Trash compactor or trash pull-out?

14 years ago

We purchased a home with a 20 year old trash compactor. After adding up all the parts and labor, it appears to be roughly the same cost to replace it with a new stainless steel model as it would be to create a trash pull-out with a semi-matching cabinet door and foot pedal. We plan on replacing the cabinets in 5 to 7 years, so the long term savings aren't a factor. Plus, space only permits a single can trash pull-out... not one of those convenient trash/recycle solutions.

Now, I'm enticed by the idea of just sliding a new trash compactor into place and forgetting about it. On the other hand, trash pull-outs seem to be much more in vogue.

Thoughts?

Featured Answer

poohpup

14 years ago

I had a trash compactor in my last house and LOVED it. I thought I'd always want another. But this house is on a septic system. Big difference. My last house I used the GD for food and in this house it all goes in the garbage. I wouldn't want a trash compactor smashing down all that food. Plus the garbage goes out now at least once a day. If I wasn't on a septic and had a GD, I'd have a trash compactor again.

My trash pull-out was installed today. Really looking forward to having that. Can't open the darn thing yet because none of the handles are on yet. lol

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

remodelfla
14 years ago
For me it would be a no brainer... definitely trash pullout.
xc60
14 years ago
We have a trash compactor in our kitchen, we all love it!
Related Professionals
Pensacola Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Alexandria Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Sedalia Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Meridian Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Danbury Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Burlington Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Milwaukee Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Queens Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Columbia Kitchen Remodelers · Knoxville Kitchen Remodelers · Spartanburg Custom Countertops · Bloomington Custom Countertops · Webster Custom Countertops · Mansfield Custom Countertops · Eugene Custom Countertops
suzanne_sl
14 years ago
I have to say that when I had a group of young (that is, younger than me) friends over and they saw our freestanding trash compactor, they laughed and said they hadn't seen one since they were kids. Thanks! In any case, we replaced it with trash cans under the sink when we did the reno. Our small kitchen didn't have space for a pullout or we might have gone that way.

How many people live in your house? When all 3 kids were growing up, the trash compactor was marvelous. When it got to be just the 2 of us, it could take 3 weeks to fill. We made separate trash runs for smelly things like meat trays. If you have a houseful of people, I say replace it until you do your reno and then reevaluate. You're unlikely to be sorry you have it, and it's so much easier not trying to blend a new element into a cabinet run that you're going to replace anyway.
rhome410
14 years ago
We hated our trash compactor and are much happier with trash pullouts. With kids doing the meal cleanup, we had to be so careful that they covered anything 'yucky' before compacting, it was such a cleaning nightmare. Also, the bags got too heavy for the kids or me to carry out sometimes. We have to take out the trash more often, and we have more primitive and less efficient ways of squishing it down, perhaps, but I feel it's worth the trade offs. If you loved the trash compactor, you may like another.
MichelleDT
14 years ago
Love our compactor and wouldn't give it up. Putting two i the new house - one in the clean up zone and one in the prep zone.
a2gemini
14 years ago
Nerdy - when my DM compacter died - she just used it as a pull out trash bin without crushing.
The nest was empty - so she kept one bag in it and then used regular bags on top and just pulled those to throw away, leaving the bit thick bag in the drawer.
I assume she periodically replaced the big bag but not sure how often...
jjaazzy
14 years ago
I like the compactor, you can use reg bags and it is a good idea to put a fold of newspaper down first before smashing. We never found it too heavy to pick up.
camphappy
14 years ago
We currently have a compactor and are planning a reno for our kitchen. We considered not replacing the compactor but then I remembered living without the compactor. The garbage had to go out everyday, rain or shine. With the compactor we take it out once per week and save money with our garbage bill by having the smaller size garbage can.
marvelousmarvin
14 years ago
Depending on the size of the kitchen and how much storage you have, you might just consider taking out the trash compactor and replacing it with a base cabinet for more storage.
library_girl
14 years ago
Growing up we had a compactor and the bags of trash were so heavy because so much was compressed into it. I remember as a teenager having to hold the bag to my chest to get it to the garage (no string ties to hold it) - I hated it. Not sure if it's the same issue now, but I prefer getting the trash out of my house sooner, rather than later.