Software
Houzz Logo Print
carla35_gw

Do you have to sell?

19 years ago

A friend just called me with a question...

If you put your house up for sale and someone draws up a contract for the asking price and you accept...can you (the seller) still get out of the sale before closing? The seller has decided they don't want to sell after all. What are their options? Thanks.

Comments (19)

  • 19 years ago

    You could sue for specific performance, but the time it would take may not be worth the bother.

    On one of my trips to FL I found a house for our best friends. It was just what they wanted and they made an offer. Each offer was rejected. They finally offered asking price and the seller's then said, no, they wanted more. My friends were bummed, so I told them to tell the agent that showed them the house (not the listing agent) to contact the listing agent and demand payment of the commission since he brought a qualified able buyer ready to pay asking price. The listing agent couldn't believe it, but knew they were right. The listing agent told the sellers they would still owe the commission (sale price $500,000 so commission was big) if they decided not to sell.

    My friends now own the house!

    Good luck with your dilemma,

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    If the sellers aren't backing out for a reason specified in the contract, but have simply "changed their mind", I believe the buyers can sue for monetary damages or specific performance.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Backing out of a deal

  • 19 years ago

    When I bought my current house from a builder the contract gave the seller rights to terminate the sale at any time for any reason. I tried like mad to get them to take that out of the contract but they wouldn't. thankfully there was no problem with it but suppose I had made all these arrangements and temrinated the lease I was in then only to find out, oops sorry we don't want to sell to you. Check the contract first and see if there's anything like that in there and if not call a RE atty and see what they say.

  • 19 years ago

    As a buyer, I would be highly upset that the seller has change their mind in selling their home. I would think they would have to pay, for some type of inconvenience.

    That's just my opinion.

  • 19 years ago

    If your friends were pretty far into the process, I'd seriously consider talking to a lawyer about specific damages. Depending on how far into the process they were, they could have already incurred a number of expenses, like appraisal, home inspection, etc. that they may want to talk to an attorney about.

  • 19 years ago

    Talk to a lawyer about remedies. It will be money well spent.

  • 19 years ago

    I wonder why sellers are not required to put good faith/earnest money like buyers while signing the contract?Seems like that should protect buyer's interests in situations like these..

  • 19 years ago

    If the buyers are meeting all their contingencies as specified by the dates on the contract, the sellers will have a really hard time backing out. In my county, I'm told that there have been historically extremely few cases of the sellers even being able to get this to court, let alone getting a favorable judgment.

  • 19 years ago

    The short answer to that is no. It is a binding contract. The long answer is the buyers could get a court order to perform under the contract and the one thing the other poster left out - the court could also and probably would - order the seller to pay the buyer's court costs and attorney's fees and any other incidental costs or expenses.

    The lawyer answer is - it depends on how badly the buyers want the house or need to move into the house they have a binding contract on.

    Maybe money will buy out the prospective buyers.

  • 19 years ago

    According to the post by Finesse, the seller must sell even if there is no contract yet? Are you saying that a seller cannot put their home on the market and change their mind before a contract has been signed? That doesn't seem right.

  • 19 years ago

    The sellers can absolutely change their mind before the contract is signed, they cannot be forced to sell at that point. What they may owe (depending on the listing agreement that they signed) is the RE commission if an agent brought a ready, willing and able buyer with a full price offer.

    In the case posted by finesse, it looks like the sellers decided to go ahead and sell but they were not *obligated to sell.

  • 19 years ago

    That is an interesting point that I had not thought of. We are getting ready to sell, but we also have to find a suitable home to purchase. So if I put my home on the market, and someone offers me full price, but I cannot find a suitable home to purchase at that time, I need to sell anyway or risk paying the realtor fee? Wow, that makes it even harder to buy/sell, especially if you are determined not to buy before selling.

  • 19 years ago

    Laura's interpreted my post correctly. The sellers in my friend's situation were not obligated to sell since there wasn't a contract yet. They were obligated to pay the commission, though.

    Think about it, Georgia. A realtor doesn't take any money from a seller up front. Yet, they expend a lot of time and money marketing your home. They get paid when they sell your home. If they do their job and produce a ready, willing, and able buyer, at full asking price, the realtor's done everything they agreed to do. Once they've done that, they've earned their commission. In most cases, you'll owe them if you back out or change your mind. It's only fair.

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    Kevin,
    Is this situation *only* in the instance of a full price offer? What if your friends offered even $1 less than asking, would it have been the same outcome?

  • 19 years ago

    Georgialivin what you do is put in the contract with the buyers a contingency that gives you "x" days to find a home. Done all the time, but a buyer may not like your contingency if you are asking for too much time. Juggling simultaneous or consecutive closings can be an adventure but it is not unusual at all. It's all a matter of timing. Your real estate attorney is probably painfully experienced in handling such closings. Or rather his paralegal is.

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, my real estate agent told me about adding a contingency to get a contract on a home to buy. But the posts here seem to conclude that if someone offers full price, then the seller must take their offer or owe a commission, because a valid qualified buyer was brought. If this is true even before a contract is signed, then if the buyer doesn't want a contingency, the seller is out of options?

    Maybe it's a moot point, since apparently full-price offers are few and far between these days!

  • 19 years ago

    Hi, Sparksals.

    It's my understanding it has to be at least a full price offer to trigger the commission. It could be more, but not less.

    I would also think that if the offer includes a contingency, the seller could refuse even a full price offer and not owe that commission.

    I'm not in the real estate profession. I'm not even sure how I learned of this years ago. It's apparently valid since it worked for my friends. Their realtor was a bit reluctant to go to the seller's realtor with the demand for commission, saying we don't usually do business like that here (SW Florida), but conceded that I was right. When my friends' realtor presented this to the other realtor, they couldn't believe it, but agreed it's a valid claim. It was this demand that compelled the sellers to agree to the full price offer. Needless to say, it was a "cold" transaction.

    What was different in my friends' situation that the OP's friend is the seller wanted to sell but felt they could get more than they were asking. Too bad. In the OP's situation, it appears the seller's decided not to sell. However, there's a contract, so even if it may be less than full asking price, the commission is still due, since the seller, by virtue of signing the contract, agreed to the terms. The realtor did their job, and earned the commission.

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    All of this is spelled out in the contract you have with your agent. Rather than speculate, read the contract and have it vetted by your lawyer.

  • 19 years ago

    wow this is really interesting...When I found a house I wanted I had my realtor call and give the full price offer, minus fixing the stack in the basement (they had most of it duct tapped, wierd). They declined so I said to heck with it and found another house and god, what a horrible choice I made but that is for another post...