Software
Houzz Logo Print
lzydogrnch_gw

Hickory-too busy?

17 years ago

My husband loves the look of Natural Hickory cabinets. I'm afraid it will look too busy and limit my counter and backsplash choices. Our house is very "rustic" with lots of color and mexican influences. Any ideas, pictures out there? We are looking at Shiloh.

Thanks

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    I think it could work really well in a rustic house with a simple counter (something like soapstone, maybe!).

  • 17 years ago

    Go to the finished kitchens blog and view all of the beautiful hickory kitchens. I really wanted a hickory kitchen, but DH vetoed it. I really think it depends more on the door style and stain color than just the hickory. The hickory I have seen(and loved) was most beautiful in natural. Pecan is also hickory type woo, (or maybe ist is hickory) anyway, Omega and several other companies offer hickory and really, I think it is all beautiful. Take a couple of the door styles and stains home fro a few days and shop around with them. It will help you compare the cabs to the granites and floors you like and make it clearer to you regarding the rustic quality. HTH

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with Danielle00. I think you'd want to let the cabinets be the star, and go with something simpler for counter and backsplash. I like the look of hickory, though, and think it could look terrific in a rustic house.

  • 17 years ago

    Not all hickory cabinets on the market are the "rustic" hickory with a lot of streaks and knots. You may have more variation from door to door than with some other wood species, but I wouldn't necessarily call it crazy or super busy. Also, choosing darker stains will even out the streaking and color variation to a degree. I think hickory is a great choice. Good luck.

  • 17 years ago

    What kind of flooring do you have? Could you use hickory for the floors maybe? I love it--and it sounds like it would match the rustic/Mexican influences in your house.

    With that being said, I do like hickory for cabinets. Some hickory is busy--but not in the very tiny, grained way that oak is. I do wonder if the reason I like hickory for cabinets is that I never see them and they get the "unique" thumbs-up from my sensibilities. I wonder if I saw them in tons of kitchens if I would like them as much. Hmm...

    :)
    Sarah

  • 17 years ago

    Our new house is also leaning toward a rustic feeling, and my DH and I debated between using hickory and rustic alder. In the end, we chose rustic alder for it's knotty, distressed look. But I think hickory is a beautiful wood with all of its streaks and knots, especially with a natural finish. Definitely more busy than other cabinet woods, but it works well in a rustic setting.

    I also like the look of a hickory floor. Maybe DH would agree to that and let you have a toned down cabinet? What type of wood do YOU prefer? I might suggest taking a look at rustic alder or rustic maple, both a little less streaky and still give that rustic feeling. Kind of depends on how uniform you want your cabinets to look and feel, and what countertop material you are drawn to. The choices are endless - both a blessing and a curse! :-)