I am trying to restore an old wood screened porch with attached deck. I plan on painting the wood surfaces white and was considering screen tight for screening.

A friend pointed out that it may not look so good to have a white vinyl covering for the porch and then painted white wood on the deck. Also, my house is yellow painted clapboard. There is no siding what-so-ever on the house.

Do you think the vinyl screen tight would look weird with the wood or should I stick to covering the stapled screen with another piece of wood?

Your input is greatly appreciated. Thanks!