Software
Houzz Logo Print
novahomesick

Contentious Closings. Any stories?

19 years ago

We learn a lot here from the stories of how posters handle situations in the wonderful world of real estate. Have any of you ever suffered a contentious or difficult closing? How did you handle it? Ive heard nasty stories about sellers who swap out appliances and buyers who just donÂt show up for settlement. My storyÂ.

I was young. I was naive. I was an "accidental" landlord selling my first home.

During the bear market of the 90Âs, I was underwater on my condo. When I moved, I rented it. After two years, as a rental, the place was not at its best. When the market finally changed, I decided to sell. My agent and I decided to put in the minimum work and priced under market. We had a contract in 14 days, 10% earnest, all cash buyer, 95% of list price, as-is condition, no inspection. I was thrilledÂuntil we got to the closing table.

It turns out the buyer had never seen the place and bought it on his realtorÂs advice. I guess he didnÂt like what he saw on walk-through. His realtor came out of the box swinging, berated me for the condition of the condo, and demanded a $5000 credit to replace worn countertops in the kitchen, new overhead light fixtures (panels had yellowed), new carpet, and a new washer and dryer. Apparently, the washer made a funny noise when they turned it on. I was blown awayÂnot just with the demands but the incredible hostility of the buyer and his agent.

I looked at my realtor for help and, well, he said nothing. After a moment, he mumbled something about the as-is clause. The buyerÂs realtor retaliated by calling me a bad seller who was trying to dump a lousy property on her buyer. Okay, that ticked me off so for the next hour, the buyerÂs realtor and I went back and forth bickering over the meaning of the contract. The settlement lawyer remained quiet. This was my first time selling so I really didnÂt have a legal clue. My agent sat there like a bump on a log. We negotiated down to $700 for the washer and dryer only. I was willing to concede a new washer but the dryer operated fine. They wanted both because the washer and dryer were a matched set! Finally, I stood up, grabbed my purse, and said $350 for the washer or we donÂt close. They caved and we put the $350 in escrow. Funnily, I probably would have given them much more if their intimidating tactics hadn't made me so angry.

I learned about a million lessons that day and can, happily, say itÂs the only time a realtor has ever disappointed me. Every time, I interview a realtor I ask about their experiences with tough closings.

By the way, the buyer flipped it for a $100K profit 18 months later...good for him.

Any other stories out there?

Comments (48)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have not been to a closing except for a personal residence in many years.
    My attorney handles everything.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nova, that's terrible.

    Some agents are/were taught to keep their mouths shut at closings, to let the closer handle everything regardless.

    To a point, that's good advice, but if the other party or other party's agent or attorney is beating up on my client, I think I'd have had to intervene.

    The closing agent was doing the only thing she could:
    A closing agent is an "arm's length" disinterested third party.

    Her job is to make sure the documents are properly executed & filed.

    She represents neither the seller nor the buyer.

    Had she tried to make peace, she could have been exposed herself to liability suits for favoring one party or the other.

    I guess my worst closing was the one where a divorced couple was selling & the husband worked himself into such a state, screaming abuse at his wife, that the receptionist was poised to call 911.

    On that one, I was literally afraid to try to intervene.

    I now have divorced people come in 30 minutes or so apart.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We don't use RE lawyers here. Agents also don't go to closings, since the money doesn't get exchanged until recording. No one shows up to closing at the same time. Each party has separate times. All of this helps avoid problems.

    We had a bit of problem with our buyer wanting to change some things a couple of hours prior to the closing. He threatened not to close. We said fine, we were sticking to the contract. We wouldn't be bullied. We went and signed. They went and signed.

    I think a ton of this crap is bluff and I wouldn't have had problem walking.

    Gloria

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "She represents neither the seller nor the buyer."

    They attorney represent whomever is PAYING them.
    They are a 'trusted' party, but that does not mean they are not without duty to the person who hired them.
    Was this in Virginia?
    I would have come close to firing the attorney on the spot and moving the closing.
    The walk through is to verify that the property is in the same condition as the date the contract was signed.
    Unless changes happened since signing, the purchaser does not have a leg to stand on.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    nope, "settlement attorneys" do not represent either party.

    They draw documents, & they have buyer & seller sign acknowledgements that they, the attorneys, represent no one, that they are paid for drawing documents & making sure that documents are executed & recorded, & that their fees are not for legal representation.

    & each party pays a portion of the attorneys' fees.

    If you want legal representation at closing, you must bring your own lawyer.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I was buying land in St. Croix and all through the qualification process all the documents stated a 15 year loan (which is what we expected). The day before closing we were reviewing all the documentation and the bank changed the loan to a 5 year loan amortized over 15 years. We tried negotiated but the bank said it was sticking to the 5-yr term. Our attorney basically told us there wasn't much we could do.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, it was a Virginia closing and, I think, the settlement attorney was just there for the paperwork. One of the best lessons of that close was that a good realtor has value way beyond house hunting. The buyer's realtor at my closing intimated the heck out of me. Had she not crossed the line and gotten my Irish up, I probably would have rolled like a puppy begging for bacon.

    I later bought a house from a divorcing couple and they were scheduled for separate times. Good thing 'cuz they really disliked each other.

    Mckinney, did your loan end up being a 5 year ARM?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The type of loan Mckinney had in St. Croix is how mortgage loans are executed in Canada. The buyer chooses an amort period that used to be up to 25 years, but now they can get up to 35. You can also choose shorter am periods like 20, 15 or 10 years and you can pay weekly, biweekly and have the payment applied when it is received, unlike in the US where the full monthly payment must be received first. Within that 25 year amort, the buyer picks a term from 6 months to 5 or 7 years max (I can't remember what the max term is). Then, when the term is up, the owner either renews with their lender or shops around.

    Canada hasn't done 30 year fixed rate loans in decades. When my parents bought their house in 1971, they assumed the 4% - 35 year fixed mortgage initiated in 1963 at a payment of $160/month. Those were the good ol' days, eh? lol

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It turns out the buyer had never seen the place and bought it on his realtors advice. I guess he didnt like what he saw on walk-through. His realtor came out of the box swinging, berated me for the condition of the condo, and demanded a $5000 credit to replace worn countertops in the kitchen, new overhead light fixtures (panels had yellowed), new carpet, and a new washer and dryer. Apparently, the washer made a funny noise when they turned it on. I was blown awaynot just with the demands but the incredible hostility of the buyer and his agent.

    I looked at my realtor for help and, well, he said nothing. After a moment, he mumbled something about the as-is clause. The buyers realtor retaliated by calling me a bad seller who was trying to dump a lousy property on her buyer. Okay, that ticked me off so for the next hour, the buyers realtor and I went back and forth bickering over the meaning of the contract. The settlement lawyer remained quiet. This was my first time selling so I really didnt have a legal clue. My agent sat there like a bump on a log. We negotiated down to $700 for the washer and dryer only. I was willing to concede a new washer but the dryer operated fine. They wanted both because the washer and dryer were a matched set! Finally, I stood up, grabbed my purse, and said $350 for the washer or we dont close. They caved and we put the $350 in escrow. Funnily, I probably would have given them much more if their intimidating tactics hadn't made me so angry.

    I think you did well for someone that didn't know what they were doing. Although the washer & dryer were a "bonus" IMO, they were lucky you gave them the $350.

    By the way, the buyer flipped it for a $100K profit 18 months later...good for him.

    I'm not surprised. It actually makes me wonder if you were set up. Why else would someone let their agent have final say on an "as is" house? Glad he didn't make that kind of money on your dime had you given him a $5,000 credit. Sheesh.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "they have buyer & seller sign acknowledgements that they, the attorneys, represent no one"

    Not in Virginia.
    No such document is signed.
    They represent the person who is paying them here.

    Sounds like a great way to try and escape responsibility and the duty to your client.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sparksal,

    Thanks for the explanation. How do you think the two systems compare?

    Roselvr,

    Oh, indeed...I've always wondered if that close wasn't just a game by an investor trying to beat the price down further. In a strange way, I'm glad it happened because of the lessons...especially the things I could/should have done differently. Experience is a great teacher.

    When my sister bought her home, she discovered, at walk through, that the seller had swapped out the fridge and stove for cheaper models. Quite a little disagreement at closing because the seller denied it and demanded proof. The realtors worked out a compromise. My sister swears that if she ever buys another home, she's videotaping the entire house. I'm really liking this idea of buyers and sellers never meeting at settlement.

    My poor neighbor went to closing fully believing they had a sale and the buyers never showed...apparently, they left town. They found another buyer six weeks later but for $20K less. Strange stuff.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've been trying to think of the most contentious closing I've experienced as a lender & there've been lots.

    I'll have to go with this one...

    (First, let me say that I have absolutely nothing against the type of borrower this was. I am, in fact, a practicing Christian so please don't be offended. This REALLY happened.)

    OK, on with the story...

    I was working for a mortgage broker in the Denver area. It was the early 1980s. This was a commercial loan for about $5M. The loan proceeds were to be used as a combination of working capital plus a construction loan so I prepared two sets of closing documents. Underwriting happened with no problems. Everybody was cooperative & easy to get along with. Happy, happy.

    Day of closing. We're all sitting around the closing table at the attorney's offices. The AA was handing out soft drinks. Happy, happy.

    I gave my canned speech explaining the documents. Happy, happy. Handed everything over to the principals for signatures & leaned back in my chair to enjoy my Pepsi while they were signing. Happy, happy.

    My easy closing was rudely interrupted when one of the principals quietly put his folder of documents waiting for signature down on the table, looked me square in the eyeballs, & announced without raising his voice, "God doesn't want us to pay points."

    I nearly spit my Pepsi all over the table! At first, I thought it was a joke so I smiled & responded, "Good one...you had me there for a second." The minister returned my smile and repeated his proclamation, "God doesn't want us to pay points."

    Well, not being one to argue with God...I quickly gathered the documents scattered all over the table, stood up, & said, "I wish you would have told me a month ago that you'd had this conversation with God & asked him to leave me a message before I took this %$#@ing loan to the Board!"

    Epilogue...read in the Rocky Mountain News a few months later that this particular church had a new minister.

    Tricia

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The sellers tried to get out of the contract 2 weeks prior to our December 1 closing. We had already sold our previous house & it was set to close December 15. They had several "reasons" they wanted out of our deal but we suspected they got a better offer. They'd already moved out of town. They consulted an attorney that told them to sell to us.

    OK - forward to closing day. At first we were told they would not be attending - just their attorney. No such luck, the wife came & was very unpleasant. When we went to house after closing that evening, there was no electricity despite it being 20 degrees outside & even though we'd worked out just transferring the power with no disconnect. Well, at some point right before closing she called & ordered it to be cut off - since it was in her name, they did. She took all of the appliance manuals, warranty information on hvac, etc., plus she was going to leave house plans so we'd have a record of where the piers are, etc. NOPE - took it all. About a week later when we got around to hooking up the satellite dish, we could not get a signal in any room although they were all wired. Finally DH went up in the attic & they had cut all of the cables. We've been in there for 8 months & haven't found anything else........

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Now, that's what I call a tough negotiation. Great story, Tricia.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Sounds like a great way to try and escape responsibility and the duty to your client."

    but there is no client relationship between the attorneys who draw the docs & either buyer or seller.

    The only client relationships are between buyers & their Realtors and/or attorneys & between sellers & their Realtors and/or attorneys.

    The attorney fees for the drawing of documents are shared by buyer & seller.

    It's good to know that in Virginia the docs are drawn by someone who has fiduciary responsibilities to one party or the other:

    In Virginia, I guess it's standard procedure to have your attorney review any documents drawn by the other party's attorney.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Videotaping is WISE. A friend bought a vacation condo in Myrtle Beach, which was sold furnished. The family had a new video camera and her DS was forever fooling with it. He taped the family touring the condo, poking fun at his sisters and the condo.

    At the walk-through several months later my friend thought she'd lost her memory because so many things seemed "different" to her. When she remembered the tape and looked at it, sure enough: the seller had swapped out fixtures, curtains, towels, bedspreads.

    Since they had the videotaped "proof", all was restored.

    Another story:
    DH and I sold our prior home to a couple who wanted to completely remodel it -- virtual teardown. We were building. They would be building. We all needed time to get plans in order. They agreed to a closing ten months later.

    The morning of the closing we had a call from our realtor. The buyers didn't have the money! Fortunately, we weren't attending, and fortunately, were they to default, we could put the house back on the market for more than they'd paid (boom times). The deal finally closed around 4 p.m. after the buyers made a lot of frantic calls to banks and family.

    DH was sorry it did close. We could have moved "home" from our temporary apartment while we waited for our then-much-delayed new house to be completed. I just wondered why, given all that time to line up the financing, the buyers didn't have their ducks in a row.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think some here are thinking of attorneys as their own legal counsel.
    Here in CA, we don't usually use attorneys, but escrow companies with escrow officers, who simply push paper. They are paid by both the buyer and seller.
    When an attorney is used, one party has contracted with them so they obviously are representing that one party only.
    Different areas have different practices, here both parties never appear at the escrow company at the same time, I've never had my agent attend either.
    As a seller, I usually never go to the escrow company, i just mail the docs in.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    About a week later when we got around to hooking up the satellite dish, we could not get a signal in any room although they were all wired. Finally DH went up in the attic & they had cut all of the cables. We've been in there for 8 months & haven't found anything else........

    You don't live in NJ do you?

    My son installs DirecTV, he had a job like that this year.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Novahomesick - Both have pros and cons. With the US system, if you're going to stay in a home for a long time and get a low fixed rate, you're in good shape. However, if rates are high when you buy in Canada, you can choose a short term and hope that the rates go down when it's time to renew. There are no costs associated with the renewal. Mortgage interest is not a tax deduction in Canada. Closing costs are much cheaper, we don't have points and there are not alot of fees associated with the mortgage funding like there are in the US.

    Personally, I prefer the Canadian system because you can pay biweekly to eat at the interest rather than putting an extra amount to principal monthly or annually in the US which is over and above the mortgage payment.

    However, there are limits in Canada to how much you can prepay within the mortgage term. I think it's the equivalent of one month's payment every year. When it's renewal time, you can put down as much as you want without penalty, but you cannot just pay off the mortgage anytime within the term without paying a penalty.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Another reminder that attorneys seek to avoid any responsibility they can.
    In Virginia an attorney owes a duty to whomever is paying the bill.
    It would be a conflict of interest to represent both parties at a settlement.

    Another good reason to avoid Texas.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh guvnah! The Notorious Revenge of the Unhappy Seller. That's just low.

    Chisue, It's hard to believe that people actually pull this stuff but it happens.

    Sparksals, thanks for the explanation. One learns something new every day. It's interesting to hear how other systems work. Can you imagine what would happen to the US housing market if mortgage interest, property taxes etc weren't tax deductible?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I shudder at the thought. We think it's tanked now - I can't imagine what would happen. It would be economic suicide.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    roselvr - we're in Texas. They also took all of the touch-up paint (not that we liked their crappy paint scheme anyway, but still, what were they gonna do with it? I hope they're still carrying it around trying to figure out how to dispose of it. They were going to leave filters for the house water system & supplies for the septic but they took it all. We suspect that they also poisoned the minds of the immediate neighbors because they're not that "neighborly" --- and for rural Texas, that's unusual.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    guvnah -- Not sure how your nice sellers were able to have the electric power shut off; hadn't you applied for service as new owners? At least, having done that, they probably didn't feel the need to remove every lightbulb -- something one of our former neighbors did "because our new house is so BIG that we'll need them". Jeez!

    My mother was a broker. Those stories about deals falling apart over who gets the DR chandelier are all TRUE.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Another reminder that attorneys seek to avoid any responsibility they can.
    In Virginia an attorney owes a duty to whomever is paying the bill.
    It would be a conflict of interest to represent both parties at a settlement.
    Another good reason to avoid Texas."

    one more time:

    The attorneys for the title company/escrow company/closing office draw documents.

    Their responsibility is to be sure that the conveyancing is done correctly, & for that the buyer & seller each pay part of their fee.

    The attorneys who draw docs do not charge for representation or advice or contract negotiation;
    they charge for drawing docs.

    Buyers & sellers can have lawyers representing them if they wish, & in that event, yes, each party would pay his/her own attorney, & the attorney would have a fiduciary responsibility to the party paying the fee for representation & advice unless, as is common in, say, some divorces, one party agrees to pay the other party's legal expenses.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ...Contentious Closings

    I once sold a new home for a father-son building firm.

    The buyer's sister insisted on using the title company where she worked;

    she said she got an employee discount.

    On the Friday afternoon we were to close, I couldn't get the closer on the phone, & I never got a fax copy of the settlement statement.

    I called the seller (the son was closing by himself for the first time) & told him not to sign a thing until I looked over the paperwork.

    Sure enough, the documents had been drawn with *all* the closing costs on the sellers' side, including the ones that are printed out on the contract as being buyers' expenses.

    The closer wouldn't emerge from her office to talk to me.

    When she called the buyers in to close first, I told the receptionist to get me the office manager or owner of the company before those buyers signed.

    I said that the sellers were so angry that they were going to file suit Monday.

    I never saw a manager or an owner, but we were called in within about 2 minutes.

    The buyer never said a word.

    The sister/closer pouted & said, "The seller doesn't *have* to help her, but doesn't he want to help her?"

    I said the seller wanted to close according to the contract.

    & we did.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    sylvia - I'm confused - why did the closer want the seller's help?

    The gist of the story I got was the closer (buyer's sister) tried to charge all the buyer's closing costs to the seller. Isn't that illegal if it's not part of the contract?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    yes, that's exactly it.

    The closer was the buyer's sister, & she put all the buyer's costs onto the seller's side of the settlement statement.

    I don't know if it's illegal *if the sellers sign*;
    the closer & the buyer could claim that the buyer was just a smart cookie who re-negotiated the contract at closing, & if the sellers sign it, it means that they agree to the terms.

    which is why the closer wouldn't talk to me & wouldn't fax me a copy of the settlement statement.

    Since the sellers didn't sign it & the closer corrected it, the sale closed as it was supposed to.

    The closer just thought she could slip the expenses in & get away with it (maybe that was her idea of "employee discount").

    I don't know if the closer's boss(es) knew what she was up to, but when I told the receptionist that I wanted the manager or owner out there in the lobby, the settlement statement got changed.

    A closer might claim she "thought" she was supposed to do this or that or whatever, but the head of the firm would have been legally responsible.

    Of course, nobody apologized to the seller for his trouble or his anxiety (he had installed what we called "Star Wars" countertops for this buyer, black with purple & green swirls & starbursts, it would have had to be changed at some expense had the buyer not closed) or for trying to shaft him.

    --------------------
    --------------------

    Although title companies are supposed to be disinterested third parties at closings, sometimes there are relationships that favor one party.

    There used to be a builder out here who refused to sell unless the closing was at his favorite title company.

    I never could prove anything, but I had a buyer who was charged $3 a page for a "fax fee".

    The total ran to about $75, & the title company refused to delete the charges.

    (Today they couldn't get away with this; at the time, title companies were answerable only to the State Board of Insurance;
    as long as they charged the published rates for title insurance, they could charge anybody anything else they wanted.
    Texas has since tightened the regulations.)

    These buyers had their furniture in a van on the parking lot, & so they closed.

    Although nothing appeared on the closing statement showing any preference for the builder, I figured that there was at least $75 going to him under the table.

    don't know how life went for him after that, I never sold another one of his houses...

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In Virginia an attorney owes a duty to whomever is paying the bill.

    Sounds like they are. They're representing their client, the title company whose interest is to not botch the paperwork.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "buyer & seller each pay part of their fee...."

    "They're representing their client, the title company ..."

    No, the title company is just conveying money for whomever hired them. Buyer or seller.
    It is a point if negotiation since that person has legal representation at the settlement table, and if the other party wants they are free to hire and bring it with them.

    While the title company has a duty to be 'fair' in the handling of things, they ONLY owe a fiduciary duty to the person that is paying them.
    Texas attorneys have figured out a way to bill while assuming no liability. Nice if you can pull it off.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Fiduciary duty has to do with representation.

    Title companies, & their attorneys, represent neither buyer nor seller.

    They convey property.

    They represent neither buyers nor sellers.

    The fact that attorneys often represents clients does not mean that every job they do involves fiduciary duties.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    At our last closing we had to sign a paper that said we understand we are paying the lawyer, but they are not representing us. Something to that effect anyways.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "They represent neither buyers nor sellers."

    Like I said, great way to diffuse responsability.
    In Virginia attorneys hired by either the seller or buyer conduct all settlements and represent the party that hired them.
    There are only a few stand alone settlement companies since all settlements MUST be conducted by an attorney (the state bar comes after anyone that tries it without an attorney).

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If I were buying real estate in Virginia, I would do it Virginia's way.

    & if the other party's attorney were drawing documents & handling closing, I'd be sure I had an attorney my own self.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I had a listing where they Buyer's had their own agent (unusual for my area) and they were using a lender from a town about 3 hours from us.

    Long story short;

    The Lender was taking far too long to get the closing in order and my Seller's were fixing to cancel the deal and move on to the next Buyer.

    The Lender called me personally and asked if my Seller's would hold off a little bit and they agreed to pay the Seller's $25/day for each day over original contractual closing with a maximum of $350. If they hadn't closed by then our Seller's could walk with the Earnest Money and the $350 extra.

    Closing came and when I looked at the Settlement Statement the credit was not on there. My Seller's wanted to know where it was and I called the Lender from the closing table with Seller's and Buyer's present.

    The Lender asked me if everyone was there and I told him they were to which he said; "Well, if they are all there then they will close. I am not going to pay them the $350 because it has been a tough deal on my end".

    When I told my Seller he hit the roof and told the nice young first time home buyer's; "Nothing against you but you can't have my house, this deal is dead".

    All the while the Buyer's re agent sat there doing nothing. I finally told the closer to take the $350 out of my commission and let's get the deal closed. My Seller didn't want me to do that but I told him I would get it back. The Buyer's agent still said nothing.

    It took me almost 3 months but I got my money back from the Lender who was very obstinate every single time I called him.

    KC

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Back in the olden days, at age 21, I handled a closing on a condo for my parents who were living out of state. They buyer had misrepresented himself to the building manager, saying he was the new owner, and she let him in the condo before a coupleweeks before closing. He did some spackling, etc., then denied he'd been in there. He came to closing asking for new counter tops in the kitchen--theyw ere scratched. We'll they were scratched when he signed the contract. He complained about the unit having no smoke detector, required by law (sorry--required by law starting July1 of the following year, buddy). And so on. He whined on and on. A weasel Felix Unger kind of guy.

    I called my folks in CA, and they said to tell him to sign the papers and close or give up his earnest money. He signed.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We went well beyond a contentious closing, it a totally tumultuous transaction! We were buying a home that had been on the market for nearly a year, and in the hands of a relocation company for several months. There was 20+ acres of land with the 10 year old house. The realtor was married to one of the legal counsel for the company that had retained the re-location company and was a first class, impossible to deal with, witch. She did not deliver keys to our agent on 3 different occassions which resulted in our needing to reschedule inspections, including one time that she took them on vacation with her! She did not return phone calls, a few of which were when we were making offers on the property. She refused to have the grass cut (it was waist high) nor to open the pool for inspection until I contacted the relocation company directly. She left a dead mouse stuck in a trap from the second time we toured the house (in April) until the day we took possession (July 6). And on the day of closing, we each appeared at the attorney's office under seperate appointments, she just no showed. I once again contacted the relocation company and demanded the keys. She walked into my office and slammed them down on my desk, saying "Happy Now?"

    As soon as she walked out of my office 6 Federal Express packets left my office. The 48 page document inside each of them contained a day by day journal of her behaviour. The packets went to her, her broker, the home office of their franchise, the PA realtor licensing office, the relocation company and the company that retained them. She lost her license, her husband was demoted and transferred and a full blown investigation was conducted by the company (a public utility) which included them sending an investigator to my office to interview me and to our home for photographs. I had included numerous photos of the state of the home when we took possession. Many questions were raised stemming from this investigation, including why the home, (a high end, desirable home) was on the market for such a long time and ended up selling for $80K under the original listing price....it was the most highly assessed home in the township.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My story isn't as dreadful as some, but it was my first home and it upset me. It was in the 80s, the "sellers" (occupants) were a young couple but the husband's father was a co-signer on their mortgage, I guess. The contract stipulated that the sellers pay some of my closing costs, but at the closing the father showed up yelling belligerently (right in front of me) "Why should we pay her costs?" My realtor had gone on vacation and had someone I had never met before standing in for her. Fortunately, this woman just kept repeating calmly "Because you signed a contract agreeing to pay this." It did go through, and I was very grateful that I didn't have to say a word.

    In cases like that of the original poster - what if s/he had just said "If you don't wish to fulfill the contract as written, let's re-schedule this when I can have my lawyer here." Of course you'd have to go and find a real estate attorney. Would that work? Thinking of myself in that situation, I would have wanted an attorney of my own. My 3 homes have been bought and sold in Maryland and Georgia without my having a real estate attorney, and that's never been a problem. However, if at closing the other party started behaving like this and the realtor was no help, could it be rescheduled?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The atty at my closing was from the title company. He said up front that he was working for the lender, not me or the seller.

    Lynn_d: wow, you rock! She must have had some kind of screw loose to be so resentful of you wanting the keys of the house you just bought. Guess her karma bit her right on the backside.

    As for rescheduling, I've heard of people rescheduling closings. Certainly, if someone was trying to pull a fast one on me, I might demand a reschedule. At the very least, I'd 'go to the restroom' and call my lawyer.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lesson to all:

    Don't go to closing where the buyer and seller are present at the same time.

    Instead, schedule where signing is done separately by buyer and seller.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What's a closer?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What's a closer?

    In Real Estate it is not Kyra Sedgewick.

    In this case the "closer" is the closing agent and can be an attorney or an escrow officer. It is the person that makes sure that the 10 inch high stack of paperwork is in order and that all the t's are crossed and the i's are dotted. It is the closing agent's responsibility to make sure that all the terms of the contract are fully executed.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    When I bought a new house, the title company delayed closing for a week because their calculations weren't complete. Well..? So when I showed up for closing, they had the sales price wrong! It included upgrades to the new house that I had decided not to make and that hadn't been done -- So they had to re-run all the numbers. This time, running the calculations took them 30 minutes.

    Next house, the title company put all of the documents in the name of my very young son and me. Now my son has a name traditionally given to older men, and my husband has a name common to little boys -- so I can understand the original mix-up. But fortunately, we caught it right away and had the documents reprinted.

    So how is it that they registered the title in my name and my son's anyway? Then insisted that my son had to sign everything to get his name removed? (This was before he was old enough to even write his name!)

    The one upside has been the numerous telemarketers who now call for my son. Guess what? I put him on the phone! ;-)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In the middle of building a home for ourselves, and after we had sold previous home and moved to a rental, DH got a job offer much closer to our DD who was going to have our first grandbaby. I needed only one semester of teaching to retire, and was unable to get a position in the new town. We put new house on the market and I moved in with minimal furniture and we crossed fingers that the house would sell by midterm.

    A lady who had had a couple of showings signed a contract. Then a few days later she says she will have a co-signer, "her boss," and we were a little put off by the arrangement, but "her boss" turned out to be a local physician, one that I had seen and never returned for followups and then been told by colleagues that I should never have seen, he was awful,etc. Then little by little stuff started happening on the deal. Turns out he is going to be the only buyer, the lady is off the contract. It took the good dr. a few days to sign the new contract, but he did sign. He had been through the house at least twice. Word is passed to us that he is too busy with practices in 3 places and some deal going in a large city nearby, so he lets his office mgr. handle all business deals. We have a glitch that he wants us to pay for the appraisal for his mortgage. We are pretty mad, but still hoping this deal will fly and I can leave town with the house sold and stop commuting on weekends. We call an appraisal friend to ask his advice and get an absolute ear full on how this buyer has a terrible reputation in business deals, but the bottom line is, do we want to lose the deal over $400. Although contract said appraisal was buyer's problem, we finally agree to split the appraisal fee; that word was passed through the original lady of the first contract, obviously this house is for her and she is hoping the deal goes through, now that she has sold her house and kicked out her husband. Buyer initials contract at title co, & closing date is set. Apparently a moving van is rented for day of closing. We had cleared out the home and I am moved in with a colleague for will be less than 90 days before I can retire.

    I get a call at school on day of Friday closing, to which my DH has come by taking leave, that buyer has still not provided insurance and funds for closing, is not going to be able to come to the table, but wants the keys and everything will be made good on following Monday. I am very upset, call his business mgr. and she puts him on the phone, he is a real misogynist, gives me a very hard time and starts saying the house has problems around the chimney, roof flashing, yadda yadda, and if I can't trust him with keys, I have no business doing business with him (which, of course we WEREN'T at the outset of this deal). I just tell him to meet my DH at the house that evening. Meanwhile DH says, well, we will go to signing and get our part over, but he is not leaving keys. We go in. Closer had advised on phone that "most deals close, after all, he is a doctor" (whose reputation has certainly made an impression on the number of people who have told us tales about him). We are signing docs, feeling ill at ease, and the closer says, well it IS weird that you are here, but he's not. We leave with keys in our pockets, wondering what will happen next.
    That evening, the buyer shows up, DH has a ladder and goes up with him to show him that everything is right on the roof (which of course wasn't ever the issue anyway). Buyer is sweet as honey to DH, tells him there will be no problem at title company on Monday, and DH takes another day's leave to deliver keys to title company on Monday and sure enough, all the $$ is there, the insurance policy is there, all is well.Lady moves in. Friends tell us to hold our breath until the one year warranty we provided in contract is out, but it is now well passed.

    As a side note, the house has been listed with one or another realtor in the past 18mo. The MLS listing was always WAY off, the last time we were town the house appeared empty but unlisted, I can only imagine the pain he caused the realtors as he bounced from one to the other. And where is the original lady of the contract? We are dying to know, but never will.

    That is our contentious closing story from a FSBO.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've dealt mostly with commercial properties and find as a buyer that I want to leave on friendly terms with the seller. I've almost always had questions about the property down the road that the seller could help with. Not all buyers feel this way.
    I was selling an apt. building with a steam furnace. I offered to go to the building with the buyer and explain how it worked. He was insulted, we didn't go, and the furnace died a month later because he never drained down the water filler as he should have.
    Another...I was selling a mobile home part to a non profit agency. The director of the agency was a real bit**. At the closing she kept demanding things saying they were in the contract.(according to her interpretation). She kept repeating that we are going with the language of the contract...nothing more and nothing less. I kept giving in to her $200 and $300 demands because the place was a major headache and I was eager to unload it.
    I had brought all the property plans to the closing. With a mobile park, most of what someone is buying is buried. Without plans you have to just start digging all over until you find what you need.
    At the end of the closing, I looked at the box of plans, I looked through the contract and the plans weren't mentioned. So, I took the plans home. About a month later I began getting calls from the director's assistant. They had underground problems and couldn't locate water and sewer lines (in this northern region they are buried 6' deep). After a few calls they said there must be some plans. I told the assistant to tell the director to read the contract to see if plans were mentioned there. Never heard from them again. I would estimate that over the years they spent a good $50,000 digging and looking for things when problems developed. I may sound cruel, but you would have had to meet this woman to understand.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Reviving this thread to add a story.....

    DH and I closed on our house on Monday, and during that final lull when the title rep went to make a million copies of everything signed, everyone started exchanging Bad Closing Stories around the table.

    The realtor told about a closing for a divorced couple where the husband, his new wife and the ex wife all showed up. No one would agree to signing a power of attorney so s/he didn't have to see the ex; no one would agree to a separate room. Everyone wanted to be there, in the same room, to snarl insults and issue threats. The combined efforts of the title rep and the bank's attorney finally got the warring parties into separate rooms to sign off on the documents, but the realtor said it was touch-and-go for a while; didn't know if they were going to have to phone the cops to calm things down. Eeek.

    Then our bank's attorney told his story: he did a closing a couple of weeks ago where the husband showed up in his jail jumpsuit and handcuffs, escorted by two corrections officers. He had refused to sign a power-of-attorney and insisted on being at the closing. When he got there, he refused to sign anything and sat there smirking "you can't make me." He thought he could leverage the closing into a day out of jail; if the closing was postponed because of his refusal to sign, no big deal, he'd get another day out when it was rescheduled. The COs took him outside and 'convinced' him. The bank's attorney said his face looked like a piece of veal when he came back in, and he signed everything without comment. Horrifying.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh my!! Those are great stories!!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In real estate people do all kinds of strange things for reasons unknown to others. I've been at closing with a drunk husband which the wife successfully hid from the settlement attorney. I've been in between bitterly divorcing couples (not much fun). I've been in situations where buyers wait until the closing to ask for money (when it is my seller I ask the sellers to remain quiet and I handle it.) If is an item we disclosed- too bad. If is something we overlooked and is something that they could sue for later- we listen and compromise if necessary) If it is my buyer and the seller is trying to pull a fast one- I ask for money to be escrowed until it can be resolved- usually an unethical seller will cave at the thought of not getting all their money.

    If it has been an awful closing and the item is less than a couple hundred dollars I may just pay for it. Sellers sometimes leave trash- I just pay a guy to go get it. It's not worth a fight.

    The worst deal I had was a young couple who did not want to move twice so they borrowed money to have their house built while they sold their condo. They listed their condo three months later than I suggested and when it did not sell right away they tried to back out of the deal. The husband had his mother call me to tell me that she was going to sue me for talking her son into giving money that was non redundable. I suggested we meet at the attorney's office- she suggested a local restaurant. After ten minutes of telling me what an unethical, horrible agent and person I was, I pulled out their signed contract on which I had additionally circled and asked him to inital next to "non refundable earnest money". I also gave her the name of the builder who had also signed and initialled that part of the contract. She bought my lunch and paid their mortgage until it sold. What a good mom!