Software
Houzz Logo Print
rikerk

Island top assistance needed quickly

15 years ago

We are in the process of the kitchen remodel, cabs are arriving Thursday. I thought we were all set for our island top but.... DH now says he wants butcherblock on part of the island. The dilemma is, I have already purchased our undermount siligranit sink.

The island will consist of:

24" sink base, 3"PO Spice, 9"trays, 3"PO Spice & 30"base

It is going to be strictly a work station NO SEATING. Therefore either 25" deep or 27" deep.

Should I put a 36" piece of granite on the sink end and then a 36" piece Thick BB? Not sure about the transition. I like the look of 2.25" cherry end grain butcher block BUT how would it look next to granite that is only 1.25". Any suggestions. The island will be 72" total. Should I go 25" or 27" deep.

Kim

Comments (23)

  • 15 years ago

    Looking at your cabinet configuration (is that the order of the cabinets on the island?) one option I would consider is 42" of granite and then 30" BB on top of the 30" cabinet base.
    What is DH's intent for the butcher block? Is it for looks, or as a chopping block.
    It looks good having the different heights. It had better because that's what ours is. On our peninsula it is granite but the overhang section is dark-stained maple butcher block and it sits about 1" higher than the granite.
    If you have the aisle space might as welll go 27" deep.

  • 15 years ago

    I should have said that he does plan to chop on the butcher block. Yes, I was going to rearrange the cabs so that they were in the order listed in my original post. blfenton how thick is your BB going to be, so your are going to be back to back?? I'm just having a hard time envisioning the different heights next to each other. I mentioned it to the granite company owner & she said they should be the same height. The lady at John boos wasn't much help. Boxerpups are you out there...do you have any great inspiration photos of what I am describing?

  • 15 years ago

    I've seen what you're describing with the differing heights in lots of photos, many from Boxer. Im considering doing this too. Have you seen Alabamamommy's kitchen? Her island is mostly marble with a very thick piece of wood on the end. You should be able to find her gorgeous kitchen with the search box at the bottom.

    Blfenton, can you pretty, pretty please post a pic of your island? I know you've talked about posting pics, but I've never seen them. I'm especially interested in seeing yours with the seating as I'm strongly considering doing my counter stool area in wood with my marble island.

  • 15 years ago

    Breezy I'm not sure if I have seen Alabamamommy's, but I have seen one that boxer posted that is exactly like you describe. I am hoping boxer chimes in because she posts the most amazing pictures. My sink has to be on one end of the island so otherwise it would be directly behind the range and I don't want that. I am going to do a search for her tight now. I did find some great photos of Eliz Piz great island. I could turn my sink like she did, but i'm not sure!

  • 15 years ago

    If Boxer doesn't see this, try starting a new thread with her name in the title asking for help. She's so awesome, isn't she?

  • 15 years ago

    Breezy, I just did a search and found alabamamommy's island and all I can say is WOW! That is not the one that I was talking about that boxer had posted in a previous post. Although it did have that really thick end grain boos board that I really want.

  • 15 years ago

    Mine are different heights because of the inspiration picture that I loved that I got the idea from. Also, my KD researched it and said that because the BB and granite can't actually be joined together, they are supported separately and looked better with the height difference. If you but them together, there will be a space regardless and so the height difference helps to minimize this and gives a design element at the same time.
    (Now watch the DIY'ers chime in and say I'm wrong - oh well)

    Ok- I went and measured and of course I was off - my granite is 1 1/8" and my wood top is 1 3/4" (custom made) and they back on to each other for 62" (just over 5')
    We did it for a design element. I really like the white cabinets with dark island idea (I think that it is a "trend" that will become a kitchen design mainstay) but we couldn't fit in an island when we changed the configuration. So this was my way of getting the cream cabinets and dark element into the kitchen.

    Breezygirl: My kids finish exams within the next couple of weeks and then Hopefully they will give their dear old mom some help in posting pictures.

  • 15 years ago

    I also have the cream cabinets with a dark granite on the perimeter. The island will also be cream. As you know the top is to be determined.

    I could turn the 24" sink base to face the side and have that granite and then have the 3"PO, 30"base,3"filler & 9"trays face the front and cover that with the butcher block. Only problem with that is I'm not sure how it would be to prep if the sink is the other way and then the faucet may be to close to the wood.

  • 15 years ago

    blfenton--Ok, OK, I'll try to be patient. I just wanna see the set up you're describing! I think it's what I want to do.

  • 15 years ago

    bump

  • 15 years ago

    Rikerk- In the attached photo, there is a butcherblock portion on the island with a sink in granite. This would allow you to utilize your siligranit sink and have some butcherblock for chopping. Just a thought...
    Not sure why this photo is so tiny. You'll notice (if you click on it so that you can actually see it) that there is a different in height. Looks great!

  • 15 years ago

    My base cabinets are exactly the same height and mine will be all running the same direction, not turned like in the photo brianadarnell posted. What do you think if my wood is 1" or 1.75" heigher than the granite in a straight line?

  • 15 years ago

    I've seen butcher block counters 1" or 2" higher than the abutting stone in pictures. I think it looks fine.

  • 15 years ago

    One thing I don't think has been mentioned to you is to consider the ergonomics of the wood area. How tall are you? Will a wood top 38" (regular 36" counter height plus 2" of higher wood) off the floor be too high for chopping comfortably? I use a big Boos block on my counter for chopping at every meal. It lives on the counter. It's about 1.5" thick and works for me. But I watch my very short SIL chop on it and it looks a bit awkward. Mock it up and see how it works for you.

    For strictly looks, I think you're fine with whatever looks good to you.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with Breezy- make sure the height of the BB will be ok. Otherwise, I think it will look great! I think a 30" base cabinet would be perfect for the butcher block.

  • 15 years ago

    I am 5'3". I will definitely mock it up and see how it feels. I do plan to definitely put it above the 30" base.

    Breezy how do you like your boos?

  • 15 years ago

    I just wanted to thank everybody for taking the time to help me with my island top. I think I am going to put the 24" sink & 3"Spice filler pullout in granite and then butt up a 30"base with a nice thick cherry boos board and then do a 3" spice filler pullout and a 9" tray cab covered with granite. So I would have a 27" piece of granite and 30" boos board and a 12" piece of granite. I still haven't decided if I should do the 2 1/4" or 3" thick butcher block. Decisions, decisions. This is strictly a work island.

  • 15 years ago

    I love my Boos. I've used a few other boards here and here at other's kitchens. And then I'm happy to come home and pat my Boos. I mentioned somewhere, maybe here, that I'm thinking of a new one for the new kitchen in a larger size. Mine is big (and blonde), put I could handle a bit bigger for piles of garlic, shallots, etc so I still have enough wide open space for veg chopping. I think mine is about the size of Rachel Ray's.

    Could you rethink that block placement in your island? You've chopped up (no pun intended) your work space by varying the heights so much. Having the two smaller ends of granite doesn't seem like the best use of space. A bigger expanse of any material is better than two smaller bits. If I were you, I'd put the wood on one end and leave the granite areas together. I'm so tired; I hope that's understandable.

    Is your kitchen room a big scale? A larger, or even more open, room could accomodate a 3" thick block better than a tiny little room in my eye. BUT, I'm sure that either would probably work just fine.

    Oh, I just re-read your initial post. I'd do 30" base on one end with the block top.

    HTH!

  • 15 years ago

    Breezy you are right I should just go with my gut and put the 30" butcherblock on the end. I guess I was over thinking that the island is very close to the edge of the fridge and granite would be a better landing place than the BB. There is another granite counter for landing anyway that is just as close. Actually now that the wall is down our kitchen is quite large. I'm almost thinking it is too big. It is 25' x 13.5" and we are not having a table in that room, just a cozy corner. However we have a huge peninsula. I think I am going to only go with the 2.25" thickness BB because I am only 5'3" and that extra 3/4" may bother me.

  • 15 years ago

    rikerk,

    Here are some images. Not exactly what you want but they
    show the transition of wood and stone. Maybe these visuals
    can help you see ways to make this work for you.
    I know it will look great.

    ~boxerpups




  • 15 years ago

    Thanks Boxer you are the best when it comes to inspiration photos. I just found a photo of Ajards kitchen on the forum and she has done exacatly what I want to. Except hers is on the end of a peninsula and she has marble but it looks awesome. Thanks for the help.

  • 15 years ago

    Well I took a leap & ordered the 2.25" thick end grain cherry John Boos board in 30" x 27" for the end of the island. Now I have to wait for it to arrive, that is going to take a while! It's like waiting for christmas for a little kid.

  • 15 years ago

    I just wanted to report that I received my 2 1/4" Boos Cherry end grain BB Island top and I love it! It is oiled & I olan to cut on it. I ordered from www.cymax.com and have been very pleased. I was a little nervous, but I got a decent price and took about 3 weeks to arrive from Boos direct.

    However, I need some more assistance. I had planned to put the 30" piece on a portion of the island and then the same granite that is in the existing kitchen perimeter (it is a remodel that removed a wall). It is Cranberry brown also called tan brown (it is a black with a lot of reddish brown). I don't really like the tan brown next to the cherry. The island granite has not been ordered yet & the perimeter has to stay.Any suggestions of what to put next to the cherry that will also coordinate with the perimeter & that section will have an undermount sink?