Software
Houzz Logo Print
hennie_gw

New to forum, kitchen help

17 years ago

Hello, I have been reading your forums, love the advice, have a ? of my own.

I live in an area limited in the brand of cabinets available. Kraftmaid, Schrock, Medallion, Merillat, Dynasty, Prestige. Any suggestions as to which is the better quality.

Also, if someone could tell me what I want. I am pretty sure I want plain, maple, cabinets, but I go round and round with the color. What do you guys love?

My house was built in the 70's, (and I still have the cabinets, I know I am pityful) split level, L shape kitchen, not an expensive house, but it's paid for.

Thanks for any help at all.

Sign me confused.

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    We used Kraftmaid in our other house. It was a good price; the customer service was fine; and the quality of the cabinets was satisfactory. We have a really quirky space now, so we needed something custom, otherwise we would have been happy with KM this time too.

  • 17 years ago

    Have you gone through the Finished Kitchens Blog (FKB)? Not only will you be able to see the cabinet "colors", but you'll also see various styles, including the one you're thinking of.

    The FKB can be browsed by user name as well as categories. Check out the navigation bar on the right once you're there. There's also an In-Progress Kitchens link for those kitchens that are not yet finished.

    To get the most out of your research & reading, I also recommend you read the "Read Me" thread, if you haven't already.

    Finished Kitchens Blog: http://finishedkitchens.blogspot.com/

    Read Me thread: http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0215535329506.html

  • 17 years ago

    We have Omega Dynasty, Omega's semi-custom line (not sure if it's the same Dynasty you're talking about). I'm very happy with everything about them...construction, finish, hardware, look. We needed a few custom cabinets so the custom line (Omega Custom) did those for us...same door style & finish but with the custom touches like matching finish inside & under the cabinets.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Buehl's Almost Finished Kitchen

  • 17 years ago

    "What do you guys love? "

    The best thing to do is look at many books, magazines, and the Finished Kitchens Blog as Buehl suggested to see what kitchens in what colors keep touching your heart. Save 'inspiration photos' until you see the similarities in kitchens you are drawn to that might show you what you'll love in yours. For you, we love what you'll love when it's done. ;-)

  • 17 years ago

    My contractor, who I really trusted, thought well of Omega/ Dynasty and felt that Medallion had the nicest finish for the price.

  • 17 years ago

    Have used both Schuler/Medallion and Kraftmaid cabinets. We did two seperate projects and purchased both brands from a big box store. While customer service was fine from both companies, when it came to construction, quality, and finish; IMHO there is no comparison. The Kraftmaids were poorly put together with cheap staples, excessive glue, and thin frames. The boxes themselves were frequently out of square, and often had to be fudged to get them to allign. The finish was blotchy in several areas, had exposed nail holes, and hardened glue on some faces. It was nowhere near the quality of the Schuler/Medallion cabinets. Sad part about this was that the price was nearly the same from both brands.

  • 17 years ago

    Medallion makes a really nice cabinet with a lovely finish, and at a lower price point than you'd expect from appearances. They're also very good about customizations.

    The advice about going through books, magazines and the Finished Kitchens Blog is really good advice. Better to take your time until you have an idea of what you like, than to rush through it and end up with something you're unsure of.

    If you can describe your ideal kitchen in 'mood words' that might also help. By 'mood words', I don't mean "maple, granite and stainless steel", but rather "light and bright (or dramatic), airy (or cozy), modern (or vintage)" -- Words that will help describe how you want your kitchen to feel.

  • 17 years ago

    I looked at Thomasville, Kraftmaid, Mouser (Beautiful, but too much $$$ for budget) and Medallion. I decided on Medallion with a painted finish. My Medallion cabinets have a beautiful finish and are much better quality in my eyes than Thomasville or Kraftmaid. Medallion also can be custom sized if you need it. My mom put in Medallion cabinets in maple with a medium finish, and she is also very happy. There are different price points with Medallion, so you have some choice in what features/quality that are important to you. Good luck with your decision. There are SO many choices out there.

    Barb

  • 17 years ago

    Are you sure that's all the brands available? I really can't comment on those brands, but there are a ton of brands out there. I've linked my list of cab websites below, if you want to take the time, you can see if there are some additional brands available near by.

    Don't forget to check out local cabinet makers for custom built cabs. They range in price, options and quality just as much as the brand names do.

    Here is a link that might be useful: cabinet manufacturers' websites