Software
Houzz Logo Print
mollyavalon_gw

on-leash or getting aerobic exercise - clarification needed

20 years ago

I've had some apparently opposing advice, and could use a bit of clarification.

Buster is very athletic. I've been told (and agree) that he needs lots of exercise. In fact, I'm hoping at some point that we can go through agility training. But he needs this exercise right now.

At the same time, many very helpful people have told me he needs to be on leash all the time, when we're out for a walk and when we're in the house. But I can't possibly run as fast as he can, and just a walk with me doesn't come close to wearing him out.

We have playdates with other dogs, which is fine. We have 79 acres to wander around on, and Buster comes to his name every time.

Soooooo . . . other ideas for exercise? OK to have him off leash when we're out for a walk (without our old Sparky, of course)?

Comments (13)

  • 20 years ago

    People have told you that he needs to be on a leash when you're in the house?????

    Why?

    I live in a very rural area and I take my dogs out frequently to run free in the desert. They smell, pee and chase rabbits!! It's heaven to them. It's not a public space but just an open area that hasn't been developed yet. I walk for an hour and they run for an hour and they are always ready to jump back in the car after the hour.

    What breed is your dog? That makes a difference.

    vicky

  • 20 years ago

    I have my Rotties off-leashed trained. The Rotties have always been good about listening. The Huskies not so much. Ok not at all LOL. So I have to keep the Huskies either leashed or fenced. I prefer both.

    Anyway, I used a LONG (50 foot) leash on the Rotties before I gave them free run off leash. They didn't get all 50 feet at once though- they had to earn it by being obedient every single time before I'd let out more leash. It took a couple of months before I let them off leash. Mostly we just played fetch in the yard. Kang liked to play with his retractable leash; we called it the ultra-fun leash game. B'Elanna also played the ultra-fun leash game, but also enjoyed fetch and just hanging out while I gardened. They had very short bursts of running around, not like the Huskies who can run forever, or at least much longer than I could run.

    For the Huskies since I don't have a safe place for them to run nearby, we just play games on the long retractable leash (the 50 leash got hopelessly tangled). They like "get the puppy" and tag. It keeps them running circles around me, so I don't kill myself trying to keep up with them. They run their little hearts out and I stand relatively still. We still go on walks, but getting the whim-whams out is also a lot of fun.

    Aleks, the only Husky that has ever gotten away from me, knew when he was off-leash. He was tricky that way. On the leash, he was very obedient for all commands. But the few times he got out, he'd go out about 20 feet (the length of the retractable leash) and then realize no tightening of the collar. Once he realized there was nothing I could do to stop him, he was off. I was extremely lucky in getting him back- once he was still young and stopped to pee just long enough for me to catch up, another time he ran into a sticker bush and got caught and I had to go in and get him, and the last time he turned around and ran back when a helpful person tried to catch him for me. 3 times in almost 11 years isn't too bad an escape record for a Husky, but I think I lost about 11 years off my life from stress!

    Anyway, I'd give Buster the freedom gradually and make sure he's truly obedient before letting him go. And if he's a Northern breed or mix thereof, I wouldn't do it at all.
    Good luck and habe fun!

  • 20 years ago

    A dog "on leash" in the house is not unusual when you're working on training. For instance, when teaching "Leave it", or working on basic obedience (sit, down, stay). A leash is nothing more than a training tool and it doesn't matter if you use it indoors or out. A leash is esp. important if you're teaching a dog not to jump on people or have to control and correct a dog that is aggressive.

    As for exercise... . with Rex I had no choice. I had to leash him. He didn't know his name when we adopted him (year and a half old). He was even more "sight oriented" than he is now! Without our best friend, Mr. Leash, we'd have gotten nowhere... FAST! I WALKED, and walked, and walked. Until I thought I'd drop. We put in easily 3 hours/day...upwards of 7-8 miles, easy. No kidding. And I drilled him with the "basics". The helpmeet was more permissive, and more trusting, allowing him off-leash before I would have. But his instincts were right... . And I learned from him.

    But I walked every single day... sometimes in my sailing "foul weather gear". And it was OK, no... it was actually FUN. Rex isn't perfectly trained by a longshot. But he's gentle, and even when he manages to charge some slob on the road I NEVER worry about his intentions. And there aren't many occasions that he sees "prey" before I do! I've become a very alert and cautious "mother".

    Once he had the basics of his name, "come!", "sit", "down", "stay", and learned the possibilities a tennis ball held "exercise" became a lot easier. :)

    Now? I tire him out with the tennis ball and the very basics of obedience (must sit in front of me and either "Give",into my hand; or drop the ball in front of me). I don't "do" tug o' war over something retrieved. When he's had a run and has burned off built up steam we do our leash work. After that we have more time off-leash. But sometimes not. I am the mistress and I call the shots!

    You will find what works best for you, and I know you will have the best of times discovering it. There is nothing like a young, excited, intelligent dog to encourage activity in its master/mistress. Rex is a daily shot of adrenalin for me. I love his face, the eyes asking, "Now?!". How can I refuse?

    (I am a cat person, lol!)

  • 20 years ago

    Oh, it's because we are working to train Buster not to jump on our old dog Sparky. We've only had Buster for 3 weeks. He's a heeler mix, and he keeps trying to herd Sparky. Poor Sparks is bummed out.

    Buster has tons of energy!

  • 20 years ago

    I seriously doubt you can take the Heeler out of the Heeler...sorry.

    That is like trying to get a person to stop blinking...LOL!

  • 20 years ago

    I think I was one of the posters that mentioned the leash in the house..........but I meant only when training and working with him around Sparky. Have you considered a baby gate to let Sparky have some peace and quiet in the house without worrying about Buster?

    Work on your training as you leave the house and on the return. I see nothing wrong with you and Buster enjoying a romp thru your acreage, sans leash, especially since he returns to you when called. Don't forget to take Sparky for his own one-on-one walks with you, even if they're short one (since he gets tired). ;)

  • 20 years ago

    webkat5 - You're right, we can't take the Heeler out of the Heeler, but at least one person here reminded us that these dogs are trained both to herd animals and to leave them alone on command.

  • 20 years ago

    It is of my humble opinion that if you have the acreage and it is safe to run your dog without a leash on, especially 1:knowing your dog will come back, 2: you are safely away from any street 3: you need to make your dog stick to the carpet when you get home or 4: you need your dogs energy level to be like yours during training.
    I am hugely fortunate in that my dog has seperation anxiety, which I helped create when he was a pup by going for walkies in the woods and hiding from him, as a result I can walk with my dog anywhere without a leash, he will be no more than 30 feet from me before turning around to locate me. I want my dog to be able to enjoy being off leash and run with other dogs at the dog park or in open space and I live where I have miles and miles acres and acres of open space where dogs are allowed to run free under voice control. From what you have written I think your dog needs both and you have the unique situation which many dont and that is you can safely run your dog off leash near where you live. YES there is always the danger of your dog taking off to chase deer or squirrel, you can do the hiding thing (best with two people,one to jack the dog up by saying wheres mommy? and of course mommy who is hiding.) I think it is up to you to use your best judgement in your case. Run you dog stupid, then snap the leash on and go to training classes. when training is over do the same, run your dog then spend a half an hour reminding your dog on leash. Training should go on all day, everyday when ever you have the opportunity. Natural Balance makes meat sticks which are great training treats when cut into cubes, use whatever you have to tip the tide to your advantage.

  • 20 years ago

    Above posting should read run your dog stupid, then snap on the leash, I have trouble with this keyboard, need a new one - I prefer to run my dog until he can no longer think or protest. So I hope nobody got offended. Also if you want to carry a leash with you in case trouble starts, you could always snap it on.

  • 20 years ago

    there are several versions of harnesses for bicycles. Or you could simply leash him and let him trot along your side as your cycle. Or google for sled harnesses, and let him drag a tire. Or go skijorning, bikejorning, or skatejorning - fasten the leash to your waist and let the dog assist you moving forward. Not a Husky? No problem. Check this site that has pictures of miniature poodles pulling a scooter.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dogscooter.com

  • 20 years ago

    Why don't you try carting?

    I live in an neighborhood with lots of homes and cars speeding by so I don't think this is a safe place for it but with 79 ac I'd go nuts. With one of my dogs that loves to play tug, I hold on to a rope while sitting in an office chair with casters and he drives me all around the basement. It's fun for both of us.

  • 20 years ago

    With 79 acres I'd let him off leash while I was out with him for sure! What about playing frisbee? He could run and you could stand still.

    My dogs are always on leash when walking in the city. My parents have a farm and whenever we take them out there, they get to run free. They love it. The only problem we have is my little poodle has turned into a chicken chaser.

  • 20 years ago

    Again, I'm with Mazer.

    I usually let my dogs work out their own relationships. As long as Sparky and Buster are about the same size (or Buster is smaller), it's probably okay to ignore their squabbling.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert