Software
Houzz Logo Print
corgilvr_gw

Need codes experts.

19 years ago

We have very old narrow streets running at the back edges of our narrow, town center lots. One of our neighbors told us she was planning on building a garage that would be "architecturally sensitive" to the neighborhood. We were delighted for her and based on her comments we were led to believe the structure would be similar in size to those already built on the alley. We have zero setbacks for the side lot lines. I hope that makes sense.

No habitable space is permitted on the alley. The garage that went up is 2 stories tall and the roof looks like the one you might see on a dairy barn. The roof pitches toward the adjoining properties and the edge of the roof is at the property lines. There is no evidence of gutters and those would have to extend into the adjoining properties if they were added to the roof edge. There is also a door on the alley side of the building next to the garage door which allow access to the structure from the alley. There is no parking in this narrow alley and none of the other garages has this kind of access or height. This "garage" is larger than some of the houses on this street and is at least twice the size of any other addition.

We are working on the size and use of space issue through the local codes office. She may use the space as an office, but not as a guest room as she told us it would also be used as. Can the run off from the roof, or half of it, be directed at my property and spill onto my structure and foundation? All of the other buildings here pitch into the owner's yards and all drainage is directed towards those owner's yards.

I would appreciate any information you have about this water coming off the roof. If it is acceptable, how can I protect my structure from all of this water spilling onto my garage? My garage is set back from the side lot line which allows a space for this spill off from the neighbor's new roof. Also, my garage roof is higher at the front and my entire roof pitches into my yard, therefore none of my roof water is directed at the adjoining properties. I have a gutter and downspout on the rear edge of my roof. Now I'll have her roof water spilling into that same area as my downspout. Our spout is directed toward our backyard and it is approximately 10 feet from the property line.

I want to be neighborly, but this just seems inconsiderate and I feel as if I was deceived. I think it also could damage my wooden structure and the foundation. Thanks for any advice you may offer.

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    Good question -
    I'm no "code expert" - actually I haven't met any that are! LOL - Codes vary by state, local municipalities etc... and INTREPRETATION is an entity unto itself. Some building depts are more to the letter of the law than others - IBC Internation building code is a basis for state/local codes

    That said - you noted "We are working on the size and use of space issue through the local codes office"
    So you have been to your local building dept? then they did issue a permit for this structure?
    And did a final inspection and granted a CO?

    If that is the case the next step is to pull local code books @ building dept(they can't leave the premises) Or your local library - and look up the issues that you have considerations with
    1. Size of lot and allowable building on lot
    ** Our locale is 20% of lot size
    2. height of structure

    3. Setback - I'm not sure what your comment meant but these are all indicated in local codes i.e. 15' from side of property 25' from front etc...
    - This is critical in your case - as the reason for establishing setbacks is exactly as you describe - NO runoff should be on other properties (not to say it doesn't happen) No part of the structure gutter/drip edge or other may be on another's property (how would it be built, repaired, maintained w/o tresspassing?)

    There are strict guidelines in building codes now related to waste water, water conveyance etc...

    If your neighbor wanted to deviate from local code they would have had to apply for a variance and that would be heard in public forum (zoning board public mtg) where you could voice your concerns

    It all sounds quite odd to me - and I would suggest doing your homework and requesting a mtg with the town building dept for some answers - If they issued permit and CO and this is non conforming to local laws they have set themselves up for potential law suit. The town is within it's rights if no permit/co the building be taken down - this would certainly make the property not sellable as well - while it may not make close ties to neighbors it is protecting your investment - one cannot willy nilly erect structures!

    Good luck! keep us posted

    Here are some code examples - but best place is at local building dept

    http://www.palatine.il.us/publications/Village%20Code/Chapt%2006.pdf

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for your response. We live in an old neighborhhod of mostly 1840s town homes. There is no side lot setback and structures can be connected to each other at the lot lines. If my garage was on the line, she could simply construct a wall next to and touching mine. I think that would be better. My garage is not on the lot line and there is a dirt/grass strip between my garage and the lot line. The 20 foot height of the new building, I think, could pose more erosion and other damage because of the distance water, snow and ice have to fall onto my property. I don't think a gutter will deter the snow and ice. I also don't see this woman cleaning clogged gutters of that height.

    The codes officer was very interested and will not "go final" until the gutter issue is resolved. They said the building is of legal height, but that they encouraged a more appropriate structure. On a lighter note, she told us we could erect a huge sail so that we didn't have to look at the new structure! I think I'll just plant more trees and maybe a little bamboo along the fence line!

    I will purchase a copy of the codes book and familiarize myself with some of these issues. I am also ending my walk shoveling days and I think she is off my guest list. Trust and respect are so easily destroyed. She has changed the vista of the entire neighborhood. Thanks for listening to all of this. I just can't believe how huge that building is compared to the other structures. We are now placing bets on the vinyl siding and asphalt roof colors. I'm hoping for a gray roof and neutral vinyl.

    Here is a link that might be useful: this sort of street

  • 19 years ago

    I would strongly suggest you take advantage of the research section of your public library to review the codes because there are dozens of code books involved and based upon the ones that I am familiar with they will cost about $45 to $70 each.

  • 19 years ago

    Not sure codes cover these things. The occupancy and configuration things sound more like zoning issues. You might need to research the local zoning ordinances.

    In most places each property needs to take care of its own runoff water - water cannot flow from one property to another, rather, it must flow to a proper place as identified by the local jurisdiction (to the street for example).

  • 19 years ago

    "Can the run off from the roof, or half of it, be directed at my property and spill onto my structure and foundation?"

    As a general rule you are required to accept natural runoff from higher elevation properties.
    An owner is NOT allowed to make modificatins that increase the runoff to adjacent properties.
    Roof dainage is NOT considered 'natural' runoff in any jurisdiction I have heard of.
    The building codes do not normally cover these types of issues, but common law (decided cases) govern.
    You should contact the local bar association and see who handles these type of cases in your jurisdiction.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with brickeyee's clarification of the runoff rules.