Software
Houzz Logo Print
hisgal2

Anyone with a painted floor???

17 years ago

I have lurked here off and on for nearly a year now. My husband and I bought a very old house in a nice little (read: tiny) town in PA. By old, I mean the house was built in 1892. We plan to basically remodel the entire house slowly. The kitchen was the first choice since it would be the most expensive and I was going insane with the condition that it was in. The kitchen was originally 2 rooms. One room being the original kitchen to the house (which was built before plumbing and electric) which was a 6'x9' room that had a bottom cabinet, a wall cabinet, a sink, and a wall pantry in it. The other room measured 11' x20' and it had the stove, 1 cabinet with a counter piece on it, a wall cabinet, and the refrigerator.

Because we didn't really know what we wanted to do with the kitchen, we did what we did know needed done. I tore down the ceiling tiles to see what was going on in the ceiling (very glad I did), we ripped up the 2 and 3 layers of flooring to look at the original floor (which is wood but cannot be refinished), we removed the wall that separated the two rooms, and installed three I beams to support the ceiling where the removed wall was and to support the ceiling in the larger room since the floor joists for the 2nd floor were hung across the 20' distance instead of the 11' distance and the floor sagged 7" in the middle.

Anyways, my goal for the kitchen is for it to be inviting and casual and to fit in the house and the house's age. Everything will be DIY, so it will be a slower remodel. My goal is to have the kitchen completed by the end of summer. Right now, the floor is on my mind. We cannot do any kind of tile because the floor will not be able to hold the weight of the tile. I wish we could sand and refinish the original floor, but it is in too bad of shape to do that. I have seen a couple examples online of people laying 3/4" plywood on the floor and using a router to put grooves into the plywood. It ends up looking like a hardwood floor. The floor would be sanded and cleaned after the routing and then would have 5 or 6 coats of poly applied to protect it. My husband thinks that the wood floor would be too much wood in the kitchen with the cabinets that I've picked out (a knotty oak cabinet). I've decided that we'll lay the floor and I'll put the grooves in and then we'll decide if it is going to look like too much wood (he's afraid it will make the kitchen too dark...there is only 1 very small window in the kitchen). So, I thought about painting the floor. I haven't thought of a color or anything, but I'm wondering if anyone has gone with a painted floor? Here is a link to what we've done thus far just to give you an idea of what we are dealing with.

Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen Remodel thus far

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    If the floor will hold the weigh of 3/4" plywood then it will easily hold some of the new laminated flooring products which come in many different finishes and colors.
    Secondly there are new lightweight tiling products that lay in segments of several squares, self adhesive and easy to install. My best friends used this product (purchased at HD) to put down a new floor in the sunroom, breakfast area and kitchen of their vacation home in Florida which is an older model manufactured doublewide with just OSB subflooring. This really turned out well and gets alot of compliments. Lastly the last home i renovated had beautiful old pine floors but they were badly stained in some areas that we couldnt get them to look good so I researched old painted floor techniques and we ended up painting a decorative border around all of the edges, a multicolor checkerboard in another and painted a simulated old country rug in the breakfast area then put a coat of satin finish poly over the entire floors. Looked great and blended well with the "country" style of the post and beam house.

  • 17 years ago

    Floors can be painted successfully with proper prep and several top coats, but before you pull out the paint supplies you should step back and try the Sweeby test. Basically close your eyes and describe the feel you want for your room. Sophisticated, homey, airy, beachy, bistro, eclectic, whatever. Use a few words. Then decide on whether or not a painted floor works with your vision.

    Painted floors look great in clean lined Scandinavian rooms with washed out colors. They also can work nicely in some Victorian rooms with the appropriate bolder colors or country style rooms. The caveat of course is that if you are using the painted floor as a stop gap for just until you can afford what you really want, you may end up with height issues. Painting the floors now, installing cabs and counters, then laying tile later may lead to a height difference that won't allow your DW to fit into it's hole.

    Good luck with your decision and keep us posted with updated pics.

  • 17 years ago

    faucetman886~
    The issue with laying any kind of tile on this floor is that the floor is not flat. It ripples. So we'd have to lay some new subfloor and then put whatever tile on top of it...adding to the weight the floor is holding. We have one floor jack supporting the floor where there is a post that holds a beam that is supporting the ceiling where we removed the wall. There are also a couple of spots on the floor where we need to replace the wood just because it wasn't supported correctly.

    laxsupermom~
    I saw the Sweeby test. I think the look of a painted hardwood floor would be OK. The kitchen in my mind's eye is kind of like an updated country kitchen. I don't really have the kitchen or style vocabulary that I'm looking for here tho. When we removed the wall that separated the two rooms of the kitchen, we saved the plank (old plank construction house...if any of you know what that is). My plan is to box in the 3 beams that were placed in the ceiling with the plank to make them look like wooden beams after we put in the drywall that will be the ceiling. Does that makes sense?

    I'm trying to find a picture of the cabinets that we will be ordering, but I'm not having any luck. On the estimate under cabinet lines it says Heritage 648 and then under doors it says Plantation. I know that the wood is a knotty oak and I love that the coloring of the cabinets is both dark and light. Its really hard to plan anything in terms of light and dark until we get the cabinets because knotty oak varies depending on what lot of wood is used, kwim? Anyways, my mind's eye has a picture of a warn painted kitchen floor and I like that thought. Here is a picture of the outside of the house just to give you an idea of the style.

  • 17 years ago

    I personally love a painted floor, whether it has a pattern to it or is just painted one single color. I have several friends who have painted floors and they love theirs as well. I think I read somewhere that marine grade paint used for decks, etc. on boats is the best way to go, along with a good top sealer. Like someone else said, it does take a bit of prep work though. I tried to talk my husband into letting me get cheaper hardwood and paint it, but he wasn't onboard with the whole concept. :(

    I think painted floors can say country as well as beachy and so they are attractive in many different settings. If you want a pattern but don't think you'll want it forever, you could always paint the floors and then paint an floor cloth to go on top of it to add some interest too. A stenciled floor cloth was a very popular alternative for people who couldn't afford expensive wool rugs.

    Good luck and your house is lovely...the flowering tree (redbud?) out front is stunning and those are some very nice old boxwoods on the side!

    Kat :)

    Here is a link that might be useful: How to paint wood floors

  • 17 years ago

    I think the idea of a painted floor is a good one, but you don't say why your wood floors can't be used. If you're worrying that they'll be too thin, chemical remover or sanding with a belt sander (or someone who knows how to handle a floor sander) can easily take off just a bare minimum; they don't need to look like new.

  • 17 years ago

    There are several Federal era houses in my neighborhood that have painted floors. It's a common historic finish. Along the way, someone paints.

    In fact my nearly 200-year old house has some areas of floor that are still painted, most recently probably in the 1940s. As I fix things or move walls or heavy things they are revealed. I leave them as artifacts because I think they are cool.

    Black, gray, red, dark green, blue were common colors. Black shows a bit more dust, but floor paint is a bit glossy, so it reflects light and it's not as dark and depressing as it sounds. In one house, the owner has a nice scuffed floor and some nice shabby orientals and some old furniture and bits mummy had lying around (worth a mint) and it looks amazing.

    A good painted floor is definitely better than a cheap stop-gap solution you're not going to be happy with that's still more money than you want to spend. Do it right though, or you WILL have problems.

    Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    The planks that make up the floor run in two different directions. That would drive me absolutely INSANE. Also, the plank in the original part of the kitchen (the smaller half) is extremely dry and would not do well with sanding and painting. Just walking and slightly dragging your feet will pull splinters up. This is 117 year old wood that was not taken care of. I realize they don't need to look new...I'm not asking my floors to look new, but splintering wood will just not do.
    Attached is a link to a picture that was taken by someone who has done this to many rooms in her house (laying plywood and routing out grooves and then painting). I love how it looks

    Here is a link that might be useful: faux wood planks

  • 17 years ago

    What a great tree! And I love your porch, too. Since you've already taken the Sweeby test and the painted floor works in that vision, I say go for it. I also vote yes for boxing in the beams. I can't wait to see your progress. I always love the pics from fellow DIYers even though it reinforces how pokey we've been finishing our project.

  • 17 years ago

    I painted my LR floor about 2 yrs ago. It is a large area and I needed to have the carpet out of there. I primed and painted over plywood subfloor...love it! BM floor and porch paint

    Barb

  • 17 years ago

    laxsupermom~ Its been a little frustrating so far....and that is mostly because of the age of the house and how it was built. Plank construction is unlike any other kind of construction. There are no wall studs and most people who don't have a clue about it wonder how the structure even stands. I've been living with a torn up kitchen for nearly a year now. We had stopped working on the kitchen so that we could rewire the house's electric. Nearly the entire house was on one 30 amp circuit. The more wiring we did, the more we wondered why the house hadn't already burnt down! So, now we are finally getting around with the kitchen again.

    Barb~ Thanks soo much for commenting! I always hesitate posting my weird idea on forums like this because nearly everyone is getting contractors to do their work and are putting in higher end kitchens and buying things that I could only dream of. Compared to that, a plywood floor sounds gross, kwim? But in all reality, a high end kitchen would look really out of place in my little old house.

Sponsored
Trish Takacs Design
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars36 Reviews
Award Winning & Highly Skilled Kitchen & Bath Designer in Columbus