Software
Houzz Logo Print
sis2two

Help needed for color direction for kitchen cabinets

14 years ago

I am looking at possibly having my kitchen cabinets painted because they are outdated and have been difficult to find paint colors that worked well with both.

If I have them repainted, I want neutral and something that won't be outdated in 10 years. I like the looks of a country kitchen and of course the creamy crackle tile and soapstone will be staying. Thanks so much

Comments (36)

  • 14 years ago

    I just wrote this in your other thread....

    If you do a google of "cottage kitchen pictures" you'll get a slew of samples and most have white cabinets. Granted with the wainscot and backslash all white cabinets would be a lot of white, but you could just leave your uppers in the wood and paint the lowers white. At least that way you'd have a neutral foundation and it would still look nice.

    I would also do a cross post in the Kitchen forum, they have a lot of experience with this sort of thing.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks lukkiirish. I wonder how that would look with white lowers and the stained uppers. It sure would be nice to not have to paint the uppers, but I just don't know.

    I sure could use lots of suggestions and pictures would help. This is somewhat overwhelming to say the least.

  • 14 years ago

    It's a popular choice to have the mix of painted and wood. Wood goes with everything and I like the idea of having a natural element in room. Here's one sample, and as I said, if you Google for it, a lot of images with a lot of samples will come up.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Home and Garden

  • 14 years ago

    lukkiirish- I love that! I have been sitting here thinking how I could possibly keep my stained uppers and still have an updated look. Not too mention that I love natural wood and the warmth it brings. You have no idea how much you have helped me. Thanks so much. If you or anyone else comes across more photos with the stained uppers and white lowers, I'd love to see them.

  • 14 years ago

    I honestly love your cabs as is. The only thing you need in the kitchen and DR are textiles. Starting with a colorful braided rug in the DR. Add a matching runner along the sink area, along with some curtains.

    The wood and walls are perfect for a country look. They just need to be softened with material, and maybe some crocks and stuff of various colors.

  • 14 years ago

    Sis, You're very welcome. It's a great look. I think the combination of the white on the lowers, wood uppers, creamy yellow wall color and wainscot will give you a nice foundation to build that cottage look you want.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks Oakleyok. Honestly there are times when I love my green cabinets and other times that I feel that they are just an outdated green. In fact I have even thought of using a different green, but who's to say that won't be dated in a few years. It is so difficult to know what direction to go in. I just know its too dark to me now and the wall color is overwhelming to the space. I do plan to add the rugs and curtains though. I have so much color throughout my home, and I think at times it becomes too much. Not changing from my country look though.

  • 14 years ago

    I agree, try painting the lowers white and change out the hardware to a silver or pewter tone on all. if you end up wanting white uppers you can go ahead and paint them, but I think they will look great with the lowers painted. I also agree a rug and some other fabric in the room will make a big difference.

  • 14 years ago

    I wonder what the green cabs would look like with a glaze on them? (Or does it already have that?) It might change the color a little, without a major paint job. Also, maybe dark oil-rubbed bronze knobs on the cabs might give you a change.

  • 14 years ago

    Lake Girl-- the cabinets do have a glaze on them. They are actually darker in person than the pictures show and are not really blue green.

  • 14 years ago

    I can understand you wanting it lighter. But don't make changes just because you think something will be out-dated, or dated, unless you plan on selling. The green is perfect! I have the same colors in my house. It's really pretty at Christmas. lol

    One thing about your kitchen is it's large enough to handle a dark color. I also think once you accessorize w/rugs, etc., it will pull everything together.

    Light yellow would go well in there too, for accessories.

    I dunno, but I really really like it. It's so "Americana" which I love!

    One more thing, I'm on the "Preview" page as I write this so I can't go back and see if you have under-cab lighting. If not, it makes a big difference in making your kitchen brighter.

  • 14 years ago

    I would paint those bottom cabinets white in a heart-beat! You asked for opinions so I will be very honest - I do not like that dark, pine green look with your pretty floors nor with your dark counter. That counter will be smashing with white cabinets. It is also limiting your paint choices.

    With the green you currently have the only "country" I can see would be primitive and primitive can get old after a while. With white bases, you can go in many directions from soft country to cottage country to primitive country, but you will have "choices". Go for it!!

  • 14 years ago

    oakleyok- you are so sweet! I do have under cabinet lighting, thank goodness. The other problem that I have with the green is they are in the sight lines from other rooms, and that really makes decorating difficult if you know what I mean.

    Tuesday 2008- thanks for your post. I am going to ask if perhaps someone could Photoshop my bottom cabinets white. I may also post on the kitchens side. I am so used to seeing them dark, that I can't picture them white.

  • 14 years ago

    Sis, I realized why I'm not keen on the bottom cabs being white. If you're going to do a bi-color, I think the bottom cabs should be darker than the uppers.

    You could always paint the bottom cabs a light "vintage" pastel green. But I don't know if it would go with the upper cabs. I think you'd have more color choices for your wall if you paint the upper cabs white.

    FWIW agian, I'd leave them be. Your room is so cozy and will be cozier once you add textiles.

    But then again, I painted my kitchen and the rest of the house to match my accessories, which I'll never change out in color. I think I do the opposite of most people. lol. I accessorize first, and then choose paint.

  • 14 years ago

    Sis, if you can get your hands on some butcher paper or inexpensive white gift wrap, why not wrap the lower cabinets in it and see how it looks. I'm all for finding ways to "test drive" a new idea without committing to it completely.

  • 14 years ago

    It is hard to pull off a mix of light on the bottom and dark on the top - the reason that the Home & Garden kitchen gets away with it is the heavy glaze and staining on the lower cabinets, which are ivory rather than white - and even then, it looks top-heavy to me.

    I agree that your lovely cabinets do seem to have come from an earlier fashion. If you want a change, you might start by painting the upper cabinets a warm ivory-toned white, and swapping your glass doors for another pair without the arched bit, and with leaded panes. Then consider very deep warm gray for the lower ones, which I think would look great with your scheme.

  • 14 years ago

    A vote for creamy white to match the backsplash -- on both the upper and lower cabinets.

    Then add black hammered iron handles to the cabinets.

    Paint the wall in the same creamy white color too ....

    Then add a painted kitchen island -- maybe add color there ... with a hanging pendant lamp or two ....

  • 14 years ago

    I love the idea of replacing my arched doors with glass with regular glass doors. They are outdated now that I look at them. I am hoping that the doors themselves aren't dated minus the color that is.

    I contacted my cabinet supplier today to see what they suggest when painting over the cabinets. They did say that my lifetime warranty would be voided should I paint over them, but that does not surprise me. They are contacting Woodmode about how to repaint them. I wouldn't be doing that myself. Obviously they can't be sprayed like with the factory finish.
    Thank you all for your suggestions. You all a great bunch!

  • 14 years ago

    When I look at decorating books and magazines, I am instantly drawn to warm woods and yes, green cabinets. However, not the green that I have. The more earthy brown greens. It may be cost prohibitive to paint the uppers and lowers. I just don't know yet. What do you all think about other greens?

  • 14 years ago

    Hmmm...if you have a sprayed factory finish, it isn't going to be easy to paint them and have the paint adhere properly.
    Very good idea to have your supplier contact Woodmode about proper prep and priming, if you decide to go ahead.

    I also think it's time to take a deep breath! You're suffering from what I call concept fatigue! Too many ideas bouncing around in there to make a cohesive plan. So you might want to start a new notebook, and fill it up with all the inspirations that really grab you, and then really analyze what appeals to you and why. I'd hate to see you go to all that trouble and expense unless you have a complete plan for the final result.

    Having said that, have you considered a painted floorcloth for your breakfast area? It's a wonderful old traditional look, and when properly done, they wear very well, and are a snap to clean, unlike a braided rug, which gets gunky eventually, no matter what you do.

  • 14 years ago

    bronwynsmom-- you are right about concept fatigue! This actually started with just changing out wall color, and it has now grown into possibly painting my cabinets! And it may be that we can't paint them anyway because of the multistep finish. And who knows! That may end up being a blessing in disguise.

    Maybe I should just look at the other ways to update my country kitchen. Definitely update the glass doors, rugs, maybe change wall color, etc. I am going back to my deep breathing.

  • 14 years ago

    Sis, i've seen this product at a home show, and it looks phenonemal! Let me tell you , it isn't cheap. I think it's purchased based on the sq ft of cabs you are painting. ;o)

    Here is a link that might be useful: new product

  • 14 years ago

    FWIW, I like your cabinet doors. They have more character and interest than many cabinet doors you see now-a-days, and I wouldn't know when to date them, so they don't strike me as dated. Country is supposed to have a little quirky character!

    I like the idea of painting the lowers a sagey green. White lowers with stained uppers might look a bit topsy turvy, IMO, with the lighter shade being on the bottom (as I realize others have already pointed out). A little sanding and bonding primer should make your cabinets paintable, but contacting the manufacturer was a good idea.

  • 14 years ago

    I think the floor and cabinets are great as they are. I like the color of the bottom cabinets (on my monitor) very much - and the floor is fabulous. What seems just ever so slightly jarring to me is the trim between the floor and the cabinets. I wonder if changing that wouldn't make a big difference. Also, perhaps, a warmer white for the surfaces that are now painted white - ceiling and window & door trim.

    I always hesitate to make suggestions since decorating definitely not my expertise but I think that relatively minor changes can make a big difference to how a room feels.

  • 14 years ago

    orcasgramma- In reality, that trim is actually a toe kick which is the exact stain of my upper cabinets. When you're in the room it's not even noticeable. The pictures are quite deceiving. For instance my cabinet knobs are all stained wood which isn't showing up. The warmer white would probably look better. We have all the same white trim throughout our house.

  • 14 years ago

    Have you ever looked at the Workshop of David T Smith? He uses a mix of paint/stain and a country/primitive. Look at the gallery, especially kitchens #5 and #7 with their green and staining.

    I would think about keeping the green color on the bottom of the microwave section (right of stove/hood) and painting the top cabinets (since they sit on the counter) the same green. Make it look like a hutch.

    What is the table/island you're using? Is that staying? It seems small for the space. I know you like it turned that way, maybe using it when you're cooking (?) but I think it would look better going the other direction. Have you thought about buying a pre-built island?

    The upper cabinets between the sink and stove/hood, what about removing the doors and having them open? You could even add a plate rack in the bottom of the cabinet with glass doors (once removed). Perfect, over the dishwasher.

    Also remove the cornice over the sink. Add curtain/fabric. You could even add a skirted fabric under the sink. Leave the false drawer, but remove the doors.

    Leave the doors on the pair of uppers to the left of sink. Remove the cabinet above the fridge. It's useless and replace it with a gigantic woven wicker basket.

    I wouldn't do a braided rug in the kitchen or breakfast area, as suggested either here or on your other thread. While they do have that country feeling, they are hard to keep clean in the kitchen. I had a stenciled sisal in the kitchen and breakfast room in our last home - messy DH, three children and pets. I ordered mine from Ballard a million years ago - no idea what's out there now, but I sprayed them with a waterproof spray (so they would clean easier) and you can always spray the back with the rubber spray in a can from Lowes/Home Depot - used on truck beds, etc. to keep them from slipping. Better than rug pads in the kitchen, imo, if you have children.

    I'm not sure if you're only wanting to paint or willing to do a bit of cosmetic work - so I apologize if I went overboard. Let me know and I'll make more or change my suggestions. I'll go read your other thread now, only skimmed it earlier, and talk about paint colors.

    Allison

    Here is a link that might be useful: David T Smith

  • 14 years ago

    allison- I left my response to your post on my other thread. Thank you so much.

  • 14 years ago

    You're welcome! Sorry it took me awhile to get back to you!

  • 14 years ago

    I really like your green and wood tone. I would be tempted to paint the center island/table legs to match the cabs.

  • 14 years ago

    Thank you for responding to my post sis2two - I've gone back and looked at the posted pictures again. Your response helps me to realize how different the pictures are from reality.

    I still like what you have now a great deal. In our new house I'm only going to have lower cabinets and have been considering painting them something other than white so seeing your pictures is helpful.

    Are your floors as beautiful in reality as they are in the pictures?

  • 14 years ago

    I would have all those cabinets painted in a creamy buttermilk color in one red hot minute! They are lovely cabs and a new color is a fantastic idea!

  • 14 years ago

    The buttermilk color may be a really good option for an island. When I think about the work it's going to entail to have them all repainted, I think I would rather leave them as they are and make other cosmetic changes. As others have pointed out, I really need to add some textiles and make some changes to my cabinets. Hopefully that will help with the hardness that seems to be going on now.

  • 14 years ago

    My disclaimer is that I usually favor the option that requires more work but... I don't think those dark green cabinets are doing your soapstone any favors. It's getting lost in the sea of dark, and you are a lucky girl to have soapstone - that's what I'd be showing off (envious!) I would put the effort into painting those cabinets - something light and soft but it does not have to be white - a pale sage, a pale steel blue, buttermilk as someone suggested or maybe a very pale coffee with lots of cream. I would also make both upper cabinets flanking the window into glass cabinets, with square panels - if you don't want to display all of that stuff, a I would do a glass that doesn't show everything or some kind of gauzy panel... if you do want to show the stuff, I would go as far as to paint the interiors of those cabinets a darker version of whatever color you paint the cabinets if you wanted to be calmer and neutral, but something really fun if you want to be more bold. I would not do lowers one color and uppers another but I would add some color to the inside of those glass cabinets.

    A lot of work, yes... but IMO your kitchen is on the edge of "wow" and those dark cabinets are not going to get you there. So much potential! The expensive stuff is there and gorgeous, just needs some tweaking.

  • 14 years ago

    I haven't read all the responses but I know you were talking about wall color on another thread recently. Have you considered leaving cabinets as-is, painting the walls a cream (similar to your backsplash) to give the space a more airy feel, and perhaps changing out cabinet hardware (oil rubbed bronze?) to update things a bit? You have a very pretty kitchen with a gorgeous window/view (from the other thread). Maybe creamy walls would give you the freshness you're looking for.

    You might also consider incorporating an apple green in your accessories. The combination of darker green with a brighter green can work if you find the right elements.

    We recently painted our kitchen cabinets ourselves (for the third time) and it such a time-consuming hassle. Having it done professionally was cost prohibitive for us. If you can achieve the look you want without painting the cabinets I'd certainly recommend going that route!

  • 14 years ago

    I must say that you all have given me so much to consider. I know the easiest thing to do would be to leave the cabinets as they are and possibly repaint the walls. If I were building from scratch, I would not do the cabinet combination that I have now. However I also know that it's not going to be an easy task to repaint especially since they are already stationary in my kitchen not to mention the cost. Having said that, I want to be happy long term with my kitchen and I realize it is very dark. I am weighing everything out and will probably have someone take a look at our cabinets and give us information on what will be involved if we have them painted. So much to consider. As you can tell by my posts, I am all over the place about how to proceed. Again, I appreciate all of your input more than you know.

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations