Software
Houzz Logo Print
mary1218_gw

Light granite vs. darker granite

14 years ago

We are now ready to pick out granite for our new kitchen. Dynasty Cabinets are cherry with butternut stain and coffee glaze. SS appliances. I am undecided about granite color. Would like a warm feeling in this kitchen. Thought I would go with something neutral, like new venetian gold, but today saw a beautiful granite - Santa cruz. We are going to put hardwood on the floor. Any ideas on lighter vs darker granite? How about any suggestions for colors of granite? Does darker granite require more maintenance than lighter stone? Thanks so much for any ideas.

Comments (6)

  • 14 years ago

    Just a word of caution from someone who went with a light granite--I will warn you to make sure it will go with whatever kind of backsplash tile you want first. Mine is proving to be tricky to work with. It would have been easier if I had selected a darker granite and just had to find a lighterbacksplash tile to contrast with it--instead of having to find the exact shade that blends with the granite. See what kind of tiles work with whatever granite you select first. Make sure it all goes togetherbefore you decide (though, I wouldn't actually commit to the tile for the backsplash until the granite is actually in, as it could look slightly different in your lighting. Just get a general idea first.

  • 14 years ago

    I can only speak from what friends told me when we were picking ours out this last month. We all still have young kids at home, so that may make a difference, but two friends have darker granite (black) and they both said that you can see crumbs and messes much easier, b/c of the reflective nature of the black. They both said that they feel like they are constantly cleaning smudges off and that if they had it to do over, they would have gone lighter. For what it's worth...

    To me, a darker granite is a cooler feel. We went with a lighter one as well (fiesta gold, which is very similar to NVG). Can't wait to see your finished kitchen! Good luck!

  • 14 years ago

    Cherry cabinets themselves can give a lot of warm tone to a kitchen so you could choose from a wide range of granite colors and still have a warm tone to the kitchen. Our granite has pretty cool tones (aqua blues) and our kitchen still feels warm with cherry cabinets.

    Light granites may need more than one coat of sealing to start off because the lighter colors tend to be more porous (but not always). Once they have been sealed, they can be easy maintenance. Very uniform black can show dust and finger prints more, but move away from the very darkest ones or have ones with some pattern and variation and that isn't a problem. So mostly color isn't going to make a significant difference to granite maintenance.

    Here is our natural cherry kitchen:

  • 14 years ago

    I am in the same place as you. My kitchen is small and has a north facing window, so I think I need to go with a light granite. I was sure I was going to go with Bianco Romano, based on the granite samples I saw. That is, until I got to a stone yard and saw the huge slabs. Completely different from the pieces - AND I don't like it at all now!

    I got small pieces of various lighter colored granite from fabricators, sealed with one coat of Dry Treat and Stonepro. Red wine, grape juice, coffee, oil etc will leave a stain if left on for a few hours. Specially red wine, it leaves a bright pink stain. I could lift it using a baking soda poultice. I am going to take the pieces back for another coat and will let you know the outcome.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks so much to all of you for your comments. I will consider everything you offered and hopefully will pick a color I can live with. I am leaning toward the new venetian gold. It seems to have the best of both worlds, light and dark tones.

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH