Software
Houzz Logo Print
dabunch_gw

Gutters..... please.

19 years ago

Does anyone here have Pine needles falling into your gutters?

What is the best cover/protection type cover to place over the gutters?

I would prefer that the pine needles roll off the gutter protectors, not just sit on top of the lids.

I Googled & I'm finding only 2 types of protectors, one that is almost a solid cover. The other is a straight cover with holes in it to not to allow the leaves through into the gutter.

In my mind an ideal gutter cover would have a mesh for the leaves & pine needles to not to get through, plus it would be angled a bit for the needles to roll off.

Anyone familiar with such a thing? I'm looking for something economical.

Thanks. I prefer honest answers form you posters, instead of some sales pitches...

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    Having researched this issue to death, I can tell you the ideal product does not exist.

    The companies that sell the full covers give you a lifetime warranty at a hefty price. I think what you are indirectly buying is a lifetime service agreement to clean your gutters.

    You can buy mesh-topped gutter covers, but I don't know how you could install them at an angle.

    Go to the Home Repairs forum and do a search on "gutter cover" and you will see lots of posts. Beware: lots of salesmen in disguise.

    Here is a link that might be useful: mesh covers

  • 19 years ago

    Anyone use gutter helmet?

  • 19 years ago

    We also have lots of pine needles, researched it to death, and came to the same conclusion as Graywings -- There really doesn't seem to be an ideal product.

    The 'solid on top' types can't seem to handle the vast quantities of rain we sometimes get, and the 'holes on top' kind get pine needles stuck in vertically, turning the entire gutter into a big 3-D 'comb'.

    We ended up getting oversized gutters only in areas where valleys formed, and no covers.

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you all.

    Graywings- that is sort of what I'm looking for. The mesh that fits on top looks like it's installed at a bit of an angle, which should help roll the pine needles and leaves off. Thanks a bunch!

  • 19 years ago

    If you find something, please post what it is. We're looking for the same thing. We've got pine needles but the itty-bitty spruce needles are really obnoxious. They're so small they get through anything & clog up the works quickly. What a PITA for anyone who lives in an area with lots of trees & lots of precipitation (that would be us).

    Tricia

  • 19 years ago

    I purchased and installed the mesh covers for my gutters two years ago. I thought they were a great invention until the first major rain storm....

    I woke up in the middle of the night to the sound of rain literally rolling straight off the roof of the house and onto the foundation below. At 2 AM in the pitch black pouring rain I climbed up a ladder to find the problem. It seems that all the seeds/pods/needles/leaves, etc. which I expect to "simple roll off" the mesh screens instead just accumlated on top of them and thus were not allowing any water into the gutters! I spent the next hour in my nightgown on a ladder ripping the mesh screens off before my basement could flood. (It is times like this a girl could use a husband....)

    Thus - not a big fan of the mesh covers.

  • 19 years ago

    I don't know 'bout the gutters, but spy 10021 sounds like my kind of gal...Willing to get up on a ladder, in a wet nightgown. Too bad I'm already married.