Forthe past year a few of my favorites have been:

BM Jonesboro Cream:

BM Porcelain Ivory (or Ivory Porcelain - I always forget):

BM Revere Pewter:

BM Flowering Herbs (1 shade lighter than Baby Turtle):

BM Baby Turtle (very chameleon like depending on other peoples light and exposure):

I have BM Manchester Tan in my foyer going up into the loft which is my family room...I'm repeating the color in my downstairs office/den...in my home it picks up as a khaki color - in a lot of sun it's very light and beigey tan but sometimes in low light it looks like it has a gray/green tone going on...

There are tons of pretty colors that BM makes I don't think you can go wrong...

Another place to look for ideas is on the Benjamin Moore website, there is a link to Pottery Barn colors, which shows you rooms painted in various BM colors.

I was also going to suggest Manchester tan, and Revere Pewter.
Any BM dealer can mix you Believable Buff.

I love BM wheeling neutral. Its a nice golden tan in my living room.

BM Monroe Bisque. I think it is a great neutral and looks good with stained trim.

I have Manchester Tan and like it, but it is a medium gold - darker than Believable Buff.

BM Pittsfield Buff is a lovely color and I'd say it's almost a match to Believable Buff.

If you really like Believable Buff, I bet BM could mix it for you with their paints. SW has all the BM colors and I've had SW mix all my paints that I've used that are BM colors.

With computers, they pretty much can mix what ever you want.

Hi guys!

Thank you so much for all the many and wonderful suggestions and to ttodd for the visuals as well. I am really loving the Jonesboro Cream. I am now armed with a lot of color choices. I don't know if that's good or not cause it's time to make decisions, decisions:) I will let you know which one would be the final contender. Thank you SO much!!!

Rutty

After a ridiculous amount of deliberation, we went with BM Antique White. It was just what I was looking for- a neutral light beige that didn't turn green, yellow, or pink. We have it in an upstairs hall and a bright foyer and in both lights it stayed true.

Thanks...I will look into than one too! Decisions, decisions...

I choose BM Natural Cream. It's very similar to edgecomb gray, but if push came to shove it leaned a bit yellow instead of pink and I wanted to avoid pink at all costs!