the least.

    Jhn, If you like the frame trim, don't do away with it just because of a switch plate! It will add character and interest to the room. Honestly, when is the last time you ever went into a house and said, "Oh my, would you look at that! They painted their trim a different color than their switch plate!"?

    IMPO you're struggling over an issue that realistically should not be an issue at all. I would grab some sample cards for a few nice creamy whites, take them to the space and choose the one that looks the best in the lighting of your rooms and not worry about the covers at all.

    Here's a sample of ours with the Pot of Cream, as you can see, it's soft, but definitely white, the walls are Modern Tan by Ralph Lauren:

  • 15 years ago

    Good questions! I have wrestled with them myself.

    We have warm wall colors and opted for a creamy white. As others have mentioned, it still looks white, relatively speaking. I do like the creamy color, vs. a bright white with the warm tones. Many of our rooms are painted in BM historical colors, so the creamy color looks great. In rooms with clearer, brighter colors, a brighter white might look better. Don't let the switch plates dictate your choice, though. We used off-white for our outlets and switches, and the toggles and outlets are all the same off-white color, it's not a combo white/off-white situation.

    I hope this helps. It sounds like your home will be beautiful. Enjoy!

    Jan

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks again everyone. We wound up with a "bone white" trim and light almond switch plates and outlet covers. It looks stunning for having been such a last minute decision. It's very subtle but so warm. The bone white trim really softened the wall color.

    lukkiirish - the pot of cream is really pretty. Maybe in our next house. :)

Sponsored
Brenda M. Miller Designer of Interior Spaces
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars77 Reviews
Client-Oriented Interior Design in Loudoun County | Best of Houzz X6