Software
Houzz Logo Print
acdesignsky

What's a kitchen redo really worth?

18 years ago

We're in the process of prepping our 12 yo house for sale. DH's job transfer is moving us closer to family. We had planned on being in this house for quite a while, so we remodeled to 80's style kitchen right after moving in 2004. By being an intrepid shopper and bargain hound, we managed to come in right about 20K for custom cabs, granite and cherry counters, KA appliances, and HW floors. The kitchen is gorgeous (at least to me LOL) and is what will sell the house.

Now that we're moving we had a Realtor out and he raved about the kitchen, but when talking about setting a price, he only mentioned the 3-4% annual appreciation in the region. We haven't talked final numbers since the relo company appraisers haven't been here yet.

I'm confused, shouldn't a new kitchen play a larger role in the asking price? I know we won't recoup 100%, but I figured 80% or so.

We paid 301K in Fall 2004. 3.5% appreciation would take us to 339K. Our best comp is another 12 yo brick colonial in our neighborhood. It shows really well. It has the original kitchen cabinets, but new granite counters and midrange appliances. They listed last month and sold in less than 10 days for 345K. That's the highest selling price achieved in this neighborhood thus far, but another home (really dated) is on the market at 365K.

Would you stay with the safe price of 345K, or up it a bit to recoup the kitchen? I worry the neighborhood can't support much over 355K.



Comments (22)

  • 18 years ago

    The kitchen IS gorgeous! Good work on not too much money. How long has the house at $365K been on the market? If it's been more than a month, it is priced too high. I think you might try $349K. But see what the relo appraiser says. I'd be interested to know how it goes.

  • 18 years ago

    I learned the hard way that in today's market a kitchen isn't worth what it was two years ago when we did ours. DH, our agent and I all expected our kitchen (and all the other remodeling to the entire rest of the house) would sell it quickly and for a great price . . . but we were wrong. We made ourselves into the *nicest* home on the block without thinking about it, and though everyone adored our house they didn't feel the same for the neighborhood. They expected houses that looked as shiny and new on the rest of the street, and that isn't the case. We did sell - close on the 11th - but it look a while and several price reductions.

    Lesson learned? Nah - we're gutting the new house and re-doing it all again!

  • PRO
    18 years ago

    Thanks for the replies so far.
    The 365K house has been on the market 6 long months. I think it's less the price than the house itself. Think Miami Vice and you've got a good idea. Lots of mauve and blue textured wallpaper, mirrors on the walls, pickled oak cabs, and blue and rose carpets. It needs at least 30K just to get a basic updating. It's larger by 2 bedrooms and a full bath, but the layout is really odd. Honestly, it should be priced around 289K.
    The rest of the neighborhood ranges from nice to really nice. It's a custom neighborhood where you bought a lot and brought your own builder, so the houses vary widely as far as size, style, and quality of finishes. We're probably one of of the nicest houses, but I hope we haven't priced ourselves out too much.
    We're painting, having the deck refinshed, and replacing carpet this week before the relo appraisers come. I'll let you know what they say!
    Thanks again.

  • 18 years ago

    "We're painting, having the deck refinshed, and replacing carpet this week before the relo appraisers come."

    I'm curious, if you think you've already remodeled yourself out of the neighborhood's price range why are you putting even more money into the house before listing? Painting, staining the deck, & replacing carpet are not things that the appraiser is likely to even notice much less care about when he's doing your appraisal. He's going to care much more about your total square footage, number of bedrooms/baths, is there a fireplace, patio, garage, etc. I'll just about promise you there won't be any realizable value added for the money your spending this week. He/she will take a quick look around & note whether there's any functional obsolescence & determine if the property's in "good, average, or poor" condition. You won't get extra points for staining the deck because it sounds like your home's condition is already in the "good" category. Appraiser's don't go higher than "good".

    Please don't take my comments wrong...it's just that you're emotionally attached to your house & the appraiser is not. The appraiser job is to be detached & compare your property against a pre-determined set of criteria as I noted above. They make one "condition" adjustment to the comps, if necessary. They don't make adjustments for any of the items you're paying for this week.

    /tricia

  • PRO
    18 years ago

    tricia,
    I understand what you're saying. We're really just doing basic maintenance that we put off last year. The deck finish is completely worn away and it looks really shabby. I'm painting the kid's rooms and bath to a more neutral color and we're only replacing the carpet in the upstairs hall and 2 bedrooms. We got a new puppy right after we moved in, so between the accidents and the chewing, it has to be done.I think of the work we're doing as necessary to keep up to par.
    I know it shouldn't matter to the appraisers, but I think clean, new, and neutral has to be better than our current more lived-in and maintenance-deferred state. I'm thinking more of the potential buyers than the appraisers since regardless of their numbers, we'll still put the house on the market.
    We did decide against some more expensive upgrades like hardwood in 2 rooms and extensive landscaping. We'll save by planting some inexpensive bushes ourselves and just having the carpet cleaned.

  • 18 years ago

    Do you just get one relo appraisal? We had to have 2 and if they were more than 5% apart, then we had to have a third. Ours were more than 5 % apart, but we got an offer before they had the third appraiser in, so we never got an actual value from the relo company. I really wanted to know how the relo buy-out compared to the offer we negotiated with the buyer!!

  • 18 years ago

    if you want an honest opinion that wallpaper has to go. it would be a turnoff to most people.

  • 18 years ago

    vhehn, I think you're looking at the "pre remodel" picture of the kitchen....there is no wallpaper that I can see in the "post remodel" kitchen (bottom photo).

  • 18 years ago

    chispa -- all of our relo offers were less then what we sold our homes for. Don't know if that's typical, but it was true for all of ours.

  • 18 years ago

    This line in the OP kind of threw me before I realized that to 80's style should be the 80's style:

    We had planned on being in this house for quite a while, so we remodeled to 80's style kitchen right after moving in 2004.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm guesing the top pic is before the kitchen redo and the bottom after?
    The island you currently have would be a turn off to me and so would the lighting....least from that pic. The lighting doesn't look functional enough for a kitchen and I think the island you replaced the old one with removes a significant amount of storage from the kitchen. The islands color also for many would be a problem and as a buyer I'd wonder if it was staying or not. It looks like something that was placed there not a built in.
    In all honesty it's a average looking kitchen and for the price point you are talking I'd want to be wowed,yours just doesn't do least not from that pic.

  • 18 years ago

    Carol, the island is 'supposed' to look like a free-standing piece of furniture. You can tell though it's staying because it's got electricity. That island isn't going anywhere.

    Also, I like the painted cabinets. That's a personal preference thing but I sure don't believe that, "The islands color also for many would be a problem...".

    /tricia

  • 18 years ago

    It's a nice redo, but I'm afraid you're not going to get an 80% payback in today's market except in a very few areas.

    Getting your home in top condition will help sell it faster, but not necessarily for more money. The market is what the market is, and with loan guidelines tighter than a small-size corset on Mae West, you need to be realistic, not optimistic.

  • 18 years ago

    Gorgeous kitchen. I love the white island and all of the task lighting. If I were a buyer, that kitchen would sell the house to me.

    I would think that the 3-4% annual appreciation would apply to your basic purchase price, and that you could add a percentage of your remodeling investment on top of that.

    Since houses are selling quickly in your neighborhood, why not list at $355 and see what happens?

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with some of the other responses. We are in a entirely new real estate world right now and comparing anything to 2004 isn't relevant. Depending where the OP is located (some regions are harder hit than others) I would say not to be too optimistic about recouping even 80%. It is a lovely kitchen but these days it takes more than that to sell a house- it takes a realistic price. Im heading there soon so let's see if I take my own advice@ Best of luck!

  • PRO
    18 years ago

    Painted cabinets are a personal preference thing. I know it may be a turnoff to some buyers. There is another wall of base and wall cabs not shown in the pics off to the right. There's plenty of storage. The island is permanent, so it stays.
    We have to get at least 2 appraisals (more if the prices are more than 5% apart). This is our 3rd relo with this company and the appraisals have been at least 10% less than what the house has actually sold for. The last house appraised for $250K-265K and sold for 300K in less than a week!
    We're in SW Pa which is a very stable market. Prices have continued to rise and this is one of the fastest growing burbs in the country. Also, Westinghouse is bringing over 2,000 100K+ yr jobs to a brand new HQ just 10 min away. The area is really hopping.
    We're not trying to be greedy. We designed the kitchen for our tastes, assuming we'd be here for a long while. We just don't want to shortchange ourselves.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi angc,

    You live in my neck of the woods. I am in Hampton. I think you did a great job on the kitchen.

    I have been following the local market for about a year. I have not been looking in Cranberry, only Pine/Richland, Hampton and NA schools. There have been lots of houses in the $300-$350 range that have been on the market for more than a year and plenty that have had drastic price reductions.

    Of course your taxes are a big advantage for you and the reason so many people relocate from Allegheny to Butler County. I still think the market is not as strong in Cranberry as it was a year or two ago so it may be more difficult to get buyers to go for anything above $350. They know there are bargins to be found and will wait for the right house at a great price.

    Good luck to you!

  • PRO
    18 years ago

    robyn,
    Hi to another girl from the 'burgh. I've been watching the market too and it seems Cranberry is stronger than Wexford and other NA areas, but we're weaker than Adams and Mars. The 6 week teacher's strike didn't help. Taxes are a huge plus here, that's for sure. I have friends selling in Wexford in the 400K range. It's been on the market 9 months. You know sales pretty much come to a halt during the school year, but that's still a long time.
    I'm thinking that, unless the appraisal comes back much higher or lower, $349,900 is realistic and fair. Sales prices have been 97-98% of listing.

  • PRO
    18 years ago

    Update-
    The house is going on the market Sat may 3rd, with 1st showings on Mon. We had two Realtors out who both recommended listing at $349,900 for a quick
    sale.

    The bad news- The 345K house ended up selling for 327K in 2 days (not 10). We think the seller's relo packakge including a 3-5% bonus for selling quickly, so they jumped on the first offer. That selling price made one agent drop her recommendation from 365K to 349K!
    The good news- Another house in the neighborhood went on the market last week and sold for full list (I asked the sellers) of 359,900 in under 24 hrs. They have a 1st floor master, really nicely finished basement with wet bar, and an attached garage, but the house is smaller and on a busy corner with a steep unusable yard . We're hoping our cul de sac location, huge flat yard, finished 3rd floor teenager/nanny suite, and remodeled kitchen makes up for our smaller but still nice finished basement, 2nd floor master, and integral garage.

    After discussing it and sprucing up the house for the last few weeks, we've decided on a listing price of 354,900. That's allows some leeway for negotiation.
    I'll post links and pics on sun. Wish us luck!

  • 18 years ago

    Personally, I'd do under $350k to get that price point seen.
    If it shows well, you won't need to wiggle.

  • 18 years ago

    I know all real estate is local, etc. etc. etc.

    The economic downturn is very real. I'm in Dallas, an area that has one of the lowest unemployment numbers in the USA, but I see the effect of the downturn with friends getting laid off, job reqs being cancelled at work, hiring freeze, customers laying off thousands of people, gas costs eating up lots of discretionary spending (my own gas bill went from $110/month to $240/months). It isn't pretty (and feels a lot worse than the recession a few years ago).

    This is on top of the much more difficult credit market. I sold my house 1.5 years ago. I put in lots of upgrades and expensive features but didn't price those into the listing price. It sold after 2.5 months on the market. A neighbor priced his 10% higher and it still hasn't sold. New listings in the neighborhood are 15% lower than my final sales price.
    I sold to a woman who financed 100% (80/20). This probably would not happen in today's market.

    Bottom line: Unless you live in an above average seller's market, forget about the kitchen investment. View it as an advantage over the competition but don't price it higher, if you want to sell.

  • 18 years ago

    What do other houses in the same price range look like?
    They are your competition and will determine if you upgrades have value in the market.

    I personally do what I want, and if the cost is recovered so be it.
    Many changes may not appear to return actual $$, but do so indirectly by speeding up sales.
    A house has carrying costs while it is on the market.