Software
Houzz Logo Print
rivkadr

Why does this have to be so hard?

19 years ago

I know that many contractors must be hard-working, honest guys, but seriously...why does it have to be so hard to deal with them? I'm paying good money for them to do work for me, and yet I feel like I have to stand over them to ensure that they're not ripping me off, or doing a shoddy job. To wit:

Our bathroom shower started leaking a couple of weeks, and the most likely culprit seemed to be a cracked shower pan. We got 5 estimates, and went with a contractor who came in around the middle in price, and seemed knowledgeable, friendly, and competent. The problems we have had so far:

1) He told us that it would take no more than a week to replace the shower and put in a new vanity. That's one of the reasons we picked him, because he said he wanted to be speedy, because it was more cost effective for him. It's now been two weeks, all time that I have taken off to be here because I don't want a bunch of strange men wandering through my house. And they're still not done.

2) He had someone on his staff pull the permit. They were supposed to drop it off in our mailbox. They never did. No permit throughout this whole process. We've been assured that the permit has been pulled, and there have been inspections done throughout the whole process, but the fact that we don't actually have the permit posted irks me.

3) I explicitly told him that I wanted the bullnose tile in the shower done a certain way. Because the workers don't speak English, I had to take it on trust that it had been explained to them. Well, it wasn't. When I finally pushed my way into the bathroom to see the tiling in process (it's a very small bathroom, and I couldn't get in there very often without tripping over the workers, and I didn't realize they had started the tiling until well after the fact), I saw it was completely wrong. By then the tile was 2/3rds done, and I have to live with it.

4) The tile workers ran out of bullnose tile, and didn't tell me (not that I could have understood what they were saying if they had). So around the base of the shower they just used regular tile that looked like crap, and I guess expected I wouldn't notice. Even worse, they tried to hand bullnose it themselves by breaking off the edge of the tile! It looked awful, I can't even tell you how bad it was. I complained to the contractor, and he tried to convince me that one side of bullnosed tile always looks worse than the other side. Um...no. I brought the bullnosed tile home myself, I know what it looked like. Don't feed me crap and expect me to like the taste of it. I stomped my feet and made them use an actual bullnosing tool to fix the appearance of the tile, and it ended up looking semi-decent.

5) When we went around to buy all the supplies for the bathroom (vanity, showerhead, sink faucet), I asked the contractor about the shower door. He said, "Don't worry about it, I have a guy who you can talk to, to get your door through." Time passes, the renovation is nearly over, and still no shower door. Finally, he says, "Oh, yeah, you have to go get your shower door now." I'm like, "What??" So we run around, trying to find a shower door in either brushed or satin nickel, only to find out that anything in that finish in our size is at least a two wait week. IF we had ordered it back when we had gotten our other supplies, we'd have it now, but since he didn't tell us to do that -- had in fact, told us NOT to do it, we're going to have to wait. I am SO angry.

There's a ton of other small things, little annoyances that have made this process just a major pain in the butt. I don't understand how something that is costing me thousands of dollars is such a difficult process. My husband and I did most of the earlier remodeling work on our house ourselves, and this experience just confirms for me that it was the right decision. It's hard work, but you can make certain that you do it the way you want it when you do it yourselves.

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm sorry you're having such a difficult time. I don't know exactly what your project entailed, but it seems the contractor was being overly optimistic by saying the job would take only one week. Bathroom remodels can be a real pain for the small space, with plumbing issues, tile and whatnot involved. I'd suggest to keep your cool with the contractor and sit down and explain that you find the tile unacceptable and ask them to redo the botched bullnose. He'll probably balk if he wants to just get away from the job, but by rights, he should offer to redo the poor work -- at his cost. Shower pans are not easy either and are prone to leak if not done properly. I would suggest that you very plainly tell him that he if doesn't fix the errors you will report him to the BBB and possibly take him to small claims court to cover the cost of having someone come in and do the job right. I know its hard, but the best bet is to remain as calm as possible and allow the contractor to take ownership of the problem and feel he has an opportunity to fix it to your satisfaction -- and if he doesn't want to work with you, your other option is to fire him, finish it yourself or hire someone else and take him to court to recover your additional costs. Everyone can make mistakes, but the difference is those who take responsibility for them and those who try to pass the buck, take the buck and run away.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you have had inspections then a permit would seem to have been pulled. They don't inspect what they don't know about. Seems odd that he wouldn't tape it to the window. If you want to verify the permit, make a phone call.
    If your shower door is not an off the shelf unit, it will not be ordered until the whole bath has been tiled. Shower door companies will only measure finished areas. A two week lead time is pretty standard.
    In the future when you hire out for jobs, have a finish date put in the contract. This way you both have an understanding on the time frame. That said, once you demo the bath you might find issues that need to be addressed that were not forseen in the contract. This will add time and cost to the job.
    Ron

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "That said, once you demo the bath you might find issues that need to be addressed that were not forseen in the contract. This will add time and cost to the job."

    Exactly, which is why every good contract should have a change order stipulation. We've often run into such situations and a sit down with the homeowner usually gets them to understand and we move on with the added costs applied in partial to the contract and partial up front.

    Communication is an important element on the part of both parties before, during and after a job.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    i am sorry, but i believe i would have forced them to replace the tile at their expense. you told them how to do it in no uncertain terms, and they did it wrong. make them make it right.