Software
Houzz Logo Print
martmo_gw

Main Drain Sump

17 years ago

What are the pro/cons of pre-formed sump or site built sump for a residential pool?

Is it builder preference?

Thanks

Martin

Comments (23)

  • 17 years ago

    Pre-Formed

    Pros

    Known flow capabilities
    Drain cover screw holes
    Less exposed gunite
    Less chance of leaking around the pipe fitting
    Nice place to hide/find threaded hydrostatic relief plugs

    Cons:

    Hayward and Pentair only go to 2" plumbing
    Can leak between body and gunite if not done right.

    Sight Built

    Pro

    Nothing to buy
    Can use larger than 2 inch plumbing

    Con

    Cover screws set in gunite/plaster are difficult to remove without messing up the hole.
    Requires more gunite on the floor or wall
    Not a good place to put hydrostatic plugs

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    The VGB/AMSE codes are pretty specific. I don't see a company building a " site built sump" in todays world. A drain pot is under $30 .... With the specific flow rate requirements of an AMSE cover it could be quite illegal if the is not to the requirements... 1.5 X 2" pipe ... etc.... we will not skimp on the safety of our customers....

  • 17 years ago

    Scott is right on.

    Top,
    For larger pipe it is a tough market. Paramount has a MDX2 for about $200.00 that will take a 2.5".
    We do a ton of "site built sumps" with 2.5" and 3" pipe. Just like anything else with a pool, it has to be done right. All the drain manufacturers have simple specs on it.
    A big thing that is not thought about much is exceeding the FPS of the suction pipe. With different requirements around the country it is easy to exceed with a 1.5 or 2" pipe.

  • 17 years ago

    Just a PB the 6fps rule is easy to follow. It's my understanding that you only have to keep this flow rate through the "manifold" then you can observe whatever rules you have in place, or what local codes require. the cost to upsize the manifold is very little.


    To answer the OP's question, There is no difference really. All a sump is, is a void, or space underneath the grate. If its a formed plastic sump, or concrete it doesnt matter when it comes to operation or safety of the people using the vessel. Many municipalities do not allow field built sumps, which is ridiculous IMO, because there is no difference when it comes to the goal we are trying to achieve.


    Top 50, the 1.5X pipe diameter is a boiler plate asme spec, if a testing laboratory has certified the grate for lower clearances that, then it will be in compliance with the VGB. For instance the SDX has no sump requirement in most applications, as well as the Drainsafe DS-360. Most Aquastar products have a 3" clearance, the 18X18 and 24"X24" have a 6" regardless of pipe size.

  • 17 years ago

    Below will be the code as it reads... the clearance of the cover should have nothing to do with depth of the sump. The law says a field built sump has to have a depth 1.5 times the pipe.... What if it doesn't? secondly ... in a field built sump the feed pipe cannot be cut flush with the bottom of the sump.... thirdly who's going to police it?.... all this to save $30.... ???
    Sumps
    Q: What is CPSC's position regarding sumps and the ASME/ANSI standard?

    A: CPSC staff recognizes and supports the technical requirement of the ASME/ANSI A112.19.8-2007 standard, which calls for field-built sumps to have a depth of 1.5 times the diameter of the piping; however, the federal Pool and Spa Safety Act does not require pool owners/operators to replace their sump. If a new, compliant drain cover can be safely secured onto a pre-existing sump, while properly controlling the flow rate, then it meets the intent of the law. If a PE determines that additional engineering work needs to be done to the sump to bring it into compliance with the standard and ensure a secure connection with a new cover, then that work should be carried out. Finally, if a PE determines that a new drain cover cannot be safely placed on a pre-existing sump, then the sump should be removed and replaced with a new, compliant sump that is compatible with the compliant drain covers.

    Last Updated: January 30, 2009

  • 17 years ago

    This thread is starting to get good.

    Paramount makes the only set of 2.5" drains, 7'/sec is a little more 100 GPM which is about as large as it gets in residential pools.

    Larger pools, such as those in swim clubs, competition pools, and commercial pools like those in water parks may need larger than 2.5", going in fact to as large as 8" suction outlets.

    While the spec states depth, how do you figure out how many square inches are needed for the sump? I realize an 8" suction outlet would require a 12" deep sump, but that doesn't tell me how many square inches, i.e. length x width, my grate needs to be?

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    "Below will be the code as it reads..."

    Actually that's not the code, that an interpretation of the law, which is important, but it's not the code or the law.

    The CPSC has been dead wrong several times on this type of stuff.

    There are several things that even the ASME standard can leave in the hands of an engineer.

    From ASME SPEC.

    "Submerged suction outlets are manufactured cover/grate
    assemblies that may or may not connect directly to the
    circulation piping. Those that do not connect directly to
    manufacturerÂs recommended sump below or behind the
    outlet cover/grate, or a field built sump of the design
    specified by the manufacturer to control flow through
    the open area of the cover/grate. Alternatively, a sump
    built in accordance with Fig. 2 shall be permitted. They
    are further governed by the stipulations of Mandatory"

    I'd like to emphasize the part where it says. ""or a field built sump of the design specified by the manufacturer""

    So directly from the ASME is says, that its X standard which is figure 2, or what the manufacturer says. Now, there is some loose text somewhere that says that an engineer can certify something above and beyond this as well

    "Paramount makes the only set of 2.5" drains, "

    There are several manufacturers of 2.5" sumps SCP distributes one, but they MFR's name escapes me.

    Source for asme http://cstools.asme.org/csconnect/pdf/ANSI/BSR8/PublicReviewDraft1319.pdf

    draft date 5/2009

  • 17 years ago

    "going in fact to as large as 8" suction outlets. "

    Try 12",

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the info. I started to wonder after looking at construction pics. on this forum and at pools around my neighborhood.

  • 17 years ago

    My point I think is easy to see....

    There is NO way to properly certify that a field built sump meets the req...

    What if the plaster crew doesn't "LOP" off the stub? and the 2" pipe is 1/4"
    below the AMSE cover.... does it still meet the req? NO

    In fact they can't make it flush like a pre built sump....

    What would the purpose be of a new residential pool builder not installing a manufactured sump?

    To save$$$$$$$
    $30 a pool times_________ = $$$$$$$$$

    If your builder won't spend an extra $30 ... Run.....
    Next they'l be putting push-pulls on the DE instead of a mulitport...
    Oh wait!.... someone is doing that.... LOL

  • 17 years ago

    I want to see what a Registered Designer's definition is.
    I also want to see what a certain national chain that quit adding the ready made sumps thinks they are are saving after some smart lawyer realizes what is happening and takes the initiative to task.

    While I personally agree that the benefits and convenience of having a multiport outweigh the reduced head loss of a push pull or no valve for a DE filter, some customers may feel differently.

    There are insider cutting blades for drills that will allow a flush to be made.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Scott I agree...
    you know and I know that that's not what they are doing... I don't know how to post a picture on this board or I would so the good people of GW understand.

  • 17 years ago

    "What if the plaster crew doesn't "LOP" off the stub? and the 2" pipe is 1/4"
    below the AMSE cover.... does it still meet the req? NO "

    We could play the "what if game" forever, but the bottom line is the pool builder is responsible to make sure that everything meets, or exceeds the criteria. We do this ourselves.

    "There is NO way to properly certify that a field built sump meets the req... "

    Btw, you can use an angle grinder to lop the stubbs flush if you want, but we like to leave them 1/4" proud of the bottom of the sump to seal them off better.

    Then again why are you using 2" pipe on your main drains anymore. Do your systems never exceed 60 gpm?? 6FPS is the magic number.

    Sure there is, its called a tape measure.

    "If your builder can't use a tape measure ... Run....."

    It's asinine to imply that a plastic sump is far superior to a concrete box, and equate it to a mechanical deficiency. Both of them done right will work great, and the customers will smile and hand you money, and everyone will be happy as long as they own their pool.

    For the record we use sumps in residential, and where possible in commercial, but we do this to satisfy on of our incompetent health department, not because it makes the product better.

  • 17 years ago

    You know what Racket some builders aren't reputable, don't care... and do anything they can to cut corners....
    That's the builders I'm taking about... one in particular...
    I don't give two craps what you think is inferior.... or not.... who is looking over the shoulder of the builder installing a field built sump? NO ONE.... Who is making sure it was done correctly? NO ONE...
    I don't think you fully understand what I am talking about .... as I said if someone explains how to... I will post a picture.....
    If you do everything as you say you do... it's asinine to even argue with me .... you should see my point clearly..

  • 17 years ago

    Top,
    What brand sump/drains do you use?

  • 17 years ago

    Top, Is that the one you emailed me?

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    "If you do everything as you say you do... it's asinine to even argue with me .... you should see my point clearly.."

    I am not even sure what your point is.

    I don't feel either method properly executed is inferior or superior.. I just 2 different ways to accomplish the same thing.

  • 17 years ago

    We use a generic sump ... with Hayward covers..

    Scott ,
    Yes it is...

    Racket,
    Here's my .02....
    ABC cover company develops a AMSE cover.... the FPS is tested... blah, blah, blah... it tested for use on a standard sump that is X times Y in dimensions.... everybody is happy... and its approved and in use....

    Fred the pool builder come along and uses ABC's cover on a field built sump.... that Rocko the shotcrete guy scooped out with his trow as he's shooting the floor... Rocko eyes it up and says "hey that looks like 1.5 times 2" .... "Its good" ... Plaster crew comes in lops off the stub... sets the ring and cover in the plaster..... nobody knows the difference? ....
    Lets say for argument the field built sump is half the volume... of a drain pot... same pump, pipe size...etc...

    Now your going to tell me that the flow rate on the ABC cover is the same?

  • 17 years ago

    What if they put in the wrong sumps, wrong manifold, added more features to increase the flow rate?

    It's our jobs to verify, and be diligent that these these are correct reguardles of the method used.

    Aquastar product is 3" for up to 12X12 not 1.5X.

  • 17 years ago

    http://www.lawsonaquatics.com/pool_main_drains/fg_upto18x18.html

    If you want a good package. The grates have a 10 year life span vs others 5 year. Also the flow rates are far more substantial vs Haywards.

  • 17 years ago

    Racket
    My stuff is to code.....
    We are not talking about my pools.... I do crap THE RIGHT WAY!
    I'm talking about another company.....

  • 17 years ago

    Which gets to why I feel like I am bizarro world here.

    The right way is the right way regardless if the box is made of plastic or concrete. It either meets or exceeds the dimensional requirements or it doesn't.

    If large #1 in the country hack pool builder doesn't comply, or have the ability to oversee their construction projects, they are doing their client a big disservice.

    The original question posed in this thread was " What are the pro/cons of pre-formed sump or site built sump for a residential pool?

    Is it builder preference? "

    And my response is either done properly, is correct, and it depends on the builders preference. Neither one done right is dangerous, and both done wrong are.

    Like one pool that had pots, where the builder filled one of the legs of the main drain line with gunite, it ended up being a single drain, but you couldn't tell it from the surface.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree!....