Software
Houzz Logo Print
sabjimata

door-style downgrade?

16 years ago

First, let me say that I have no idea when we are going to have the funding together to do the much needed remodel. That being said, I am getting desperate. I stopped by Lowe's after work today just to look at the cabinet displays and chat up my cabinet guy.

Originally, I was set to do a function over fashion remodel. While I want to like everything I get, I want to make sure there is a purpose for the up-charge. While I would love 5" plank walnut flooring, we are going to go with 2 & 1/4" oak pre-finished (although I guess I could make the argument that wider planks would mean less grooves would mean cleaner floor would mean function wins...but still, it is a steep price differential to justify).

We made the decision to go with Schuler cabs, even though I don't think they have that many door style choices. I know someone will recommend going with another company, but I am okay with my decision.

But when choosing door styles, I inevitably started picking more expensive styles/finishes. Now that I am getting desperate and the remodel is still nowhere in sight, I am beginning to rethink my more expensive door style choices which are purely fashion.

So...anyone out there have a door style they loved or at least liked and ended up going for something cheaper due to $$$? How did it work out for you? Was it difficult to accept or did you quickly learn to happily live with it?

I mean, at this point, I am thinking that anything I have would be an improvement...

Comments (19)

  • 16 years ago

    I am definitely going to go with a simpler door style to save time/money. That said, doesn't Lowe's/HD have a big markup on cabinets?

    In your position I would be tempted to go with IKEA's simplest door style, then switch out the doors with Scherr's later on. (heck, I'm tempted to go with IKEA regardless)

  • 16 years ago

    a shaker style door with inset cabinets are usually pretty budget friendly and are very trendy right now. I like white without any sort of glaze, or paint-grade, painted a dark espresso brown (I chose behr espresso beans) or a cherry (try to find one without too much red). Also if you do granite counter tops, an eased edge looks best and also will save you money! Here some pictures of some budget friendly kitchens and a bathroom I did recently, the cherry cabinets are not inset and were very inexpensive. Good luck!
    {{!gwi}}From Drop Box
    {{!gwi}}From Drop Box
    {{!gwi}}From Drop Box

  • 16 years ago

    In my experience, desperation has led me to make some furniture and home decisions (based on low price and easy availabiity) that I later regretted. Take a step back and figure out what you really need vs. what you really want. Make a list, really evaluate the things on it, and then put it down for a few days, weeks, months. A good KD or cabinet rep can help you figure out ways to save on your cabinets. Find out the different construction options, then have them spell out the price variations on woods, finishes and doors. Keeping the doors simple will save you some cash. Maybe your compromise will be a door style you love but in a less expensive finish (i.e. no glaze) and wood (maple or birch instead of cherry). Or vice versa. Save the fancy trims and interiors for later. Go to the millwork department for your trim instead of ordering it prefinished if you have a good eye for color matching or can be creative mixing colors in your design.
    I am all for making compromises to maintain a realistic budget (making lots of tradeoffs myself right now), but make sure you allow yourself one or two things that you really love and try making up for it elsewhere. If you went with a mid-range door, would you be willing to keep the budget in check and get your kitchen sooner by going with less-expensive laminate or butcher-block counters? What about looking for closeout model or craigslist appliances? Inexpensive faucets, sinks, and lighting from clearance sales or ebay can look just as good as more expensive stuff and these sorts of things are more easily replaced than cabinets. People on this board have done amazing things with cheap subway tile from HD and Lowe's! Do a search for budget kitchens and you will find lots of helpful, innovative ideas.
    I guess what I am mostly saying is don't let the "anything would be an improvement" way of thinking make you rush into a decision you'll later regret. At least get doors that you "like" because they are likely to be the thing in your kitchen that will last the longest.
    It's hard not to get TKO reading this board! Take a deep breath and good luck with your project.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi, If you are going for a traditional look, check out the Schuler Princeton door style. It's one of the least expensive styles, but it doesn't look like it. It is solid wood with raised panels on both the door and drawer. Good luck!

  • 16 years ago

    Are Schuler's framed? If so, is there an acceptable door that is partial, vs. full overlay? Sometimes that can make quite a difference in the pricing. Remember that unless those visiting your kitchen are TKO, they won't know the difference between framed, unframed, full overlay, or partial.

  • 16 years ago

    I went with Diamond's Lansing Maples shaker cabinets. They are good quality cabinets at a budget price.

    Here is a link that might be useful: shaker cabinets

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks guys. Really great advice. I definitely appreciate it and know that it will be useful to others, as well.

    Tracie--I want to get all wood, but I know Ikea makes a nice cab. Actually, in our last house, I briefly considered Ikea, but since it was going to be my "forever" kitchen, went with semi-custom. And then we moved one year later and will get NO money back on the kitchen. OY! But now we are in our forever house. No really, we are :)

    Lula--great pics. Thanks! The door style is very nice.

    Belle-Excellent advice. I do appreciate it.

    Marcy--I just checked that out tonite! There is the Princeton and then another one that is like the same thing but one is half overlay (is that the Princeton?) and only $150/door style! I think I am going to get Capistrano maple in chestnut on the lowers and the $150 maple in white on the uppers. I don't give a hoot about what others are going to think about the mixing and matching. We are probably going to spend 50k+ on the remodel and, truth be told, it will probably only add $10k value to the home!

    RJR--Schuler is framed. The problem (imho) with Schuler is they don't offer many door styles and do not offer many half overlay, which does come with a lower price point. But I definitely hear you and agree!

    Rufinorox--just leaving now to check out your link...thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    Ugh. Just talked to Leon at Scherr's. Their custom RTA's would cost the same as Schuler in a mid-range door. And I would then have to pay shipping, we would have to put them together and then pay the installer. :( To make things even better I called Bank of America to find out about getting a home equity line of credit. No problem. If our house was worth what we paid for it 2 years ago.

    Oh well. One day...

  • 16 years ago

    Talk to your local credit union. You might be pleased. One of the best things about a line of credit is that it's incremental...you don't pay the whole cost of the kitchen until you spend the whole amount; until then, monthly it is a lot less. Snag those great rates while they're out there.

  • 16 years ago

    "So...anyone out there have a door style they loved or at least liked and ended up going for something cheaper due to $$$? How did it work out for you? Was it difficult to accept or did you quickly learn to happily live with it?"

    Yes -- And it really saved big bucks.
    But then, the particulars of my doors weren't that important to me. I changed from a mitered corner with applied bead and raised panel to a simpler raised panel with butt corners (like the Shuler Princeton). The overall impact to my design was small; but to my budget, much larger. (Like $4,000.)

    But that's not always the case. In some kitchen designs, the door style really matters a lot...
    Does it matter in yours?

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, I had to.

    I went from this:


    (Artesia door, the most expensive door in Omega's semi-custom line, Dynasty.)


    to this:


    Do I regret it? A little, b/c I really loved (and still love) the Artesia door. But, by switching door styles and eliminating decorative door panels on the back of the peninsula, furniture molding, and bread drawer, I saved approx $5,000, IIRC. (I think we saved another $2,000 by going from Miele to GE Profile ovens...so altogether I saved a total of $7,000. And, I gained "future favors" from my DH by my willingness to change for budget & his sake! He was stressing about the $$$....we didn't want to deplete ALL our savings!)

    The only two reasons I was willing to switch and didn't fight it too much, were...

    (1)**Both the Artesia & Anson have the same door frame as well as the same drawer front...another look I really love. (We called Omega to confirm...the only difference b/w the door styles is the center panel; the frame & drawer fronts were identical.) Since most of my kitchen is drawers, I was able to at least get the drawer fronts I loved if not the doors. Plus, I could keep my cherry wood w/coffee glaze (both upgrades).

    (2)**I figured I could replace the doors at a later date when we had saved more and college expenses were behind us (of course, my youngest was only in 6th grade at the time...!)


    So I switched. However, after they were installed, my KD commented that she thinks I should keep the doors. After seeing them installed, she thinks the Artesia doors may have been too much in my kitchen...that the drawer fronts + the frame around the flat panels on the doors add just enough but not too much detail. After living with them, I think I agree. However, I do plan to "build" a hutch for the DR someday...and I plan to use the Artesia door!


    Kitchen today

  • 16 years ago

    Sweeby & Buehl......wow! That's a lot of clams! I think my switch from the Capistrano to the Hampton will save about $1000...which is substantial. I actually don't mind so much because, although I do like a flat slab door, I am not really in love with full overlay cabs. The raised five panel door of the Hampton is a little more ornate than I had in mind, but I am going for a "classic kitchen" look, so it should be okay.

    I am afraid to call the credit union....I don't know if I can handle more rejection ;)

    Here is a link that might be useful: schuler door styles/hampton

  • 16 years ago

    Florantha!!!! I did, I did, I did talk to our local credit union. We have struck financing gold! Going to refinance our mortgages (we live in Florida but have not been able to sell our house in PA), save lots of money on payments and then do a HELOC. Monthly payments for the loan will be doable.

    Poo on Bank of America!

    Thanks for the advice. You know I love you!!!! (Spoken like a woman who is TKO) ;)

    Here is a link that might be useful: unsold house :(

  • 16 years ago

    Check Evan's Cabinet and Doors for a fraction of the price of Scherr's. You can mix and match your panel, stile shape, style pattern, etc. They can do more custom, stuff, too. Just call.

  • 16 years ago

    thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    Yeah, I got one of the lowest priced doors as well. I knew I wanted raised panel and there were several choices and yes, the more expensive choices were prettier IMO. But in the end, I'm pretty darn happy with what I got. Saved bucks although I don't know how much because I didn't even bother having the more expensive doors priced out. And honestly I can't even really remember what any of those other doors looked like!

    I spent those $$ on things that really really mattered to me. I never look at my cabs and think, I wish I'd gotten a different door. But I can tell you now that if I'd compromised on some other issues (mainly of function) I'd be very unhappy now.

    Sit down and consider what your priorities are. I like to say that the most aesthetically beautiful thing in the world will turn ugly very quickly when it presents an inconvenience or loss of function. What's really beautiful is having a well functioning kitchen that didn't break the bank.

  • 16 years ago

    LOL! I feel like we are going to break the bank anyway! But yes, function is the main thing that I am going for and I think that whatever I get can be beautiful...even if it is not, design-wise, my first choice.

    The kitchen snob inside me has a vision of what a beautiful kitchen is, but the realist in me also recognizes that we have to live within our means...Or at least what we can not too uncomfortably borrow from the bank ;)

    Here is a link that might be useful: how our loan is coming along

  • 16 years ago

    Did you ever look into custom pricing? If I remember correctly, you live near me, and my custom guy's price was about $3000 less than Lowe's price (I don't remember the Lowe's brand). It was also less than half the price of the kitchen design place. I got much higher quality than what Lowe's offered, I got exactly what I wanted, and I got it for less money.

  • 15 years ago

    buehl, please help. I am freaking out. I went from ordering the destin door by omega to the artesia thinking it was simpler but now I am afraid artesia is too much as in too fancy and formal. I need to hear from someone who has been there that I made the right choice and my kitchen will be beautiful.
    thanks for your input