Software
Houzz Logo Print
bppark

cement can rot galvanized drain pipe?

19 years ago

My house was built in the 30s and I have, in addition to the main soil stack, three galvanized 1.5-inch drain/waste/vent pipes that go into the basement floor from various sinks and laundry tubs. One is so badly corroded where it goes into the floor that it is swollen and flaking on the outside. If you tapped it with a hammer it would surely break. The other two seem very sound, with no sign of corrosion. A plumber is estimating a job to jackhammer into the floor and replace the bad one, but he said the cause is likely that acid in the cement attacked the pipe and he recommends that I dig out and replace all three.

Should I believe the acid-cement theory?

Comments (16)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That seems like a stretch to me. Unless this pipe is subjected to lots of water movement on the exterior, the pH of the concrete is only going to affect it to a limited degree (and it's an alkaline reaction, not an acid one). However, given that the pipes are 70-some years old, I'd probably be more worried that they're heavily corroded on the inside, so it might make sense to replace them. But how far do they go and can you completely replace?

    Also, how much does the plumber want for this job?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your plumber was slightly mistaken when he said this is an acidic reaction, when in fact it is an alkaline reaction, but either way, the end effect is the same. Whenever galvanized metal is in direct contact with concrete the lime in the concrete reacts with the zinc in the galvanized plating resulting in excessive corrosion. To a lesser degree there are also other contributing factors which result from a direct contact between metal pipes and concrete. The rates of thermal expansion are much different between concrete and metal pipes so as the materials change temperatures throughout the year there is a microscopic tension or torsion effect between the two materials. In addition, due to the fact that the concrete floor and the pipe are generally much cooler than the air surrounding the pipe there is constantly moisture at the point of contact which results from condensation.

    Generally the worst of the corrosion is confined locally to the area of contact between the pipe and concrete however if the subsoil under the concrete has a high alkalinity the problem may continue under the slab.

    In the early days of indoor plumbing there was little regard to this problem and it was common to have galvanized iron soil pipes in direct contact with concrete but as the problem became more apparent the plumbing codes were ammended to prohibit any direct contact between metal pipes of all type and concrete.

    The codes now require that when any pipe is passed through a masonary wall the pipe must be sleeved. To make a sleeve you first install a short length of pipe at least two nominal trade sizes larger than the desired pipe through the wall and extending out 1" to 2" on eihter side. The sleeve is then sealed to the masonary by any convenient means such as mortar, tar pitch, expansion foam, etc. The desired pipe is then passed through the sleeve and the space between the inner wall of the sleeve and the outer wall of the desired pipe is filled with expansion foam.

    Both the International Residential Code and the Uniform Plumbing Code now prohibit using galvanized iron pipe for DWV applications below finished grade, in fact, the IRC requires that all GIP used for DWV applications must be a minimum of 6" above the finished floor.

    The IRC now prohibits the use of iron pipe for water supply under a slab within the confines of a structure. The UPC permits iron pipe for water under slab but the pipe must be factory wrapped and all joints must be field wrapped to an equivalent standard.

    Under both the IRC and the UPC all gas piping run under a slab must be sleeved with sched.40 iron, steel or plastic pipe for the full length of the run under the slab. The interior end of the sleeve must be sealed and the exterior end of the sleeve must project outside the building and be sealed on the end. The sleeve must then have a vent rising vertically above grade and terminating a minimum of 4" above grade. The vertical riser must be turned 180 degrees so the actual opening is pointing downward to protect the sleeve from rain. (In areas subject to snowfall the vent must be 4" above average snow depth--in my jurisdiction the vent opening must be a minimum of 48" above finished grade)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    lazypup-
    That's a great explanation of what's going on. Do you have an opinion about whether the OP needs to replace this?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, one piece clearly needs to be replaced, but there is no visible problem with the other two. One drain serves a kitchen, including dishwasher, and the other serves a laundery area. I'm sure the insides of those pipes aren't pretty, but neither one has ever shown a problem moving water. The bad pipe serves a basement bathroom sink. The question is, once he gets into the basement with a jackhammer, do I only do the obvious one or do I dig up the other two drains as a precaution?
    Still can't figure why the cement-pipe interaction (if that's really the cause) only damaged one of the three drainpipes.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Is one line serving a more used fixture (like the kitchen sink)?

    At least part of the charge is to show up with all the tools for the demo work.
    It might be cheaper in the long run to do allof the pipes in one shot instead of paying for 2 or 3 visits.
    Any galvanized pipe from the 30s is way past its design life and could break or crack at any time.
    It is probably very corroded inside also, even if you have not seen any active symptoms.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Brickeye, the kitchen sink drain probably gets the most use, but from all appearanes it's in good shape. Laundry drain is in good shape too. The bad one serves an old bathroom sink that was probably the least used of the three. The difference in the condition of the pipes is so dramatic that it is just difficult to believe this cement theory. The biggest difference between the pipes is that the good ones are exposed in open air. The bad one was behind a wall of board and paster (which I just removed), and like many such walls, there was a fair amount of debris and rubble in that space. Maybe that had more to do with the condition of the pipe than the cement in the floor. The rust, corrosion and flakiness extends four inches up from the floor -- about the depth of the debris that was in that wall space.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Normally my gut reaction is "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" but in this case we could also say that "not everything that glitters is gold".

    What we know for certain is that one of the three pipes is showing severe evidence of corrossion that is consistant with the type of corrossion associated with direct contact between concrete and pipe. We can further assume that the concrete floor is 4" to 6" thick. What we don't know is what is the condition of this pipe deeper in the concrete or on the underside of the concrete where this pipe exits. From this line of reasoning we can extend it to the other two pipes as well. It is quite feasible that the visible portion of those pipes is as good as the day it was laid but a mere 1/2" below the surface of the concrete they could also be corroded in the same manner if not worse. From my personal experience I would expect that the section of pipe inside the concrete has by now deteriorated to a point where the galvanized coating is completely gone and what remains is a black section of steel that is brittle and crumbly.

    In the modern high tech world we often use the non-invasive technique of inserting a camera in a pipe to visually inspect the interior condition however galvanized iron pipe in a DWV system presents a unique obstacle. They did not have DWV grade fittings for galvanized iron pipe so they used the common pressure pipe fittings. This means that all tee's and elbows have sharp bends with no radius curve so a snake or camera will not go through the pipe.

    Now getting back to Bppark's original question, do we jackhammer the floor and replace all the pipes or do we just replace the section that we know is bad?

    The first step is to get a fair estimate of how much concrete we would need to break out. We already know that we must break out the section where the pipe is corroded so we begin there. Once the concrete is broken out we can actually see what is under the floor.

    It is quite possible that all pipe under the slab is cast iron pipe and the transition from galvanized to iron is taking place either in or just below the concrete. In this case we would only need to change the galvanized pipe so the breakout would be localized to the three pipes.

    If we find that the pipe under the slab is also galvanized we must then try to estimate what the pipe layout is to determine the extent of breakout necessary.

    Let us begin by determining where the "main drain" runs under the floor. Code requires that all structures must have a "Main Cleanout" at the point where the "house sewer"(line from the municipal sewer or septic tank) meets the "House main drain" (The main drain line inside the structure). For structures with a basement the main cleanout is generally within 3' of the basement wall where the drain exits the structure. Typically a municipal sewer is in an easement parallel to the street so the main cleanout would be somewhere along the front wall of the structure. For septic systems if you know where the septic tank is located the main cleanout would be just inside the basement wall on that side of the house. Code also requires a cleanout on the upstream end of the main drain. It may be at the base of the main stack or it may be a separate cleanout on the floor on the opposite side of the structure from where the main cleanout was found. Code also requires that we must have a cleanout at each change of direction greater than 45degrees so for the moment let us assume that the lines under the slab are run as straight as possible to eliminate the need for additional cleanouts. It would also stand to reason that the installer would want to save labor and material cost by making any branch runs as short as possible. We could then stretch a string or imagine a straight line between the to cleanouts to determine the location of the main drain, then imagine a line from where the pipes in question enter the floor for the most direct route to the main drain. If these distances are relatively short it might be cost effective to begin digging but, I personally hate to indescriminately make a long cut that might hinder the structural integrity of a perfectly good slab so here is where we begin considering alternatives. To this point we have made an educated guess where the branch from the line in question attaches to the main drain. Rather than rely upon a guess we could have a camera run from the upstream cleanout down the main drain line. When we visually confirm the location of the side tap we can determine the exact location by measuring the length of camera line from the cleanout to the tap. With our string stretched between the cleanouts we can then measure that same distance along the string on the top of the slab to determine the exact point of connection.

    Once we know the exact layout we then have a couple options.

    1.We could cut out the concrete and replace the entire run of galvanized pipe with ABS or PVC.

    2.All of the fixtures being served by these drains are well above the elevation of the slab therefore we could opt to use ABS or PVC and run the drains above the floor to a point where we can conveniently tie them into the main drain. We could then make a small cutout at the point were the existing galvanized enters the floor, cut the pipe off and fill the cutout, then make another small cutout at the point where the existing pipes tie into the main, cut the pipe and cap the openings in the main, thereby abandoning the old galvanized iron with a minimal intrustion into the slab.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lazypup, that was a fantastic lesson; thanks for patiently taking the time to lay it all out. I'm getting estimates but, as you point out, nobody knows what they're going to find down there. The three pipes are in the general vicinity of a basement toilet and they probably tie into the toilet drain before making a bee-line for the street, but all this stuff in the basement is in the northeast corner; the main stack is in the southwest corner -- so whatever is under the slab, assuming it's straight, is probably a long diagonal line.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    First estimate, $4,200 (for starters).

    The rotten pipe, by the way, is 2-inch. The two good ones are 1 and 1/2. Why the big one serves only a powder room sink and the two small ones serve laundry and kitchen, respectively, is a question for the ages. If it was 1935 and I was a plumber, I think I would do it the other way around.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The 2" might remain a mystery to the untrained eye but I find it a clue to what you may find under the slab.

    Code requires a cleanout on the upstream end of all main and branch drain lines. A toilet is required to be installed on the end of a line and a toilet can be lifted off the closet flange revealing a direct access to the line so a toilet is an approved cleanout. Therefore the line under the slab should be a direct run from the toilet to the main drain with the other lines tying into that run.

    A toilet is required to have a 3" or 4" line.

    Under the International Residential Code if a 3" is longer than 12' or a 4" longer than 16' it is required to have an auxillary vent. (Under the UPC it is 6' for a 3" or 10' for a 4")

    An auxillary vent may be reduced to 1/2 the diameter of the line it serves so if the cast iron line from the toilet is a 4" line it would require a 2" diameter vent.

    Code prohibits any horizontal venting until the line reaches an elevation of 6" higher than the flood level rim of the fixture it serves.

    Sight unseen I would guess that their solution was to run a 2" line from the 4" cast iron up to the powder room lavatory waste arm and continue the 2" up through the roof to make the auxillary vent. In this configuration the section of 2" from the powder room waste arm tee down to the 4" is technically classified as a wet vent for the 4".

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You're a genius, lazypup. Yes, the 2-inch drain from the sink extends up to the roof.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would love to be able to take a bow as a genius but the truth of the matter is I am no smarter than the average well trained plumber, on the other hand, this topic has emphasized another matter that I take very seriously.

    Quite often we see people who post comments scoffing the necessity for strict compliance with the plumbing codes but here we see yet another example of why the codes are important. According to the post this house was originally built in the 1930's so in all likelyhood there are no available prints of the layout and all the people who originally worked on this project are probably by now dead and gone but with a thorough knowledge of code we are able to understand the reasoning for the original layout and can make some fairly close educated guesses as to how to approach a problem 75 years later.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lazypup, were these provisions of the code in effect in the mid-30s? I know nothing of the plumbing code but I do know a little electricity and there a gazillion practices that were acceptable in the 30s (and that were built into this house) that are big no-nos today.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Out of curiosity I have been able to locate copies of old plumbing codes going back as far as 1929 and while we can definitely see that the codes have evolved with improvements in materials and methods nonetheless the fundamental basics have suprisingly changed very little. This is especially true in the DWV(Drain,Waste & Vent) systems.

    We are no longer permitted to combine sanitary and storm drains into a common sewer and many devices such as barrel traps, S-traps & whole house traps have been outlawed as well as cast iron pipe lead & oakum joints or lead pipe but the basic concepts of line sizing or the placement of vents and cleanouts has shown no significant changes.

    We do see signifacant additions to code as new materials became available such as ABS & PVC or new fixtures or appliances that required elements that were not previously used such as the addition of a laundry standpipe when automatic washers became available.

    Without a doubt the most noticable changes have to deal with water heaters. I remember when I was a child in the early 50's we had a Rheem water heater that had originally been installed in 1945. It was an uninsulated galvanized steel vessel with a flue up through the center and a gas burner underneath. All the seams were riveted and there was no Temperature & Pressure Relief Valve (T&P). Instead it had a blow out plug similar to the "Freeze Plugs" we see in an automotive engine block. A thermostat controlled the burner but there was no thermocouple safety device. It simply had a manual gas shut off valve for the burner and the standing pilot light that was fed by a small 1/4" diameter line with a separate shut off valve. I could not begin to count how many times we had been out for a day and came home to find the whole house full of gas because the pilot flame had blown out. In fact, as a kid I remember looking forward to that because it meant dad would open the front and back door then we would all get back in the car and he would take us to a restaruant to get a coke and allow the house some time to vent out. It must also be mentioned that water heaters did not have a flue pipe in those days. They simply vented into the room.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think if you can afford it, and you need to do one pipe now, do 'em all. It's not an emergency now, but it will be one day. To a prospective buyer, it's also a huge bonus, they'll know it's been done.