Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeff147

Help! House not Selling!

19 years ago

I don't get it. Almost 40 showings of this totally renovated house in most desirable area. Why no offers?

Can see pics at: http://www.basicthink.com/

MLS link on page.

We are in correct price range according to several agents. House shows 10+.

My wife and I are scratching our heads as to why no sale or offers yet. We fired first agent as she was not working the listing AT ALL. New agent gets constant feedback which is usually "very nice house, house to sell first, house just a bit small (around 1500 sq plus a completely finished studio apartment.)

Any advice?

Comments (47)

  • 19 years ago

    I think this house is adorable, but I'm going to offer this for your consideration... I noticed a pack of cigs and an ashtray on the kitchen counter. Has the house been smoked in consistently? That could turn off many people.

  • 19 years ago

    House looks like it's in great condition. You have nice neutral colors and it looks clean. I did notice the dog bowl. Are you sure the house doesn't smell like dog?

    Just a bit of advice. Being that the house is small, I'd clear off the counters and empty the sinks and snap some new pics of the kitchen.

    That said, the rooms do look on the small side. Plus, some people are turned off by all the levels. I don't know what the other homes in the neighborhood are like. If the house is vastly different than the surrounding homes, that could be a reason. Also, are your comps accurate? If the other homes are vastly different, comps are difficult. Establishing a market value is much more art than science. What does your agent say the problem is?

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    I noticed the same things, possibly smoker, definitely pets. If the home has the odor of smoke or pets it could turn off potential buyers. Often times homeowners do not detect these smells themselves, ask an unbiased person to come into your home and see if odors that could turn off a buyer are present. Barring that, your kitchen is very tiny, clean off the counters to maximize the space on the countertops and make your kitchen appear bigger. It looks as if you're in an area with a lot of similar homes, there should be comps that come close to your house. If you're getting a lot of buyers coming through and no offers, something in the back of my mind says it's not the price.

  • 19 years ago

    The house does come across as small, due to the large number of rooms for the square footage. The kitchen looks very cramped to me. While the paint is neutral, it also makes the house look a little sterile, with no personality. But I would do as others have suggested, which is get opinions from those who have been in the house and ask your realtor.

  • 19 years ago

    LOL! It's funny but everyone notices the pack of smokes on counter. Only the MLS pictures are seen by public so they do not have cigs or dog bowl in them. But I see what you mean with counters loaded with stuff. During showings there is virtually nothing on counters. Will try to take new shots of kitchen tho.

    Regarding smoke, yes my wife is a heavy smoker and absolutely refuses to stop smoking in the house. We have air filters running 24/7 to take some away. Regarding the dog, she goes out during every showing and there is absolutely no dog smell according to unbiased opinions. Smoke, yes, dog no.

    The house is similar to others on street but unique in its larger garage and backyard. Comps are within 10K and they were not renovated whatsoever. The difficulty is, these houses rarely come up for sale in this area; it is usually a much much older home, but a bigger lot and slightly different layout (much more $ too).

  • 19 years ago

    Well, there are a lot of people who are non-smokers. Under no circumstances would we buy or make an offer on a house that smells like smoke. No circumstances. I don't care how low the price is.
    Don't mind the dog or cat at all. A well behaved dog or cat in a house is fine.
    But, when our Realtor took us to look at houses, if we saw an ashtray, cigarettes, or smelled cigarette smoke - we'd immediately turn around and walk out. There are just too many houses to pick from.

  • 19 years ago

    If there is a definete smoke smell that that would do it for me. I couldn't stand it and it is really hard to get rid of even after a smoker moves out. Been there done that.

  • 19 years ago

    It's a cute house and should sell. However, cigarette smoke is very hard to get rid of and I wouldn't consider a house that had that odor. I grew up around smokers and never thought about it, but as an adult I've avoided exposure to the extent that it's very noticeable when I encounter it. I'm not trying to pile on here...just observing that, as smoking has declined in our society, people are increasingly sensitized to the odor and have a hard time intentionally exposing themselves to it, particularly with such an important purchase as a house.

  • 19 years ago

    Sorry, I have to agree with the other posters about the smoke. Also, the multiple levels and the narrow lot would be problems for me. I'm afraid you will either have to lower your price to make up for these drawbacks or resign yourself to a very long wait.

  • 19 years ago

    looks nice but small. too much white for me.white cabinets and trim is too much. need more warm colors.
    smoking would kill it for me too. would ditch the wood burner too. they are dirty and smelly and it would make me think it must cost a lot to heat this house if they need a wood burner.

  • 19 years ago

    It's a very nice-looking house--I love the wood floors and neutral wall colors. And the moldings. I have to agree with all the other posters about the smoke. When I was looking, if the house reeked of smoke, I didn't spend much time in it. Any kind of strong odor was a turn-off for me--smoke, ferrets, guinea pig cages--no thanks. I want to move in and not have to do any work, and those odors require painting and maybe re-doing drywall.

  • 19 years ago

    Ask your agent to be honest with you and tell you if anyone has complained about the smell of smoke. She might not want to offend you. Sorry, but that would kill a sale for me, too. You might want to hire a cleaning firm that has methods to alleviate the smell, and then encourage your wife to light up outside while you're selling. Other than that, make sure the price is right for a house that size.

  • 19 years ago

    Jeff, the smell of cigarette smoke would stop me at the front door.I would not even enter once i caught a whiff of it,no matter what the price..Perhaps if your wife reads all these comments about the zero interest in homes that reek of cigarette smoke, she might quit..You have a very tough situation on your hands, and it isn 't something that can be remedied quickly..The smell lingers in everything,furniture,walls,ac ductwork,etc..best of luck to you

  • 19 years ago

    In case you need some more evidence to present to your wife, I also would not buy a home with a strong cigarette odor.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi, Jeff.

    I'm with the rest - it's the smoke. Big, big turn-off for a lot of buyers. If the house is in character with the other homes in the area, and you've priced it right, it's got to be the smell.

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    If there's smoking IN the house, I hate to chime in but you're in trouble.

    Each time I've been on the hunt, if when the Realtor opens the door I'm hit with ciggy smell, I'm hightailing it back to the car.

    If the homeowners are there, I try my best to breathe as little as possible, smile politely as going through as fast as possible, gasp out "thank you, it's very nice", and then hightail it back to the car, lol.

    In fact one time I was so annoyed that they were showing a home that smelled that bad just at the foyer, I looked at my realtor and said "I can't even do this, sorry", and left her there to offer the smoke outside till your home is sold advice, while I waited at the car.

    Also, as pretty as your home is, ALL your surfaces will have a coating of cig smoke gunk, no matter how clean you are.

    You many need to lower your price to entice someone to overlook the smoke and snatch up a bargain.

    Perhaps if your wife realized it's smoke outside or 10k, she'll be persuaded?

    I'll go check out the house now. Sorry so long,

    Nat

  • 19 years ago

    I be put off by the smells of smoke, too.

    The home looks small, but the captions on the photos say the opposite (plenty of counterspace, huge master). I know this may be a private site, but it makes me wonder if the writer is able to be honest and objective.

    I know you think it is priced right, but, with 40 showings and no offers, it is almost certainly overpriced. The price should reflect the odor. Your wife probably has no idea just how expensive smoking can be :(.

  • 19 years ago

    Unfortunately, at this point, getting your wife to smoke outside will probably not help much. The smell is in the walls, carpet, draperies and ductwork, and is very difficult to get rid of. I got a deal on a beautiful leather sofa and loveseat that had belonged to heavy smokers. We put them in the garage to get them cleaned up and could still smell them inside the house. We tried numerous cleaning products and deordizers and even removed the cushions and throughly cleaned them. Nothing worked and we eventually sold them at a garage sale (after warning the buyers of the smoke smell). Multiply that by a whole house and you really have a problem. Sorry :(

  • 19 years ago

    Quip I noticed that about the captions on the pictures as well -- it's a very small home, but the captions seemed to exaggerate quite a bit. That being said, the OP is getting people through the home, so I don't think it's the captions that are bothering people. It appears that smoke is indeed the problem. I'm very sensitive to smoke, but once got a great deal on a car for my son because it reeked of smoke. I don't think he ever got rid of the smoke smell in that car. Some people may overlook the smoke smell if they get a great deal.

  • 19 years ago

    Ditto with the above.....every house I looked at that smelled like cigarette smoke was an instant "X" off the list, DOA, No way Jose, the kiss of death, get me outta here!!!!

    I would suggest that your wife review these posts.

  • 19 years ago

    Add another who will not buy a smoked-in house.

    I am not sure what you will be able to do. Some buyers do smoke, so just keep waiting and one may go through and love the house, not notice the smoke, and you have a sale. I would divide the 40 showings by the statistics on what fraction of the population smokes in your area and figure that you house had only been seen by that many people.

    How is the market in your area? What is the average days on market this winter, and how far above that are you?

    Your wife's smoking is just going to slow things down. Not much you can do, and nothing she can do at this point. Be patient, don't place blame and just accept the extended marketing time. Are you tied into a timeframe, or can you be flexible about when you move?

  • 19 years ago

    The pictures and the descriptions (albeit highly exaggerated) may be getting the traffic in, but the cig smell and the reality of the small size is probably what's causing the problem.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with asking your realtor to tell you the truth about the smoking smell. We had a similar issue but with dog odors. After several showings but no sale a potential buyer spoke up and told her realtor, who reluctantly told mine, who reluctantly told me. They didn't want to offend me ... but as soon as I heard about the problem I fixed it. Professional housecleaning, rugs removed (we had wood floors), dogs banished to an outside pen during the day while I was gone, frequent dog baths. And then the house sold quickly.

    Tell your realtor you really want to know about any negative responses and that you won't be insulted. I was surprised that my realtor (12+ years experience and he knew us from a previous transaction) didn't want to tell me of the problem. The whole point of this is to sell your house, so you have to look at it objectively and just get it done.

    Good luck with your wife.

  • 19 years ago

    Add me to the list of people who wouldn't buy a smoker's house unless I was in a *very* tight market.

    It wouldn't be so much how bad it was when I walked in. But if I can detect it at all, I know I'll be spending money getting the smell permanently out.

    Also, it's not just the smell. Cigarette smoke stains everything. I'd be thinking of the hours and hours spent scrubbing the hard surfaces.

  • 19 years ago

    It was in August 2002 when I was notified that my company was closing in December. I began preparing my house to sell as I would then retire. Next thing I knew my neighbors two houses down put their home up for sale, they too were reitring and purchased a home in warmer climate. I thought I would wait before putting mine up as I did not want to compete with them. I had the time to wait, they did not. After a few months, I went to an open house there to compare my recent improvements with their home. The first thing that hit me was the smell. He is a heavy smoker. Their realtor was a neighbor too, we talked a bit, but I did not have a heart to tell her to rip out the carpets, and put fresh paint in every room, as I liked the sellers and did not want to hurt their feelings. Well, my company closed, my house was ready for the market and I found a new place for me in the country. By the way the houses on the block were all built post war and were of the same general layout and size. Each had individual additions and changes, but were very similar. Their kitchen was beautifully imporoved, mine was just okay. It was now late January and their house still did not sell. I put my house up and sold it in 8 days. I mentioned to my realtor that someone should tell them to freshen the house and he jumped all over me."they are nice people, how can you say that?" Yes, they were very nice people, wonderful neighbors, so no one could look them in the eye and tell them what was obvious to everyone else. Their house finally sold the day of my closing, April 2nd. All houses will sell eventually. Yours is a lovely home and I bet that your friends and neighbors don't want to hurt you feeling either... in the long run that hurts your pocketbook. The good news is there are still a lot of people that smoke, you can wait until one of them wants to buy your house.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you for all the feedback so far. Each bit has helped.

    Nancy, I think you are right in looking at it statistically regarding the smoking because the fact is, I can't stop my wife from smoking in the house even if it meant 10K reduction. Yes smoking can cost up to 1/4 of someones income! Statistically 1/5 of population in Ontario smokes. This means there has only been 8 true showings.

    I am going to sit with the realtor tomorrow to have an "honest talk" with him and let him talk to wife.

    I will write articles about this experience once done as it has been one of the most trying events of our relationship. But I am seeing the other end (purchasing) of what I do with house flipping (Karma I guess).

    Regarding the pictures, please realize the buying public is not seeing these pictures or captions, only the MLS listing at: http://www.mls.ca/PropertyDetails.aspx?PropertyID=5341527. The room sizes are all listed there. The funny thing about this house is you wouldn't think it was functional or big enough till you actually live in it. It is more "living" space than your average bungalow or 2 story, minus the un-used basement space. The master bedroom is so big it should have been two rooms (family and bedroom). But I guess it is a love it or leave it layout. It is the most built model on the street making up about 20% of the homes on street and the last one that was for sale was ours and the neighbors over 8 years ago.

  • 19 years ago

    I mentioned to my realtor that someone should tell them to freshen the house and he jumped all over me."they are nice people, how can you say that?"

    Nice people need to be told the truth, to not tell them is mean.

  • 19 years ago

    Jeff, there's no reason why your wife can't limit her smoking to the garage is there. I smoke and smoked for years in our previous house but fortunately I was in Calgary and the house sold within hours as is.. Anyways I'm in my new house now and even though I still smoke, there is NO smoking in this house period. I have to go into my garage or on the back deck if I want to light up.

  • 19 years ago

    Jeff,

    I'm a smoker and agree with everyone else - it's the smoke. There is no way to completely rid yourself of the smell, but I do have one suggestion. Place some small bowls with about 1/2 cup of vinegar throughout the house. It does absorb a great deal of the smell. Not all, but most.

    How do I know this? Well, in my younger days when I still lived at home and my parents went away for the winter, I was ordered no smoking in the house. Since they were gone three months, I said yeah right. A week before they came home, I stopped smoking in the house, placed bowls of vinegar everywhere and they never said one word about the smell when they came back.

    Febreeze is also great on fabric curtains, sofas, etc.

    You won't get rid of the entire smell, but you can at least minimize it.

  • 19 years ago

    Jeff,

    Can your arrange your affairs to move out of this house so you can remove all your furniture, clothing etc.? Then have a a deep cleaning, a quick repaint job, and also re-carpet, etc. That may reduce it enough to get it sold w/o having to get your wife to stop smoking just now. Frankly, even if she stopped TODAY, your house and everything in it will still reek to non-smokers, which will be a turn-off until it is remediated. Bowls of vinegar, fabric freshners, etc, simply can't undo the effects of long-term exposure, especially in climate like yours where the house is closed for months on end.

    From time to time I buy items on eBay, and despite being described as "smoke free", some unopened boxes never make it past my front porch because they smell so bad. If it's textiles sometimes I can wash the smell away, but the worst offenders are books, since they can't be immersed. Everything in your house probably has that smell, so simply better cleaning won't do the trick. Physical removal of the items, then deep cleaning, repainting, replacement of carpets, etc. may get it done.

    I'm sorry that you are faced with this, but at least you're getting remarkably consistent comments. I don't think it's merely the effect of anti-smoking zealots; it's the real, visceral response from people who don't smoke to the aesthetic experience of such a stinky environment.

    Good luck,

    Molly~

  • 19 years ago

    If you could get wife to smoke outside just until it sells, you might be able to get a professional cleaning service to de-smell the place. My inlaws smoke outside and though they smell awful, their house smells ok (not the upholstered stuff).

    Yeah, I'm one of THOSE people who can't stand the smell, and a 10k price reduction would not be enough.

  • 19 years ago

    I recently SOLD a condo because the unit owner next door to mine smoked and I could smell it. NEVER EVER would I BUY a home that a smoker lived in.

    I'm an EX-smoker myself, going on ten years now.

  • 19 years ago

    Jeff, most homeowners (myself included) are deeply attached to our homes. The attachment/pride of ownership is wonderful...until it is time to sell. Like most people, I find it hard to see my home objectively, and it makes it much harder to be realistic about selling. I think you are having some trouble with that, too. Why do I think so? From those captions on your private website and from your postings here. An 18'8" x 10'11" master is nice not huge by today's standard, and it is not big enough to be split into a FR plus BR (about 9x11 each--that's two small BR or offices maybe). You can't change the size and you feel you can't reduce of the smell; doesn't it come down to price?

    I know many smokers who don't lit up in the home and would not buy a smoky house. I know many light smokers who would be put off by heavy smoke. I know many families with only one smoker who would walk away from your home. I know many smokers who can't afford your home. Even though 20% of your population smokes, I think your target audience is smaller. JMHO.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with Quip 100%. Although in a very small home like the OP has, a 19 x 11 bedroom is large (still not big enough to be split off into two rooms though). The smoke smell could be overlooked by some for the right price. So if you can't get rid of the smoke smell, reevaluate your price.

  • 19 years ago

    in all honesty, price would have no affect on me to purchase this home..The smoke and smoke residue would be just too great.. The home i recently purchased had a "garlic" type smell, the previous owners were from Korea, and it has taken 6 months for the smell to dissipate, though on warm sunny days, the smell is evident to a small degree..And the house has been painted completely, hardwood floors cleaned, every surface wiped down...

  • 19 years ago

    Qdog -- a lower price wouldn't make me buy the house either, but to some people looking for a deal -- the lower price could influence them.

  • 19 years ago

    I don't understand how most of the posts on this thread are in any way useful to the seller. There are still plenty of smokers, very many of whome own houses and,, amazing thought it may seen, they actually manage to sell their houses.

    While it may be cathartic to vent your abhorance at the mere though of buying a smoker's house, that's totally missing the point. The OP has a house to sell, his wife smokes heavily and even if he could convince her to stop smoking in the house, that's not going to alter the fact that it has been smoked in all these years.

    Surely there's got to be SOMEONE on hear who found themselves in the same position as the OP and (gasp!) managed to sell the house. Maybe they'd be kind enough to tell us how they did it?

  • 19 years ago

    feedingfrenzy, RELAX...The OP asked why ,perhaps, was his home not getting offers..And the response has been, THE SMOKING SMELL , from a plethora of respondents.So, i believe, this was/is helpful..And most of us added, we'd likley not buy the home regardless of price .

  • 19 years ago

    Sometimes it's hard to admit that you're not on a level playing field with other homes for sale that are your comps. We had to admit this to ourselves about our house because of our trashy neighbors. Bottom line is that their house makes our house less desireable than other similar homes.

    But Jeff, be happy that you at least have control over the problem with your property!

    Who was it on this Forum who said you could sell Chernobyl if the price was right? ;)

  • 19 years ago

    "Who was it on this Forum who said you could sell Chernobyl if the price was right? ;)"
    I wouldn't take it if it was a gift, just think of the clean up cost.
    At the same time, this is from a 40 year smoker who quit 23 months ago, but didn't smoke in the last 2 homes I owned. The clean up, such as paint, carpet etc. for a non-smoker needs to be taken into consideration when selling, and I'm sure prospective buyers just could not look bejond the smoke smell.

  • 19 years ago

    I suggest your wife stop smoking in the house and that you clean it or have it cleaned very well. Try the vinager, open some windows(if it isn't too cold).

    I believe the smell will go away after awhile. My mom smoked in her house for 9 months before she went into the hospital and quit smoking. We are selling her house now(she passes away last month from COPD)and you can not tell the house was smoked in.

  • 19 years ago

    What kind of air filters do you have? I think that can be key. I have sold two homes that were smoked in. One sold the first day it was on the market to the first people that saw it for full asking price. I think limiting the smoking to one room and the appropriate air filters and airing out of the room do help tremendously.

  • 19 years ago

    I know many smokers who don't lit up in the home and would not buy a smoky house. I know many light smokers who would be put off by heavy smoke. I know many families with only one smoker who would walk away from your home. I know many smokers who can't afford your home. Even though 20% of your population smokes, I think your target audience is smaller.

    Unfortunately, I think this is dead on. I have a number of friends who smoke, but only one of them smokes heavily in all parts of their house. For the rest, they smoke outside or or they stick to one room.

  • 19 years ago

    Once the decision is made to sell a home, the owners have to stop thinking of it as home and instead, as a product to be sold. Eliminate all evidence of smoking in the house and stop smoking in it. Baking soda on carpets and upolstered fabrics and a vacume will eliminate the odor to all but the most sensitive nose.

    I would eliminate some of the pix on your website ( toilets, for example) and instead focus on more pix of key rooms, from different angles.

    In terms of pricing, make absolutely certain you are priced to CLOSED comps, not the competition. Just because your neighbor thinks his place will sell for $ 1 Million does not mean beans to anyone. What matters are the facts of what homes sold for recently. Pay attention to the location of the comps too, as location matters.

    Andin the end, no amount of marketing can overcome a bad price.

  • 19 years ago

    Wow! What a debate. Sorry about the instigation of it. Update: A discussion with the new agent revealed he is no where near concern about the smoke. Quote: "if there was a choice between the house not selling because of smoke smell and price, price would win out EVERYTIME." Not sure if this was an unbiased opinion but we began to look at comps. He showed me next door sold for $257K. However, I know after many decisions that the new owner has put in over $30K in work to bring up to livable let alone comparable to our home (even with smoke smell  old and new owners smoke). Two doors down, house sold for $279K needed kitchen, floors and no finished basement. Slightly larger. New owners have put about $20 into so far (paint, floors and walkway).

    A discussion with two honest friends is that smoke is not noticeable when filters are running 24/7. Non-smokers here. Yes I know it is noticeable because I can smell myself. I cannot debate smoker/non anymore, it is just not fixable as feedingfrenzy says (remember folks, I am non-smoker and even recently lost family to it). Agent said only one person honestly commented on smoke smell and they would have put offer in if it was not for financing up to $280K (agent could not get it thru).

    Agent is not worried about price just yet. Said to wait till weekend to drop if so. There is still cold weather and snow on ground to slow buyers from putting offers.

    Lessons:

    1)Do not sell your own home for profit. Buy another, fix it up and sell. If you cant make money doing this, donÂt buy it in the first place.
    2)Hammybee and Quip. I fully agree, once the house is up for sale it is no longer ours. I walk in after each showing and see myself only visiting the house.
    3)PeopleÂs perceptions differ. DonÂt let it upset you. It is a product to sell nothing more.
    4)Any house will sell. ItÂs a matter of Location, Condition and Price. Its just a matter of time.
    5)Agent also said the house sold next door because of price alone. Neighbor said it took 18 showings to sell even tho it was two heavy smokers and smelled of cat urine.

    I will keep people up to date on progress and try to get more opinions.

  • 19 years ago

    Every Christmas we have a big dinner party where there is much eating and drinking and smoking of fine cigars - and occassionally my husband would light up a cigar - go buy yourself a Lampe Berger or one of the many knock offs - you can find tons on Ebay - We have two cats, but used to have 2 bassetts and a beagle - and between repainting, getting the carpets cleaned, keeping your house clean and using the Lampe Berger - no one has ever mentioned that they smell anything - I've had realtors come over armed with various air fresheners for open houses and never used them. Of course that does not solve the problem with constant heavy smoking in the house - you might suggest she limit herself to one room or one level so you and she can sort of isolate it, keep the windows open whenever possible and you can buy an unscented fuel for the Lampe Berger that will clean and freshen your home's air without leaving any smell. You really need to do a deep clean before you fire up the Lampe Berger. My maid uses Odo-Ban and swears by it. My house always smells great when I get home and she has been here.

    Every house has a smell - simply from years of people living in it - remember how your Grandmother's house smelled? I loved it - smelled like Grammie. Actually it smelled like her baking which may be why many people are said to react pleasantly to the smell of cookies and bread baking. The lamps work well too for homes where there are elderly residents - people who own them swear by them. Nothing tops opening up the windows and airing out your house though regardless of what your specific odor problem might be. Especially in the winter when houses are closed up and the various people and food smells recirculate. Drives my family crazy when I open the windows and it's cold outside.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm a smoker. My husband is not; therefore I'm a VERY considerate smoker. DH is also sensitive to offensive smells.

    That said, our last two homes were purchased from smokers, and one of those homes had a horrendous dog odor. These smells can be eliminated with elbow grease, new paint, and professional cleaning of a home.

    We purchased both of the houses based on location, size, layout, and most important PRICE. Both were reduced, both purchased "as is", and both had features we felt out weighed the sweat equity we invested. May I suggest that you offer a professional cleaning as part of the closing package to sweeten any offers that come your way?

    Best of luck to you.