Software
Houzz Logo Print
bayareafrancy

Are 2 high loops better than one?

18 years ago

Hi there,

I'm sure there are a zillion internet discussion of high loops and backflow from the sink. But I've been googling and searching for hours and I can't seem to get the info I need. So please forgive me for being a pest by raising a tired subject!

Yes, we have no air gap. I know some here are adamant about having one. But we don't.

Our new Bosch diswasher seems to sometimes have water standing in the bottom of it after a cycle. I'm assuming this is backflow from the sink. If that is indeed the source of the water, then...

1. Shouldn't a dishwasher have some kind of backflow prevention "one way" flap? Can we install such a thing?

2. Would adding a second high loop help stop the backflow (our DW hose is very long, so we can make a second loop)? I'm having trouble visualizing the physics involved here, and determining whether the water would have sufficient force to backflow up a second loop (if the sink faucet is not being continually run).

Thank you for any advice you can offer to the air-gap-less among us! I realize that one air gap is better than a high loop. But beyond that, would 2 high loops be better than one?

:-)

Francy

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago

    Dishwashers always have some water left in the bottom after use, which you want! Why? If the pump seal ever runs dry, the seal can overheat and fail. The last water being pumped out is usually fairly clean rinse water, so the little that runs back into the unit is typically clean and not an issue.

    I like not having an air gap (not code requirement here). A hump in the hose works fine.

    Don't double hump the drain line.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you for the reply!

    Problem is, sometimes the water looks dirty.

    So, still don't double hump it? Is that because it would actually help prevent backflow, but the pump seal might run dry?

    Thank you!
    Francy

  • 18 years ago

    The remaining water in the dishwasher is water that remains after the pump has removed all that it can do. Different type pumps could remove more of the water. But a "double hump" might easily result in more residual water left in the dishwasher.

  • 18 years ago

    After thinking about it (my sink and dishwasher have been unhooked for a while), I remember when this problem happens:

    It must be backflow from the sink, b/c it happens during cleanup. I'll be running the sink and disposal, and the dirty water will start to burble up in the dishwasher. Then it sits there until I run the dishwasher. If I don't unload the DW first thing in the morning, the dirty water will back up--even though it doesn't actually touch the clean dishes.

    Soooooooo....

    Add a backflow preventer (and have it back up into the sink??)?
    2 high loops?
    Or just keep on living with it, as I have been for the past couple years.

    Thank you!!

    Francy

  • 18 years ago

    Well, I just talked to our plumber. He's convinced the problem is a clog somewher in our drain line (we have an 80 year old house, and we had some snaking done on the upstairs shower when we moved in, but not much lower down). He said the single high loop should handle any backflow problems if the drain line is clean.

    So, a-snaking we shall go....

    Francy

  • 18 years ago

    Is the high loop all the way to the underside of the counter?
    It is pretty rare for a kitchen sink to ever be filled high enough to cause a high loop to fail.
    The DW already has an electric solenoid operated drain valve.
    You might want to check if debris has become lodged in the valve.
    Most use a plastic ball on the solenoid shaft that is held closed by a spring, and then pulled open by the solenoid to drain the unit while the pump reverses direction so the arms are no longer driven.
    If the valve cannot close fully all the water after the valve in the drain line will run back into the DW, air gap of high loop.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you for that detailed reply lazypup!

    The loop is built in on the Bosch, so it is at the back corner of the dishwasher. We could move it to the sink though...

    Our issue pretty much seems to be cross contamination (which the loop should prevent). We get dirty backflow into the dishwasher when I am using the sink and disposal. The dirty water sits in the DW until I run it. I always run it before the backflow gets too deep! But it does get deep!

    My husband snaked 25 feet into the drain the other night, but don't know if that made any difference. Not sure yet if we should call in the pros with the "real snake." We did have this line snaked by pros almost 2 years ago, but our plumber said that if our 80 year old line were clogged with grease, etc. it could collapse back on itself after the pros snaked it, and thus still be clogged.

    Hopefully we'll get the sink and DW hooked back up this weekend (kitchen construction going on) and we can see if the snaking helped at all.

    Thank you again for taking the time to reply!

    :-)

    Francy

  • 18 years ago

    Have the drain valve of the DW checked.
    Something is preventing it from closing all the way.