Software
Houzz Logo Print
milarab

Sanity check on contractor behavior

13 years ago

Hello all,

Over the course of getting my kitchen, connected front hallway, and bathroom renovated, I have been increasingly frustrated with my contractors. But as a first time renovator, I have no idea how out of the ordinary their behavior and the service quality rendered has been. I'm posting here in the hopes that some of you will be willing to read my tale and tell me what you think.

I opted to go with a full design and build firm because of how little I know, and because I didn't want the hassle of dealing with permits, inspections, shopping, etc.

I chose my contractors over the other likely options for two primary reasons: 1) I prefer contact online to over the phone, and they had a cool new online interface that they would update with pictures of their work, an interactive schedule, an updating budget, etc. which would allow me to know when they'd be in the unit, where the process stood, etc. 2) They led me to believe that they had access to significant discounts on finish materials that they would be passing on to me, as well as a warehouse of leftover materials from other projects that they could sell to me at a discount.

I made it clear to them that as I was planning on renting out one of the rooms and I'm located near a university campus, I needed the renovations done by mid-September so that the unit was ready for the new roommate to move in.

They said they could fit the contract into my stated budget of 23K, and we signed off on it.

Then, things started going wrong.
0. The designers, managers and salespeople bought into the fancy website, but the builders didn't. The result is that I never knew if they'd be in my condo or not. I never knew what the updated schedule was. The process wasn't being documented and put online. And to communicate with the actual workers I still had to use the phone.
1. The so-called discounted prices they had access to didn't seem to exist. I could get better prices on the Internet and sometimes even at my local hardware store. I ended up having to source all of the faucets, drawer pulls, and knobs. Their tile prices were barely better in price than we could get elsewhere. We were able to source a sink and some tile from their warehouse and the warehouse tile was a pretty good deal but the sink was comparable to in-store prices.
2. The budget turned out to be too small for their lowest-end cabinets. The owner stepped in and offered to make us custom cabinets, since my kitchen is a tiny galley. Since I know that custom cabinets are WAY more expensive, I was initially mollified by this offer. But custom-made implies customization, and that's not what really happened...
3. My 'custom-made' painted wood cabinets have a particle-board frame. Although we ripped out the soffit in order to give me more cabinet space, they do not go to the ceiling, so they had to put a panel where the soffit used to be. The bottoms of the cabinets are not thick enough for the under-cabinet lights, so those lights and the wires connecting them are only hidden by a ledge. All of these could have been addressed if the cabinets were really custom-made for the project
4. They mis-measured my (3-month old) water heater (apparently professionals don't realize that metal cabinets are thinner than wood cabinets, and so measuring the outside of the old metal cabinets does not give you the size the wood cabinets have to be), so that my 'custom' cabinets are too small for the heater. The result? I have to spend $500 on another brand new water heater.
5. When the water heater issue was discovered, they dragged their feet on everything and work on the renos stopped. The result? I was without hot water for over 2.5 months, 21 days of which was spent waiting for them to answer my questions about water heaters.
6. 11 days after I approved the water heater, I finally contact them, including the owner, to complain and ask what was going on. They suddenly discover that the manufacturer sent the wrong model. Three days later, they have the right model and come and install it. No explanation of why the wrong heater took 11 days and a complaint email to arrive, but the right heater only took three days. Maybe it's because they never placed the damned order.
7. When they ripped up the carpet, I told them I wanted to keep it. They threw it out.
8. Apparently they didn't notice that my walls are made of concrete, because now they're saying, oops, we can't make the cabinetry flush to the wall because of the concrete, and oops, we can't install wood baseboards because these are concrete walls, so you'll have to have rubber baseboards instead to cover the crooked edges of the tile, because we didn't invest the effort to make them nice and straight because we assumed we'd have baseboards covering our mistakes.
9. The dishwasher doesn't work. This might be faulty installation on their part, or it might be the dishwasher; we'll have to see.

There are a number of other small issues which may or may not end up being resolved before this is all over. But it is now December 31. While we are down to the finishing details, those details still aren't finished, and we're already 3.5 months beyond the deadline we originally set for the project.

So, how badly do you think I'm being screwed?

Thanks in advance!

Comments (9)

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yeah, you're not having a good time, are you? They are total schmucks. And you need to get rid of them and find someone else.

    But, part of this is your fault. Being blinded by the possibility of technology didn't do you any favors. NOTHING beats old fashioned communication by phone. NOTHING. Nothing gets done without it, and you seem to be afraid of it. That's not working in your favor.

    And really, 23K for a budget is horribly unrealistic on your part for all of the work you've described. It's about half of what a realistic budget should be if you have to pay labor. And that's for the kitchen alone, according to national average statistics. Anytime something sounds too cheap to be true, it IS. Just because you lack the skills to do the project is no excuse to lack the knowledge to judge how the project should be done. You love online communication, well that's where you should have started to find out information about how the process needs to happen and what a realistic budget for what you wanted would actually be.

    Now, you need to use your love of the internet to investigate what the contractor's lien laws are in your state should you fire them. Have you paid them in full? Do you have a written contract? You also need to find a local attorney that does construction contract law and have him take a look at your contract to see what the terms are of ending it.

    And then find another contractor. Don't be blinded by razzle dazzle either. Or low bids. Find a good old fashioned guy who uses the telephone and calls you back and shows up on time. Those aren't the easiest ones to find at all. A contractor that does those simple things gets upgraded a letter on my list regardless of skills. It takes an average guy and places him above average simply because of being able to communicate effectively.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the response, hollysprings.

    Re: the online interface... I have a party with a financial interest in the renovation in a different country, so that was a part of that decision.

    Re: the small budget...
    1. If they couldn't do it in the budget given, they should have said that it couldn't be done. They didn't, nor did any of the other contractors who gave me quotes.
    2.
    a) According to Remodeling Magazine's statistics, the average job cost for a bathroom of my size is 16.6K. My job cost doesn't include the tub, toilet, lights, mirror/medicine cabinet, or hardware (curtain rail, toilet paper dispenser, towel bars, etc.) or paint; their job cost includes those things but doesn't account for my 60" granite countertop.
    b) The average kitchen remodel is about 58K. But that's for a 200 sq ft footprint with 30 linear ft of cabinetry. I have ~64 sq ft and 18 linear ft of cabinetry, plus a 6 foot shelf. Remodeling Magazine's number also includes a cook top, wall oven, fridge, microwave, dishwasher, and disposal, plus an island, painting, trim, and custom lighting, whereas my budget didn't include any of those appliances (indeed, I have a free-standing range, which is less costly to install), nor painting, and while they redid the wiring and switches and put in under-cabinet lights, they didn't touch the overhead lights. On the other hand, they budgeted for laminate counters and I went with granite. With so many differences between the Remodeling Magazine example mid-range remodel and mine, it's hard to judge what the cost should be. The best I can do is subtract an estimate of the appliance cost and then divide by a factor to account for the size. I'd guesstimate that this would come to between 17 and 27K.
    3. Knowing that an optimistic average cost for the project would be about 10K out of my budget, I put forth the option of doing the bathroom first and then when I'd rented the room for a while and had more money, doing the kitchen. But they insisted that there are labor savings in doing both at once and that they could do it within my budget. Given the estimates from other contractors who bid on the project were only 1-2K higher, I believed them.

    I did my best to do my research, but it's hard to get good estimates on an unusually small foot print from the information online.

    Maybe my expectations are unrealistic. After all, I do have porcelain tiles instead of ceramic, granite instead of laminate, and painted flat panel cabinets -- all items that are higher end than you'd expect in a budget remodel.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's not about the granite, porcelain tile and other upgrades. It's that the marketing hype obscured your judgement. This is a blend of wrong contractor, poor communication, slim budget and rosy outlook at the onset. Seems that the outfit can't even communicate with themselves effectively. Glad it's almost over. Happy New Year.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am sorry you are not having a good experience, but I also think that you still are very unrealistic about what exactly is going on here. Maybe that is not your fault, since you simply may not have known. But not knowing the truth doesn't change the truth.

    I don't think any good outcome could have resulted from this venture. Why?

    I think that you still are very very mistaken to ASSUME that renovating a smaller than average space would have any bearing on REDUCING the cost involved.

    If anything it will make it more expensive, because the standard solutions won't work, and more things will have to be custom-engineered for your job.

    You were expecting a standard "off the rack" type of solution, but custom tailored to your petite frame, and at a discount off standard.

    It is much less costly to put in a standard 12 foot run of counters and appliances for example, than to try and figure out how to get the same amount of appliance function and storage into a 9 foot space. This is not something that is cheaper because you used 25% less materials. It is more expensive because you now can't use a standard sink base, drawer stack, and regular refrigerator.

    So while I agree that you didn't get what you expected from the contractor, I think maybe you didn't get around to asking the right questions before you began, and then the lack of interpersonal dialog prevented it from ever happening. I don't mean to say this is your fault. A good contractor would have done the proper review of this with you. But since you still are not aware of this, it is obvious you don't have a good contractor with decent communication skills.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I feel bad that your project is so off track. I was in a similar place as you in that it wasn't until after I bought my old house that I realized that I had no real DIY skills to speak of and everything would need to be done by a contractor. I'm also very frugal and had a rather anemic budget.

    I don't think you were wrong at all in believing that the work could be done for your budget. As you said, your other bids came in only slightly higher and this firm agreed that they could do your job for your stated budget. I don't have any words of wisdom for you on this job but I will tell what I did that may help you in the future.

    I had the contractors break out each piece of the job, including the material allowance. For example, instead of a line item for installing a bathroom with one lump sum amount, each fixture and the specifics around it were on a separate line. Then I researched prices for materials for hours on end. Knowledge is power.

    I wrote a detailed description of what I wanted for each part of the job AND included pictures. That gave the contractor the opportunity to agree or bring me to reality on what my budget would really afford.

    And, most important, I made sure that EVERYTHING we agreed to was in the contract! When you have to contract out all of your work, the contract is your only saving grace. In your circumstance, that means it would have included things like the kind of cabinets that would be installed in your kitchen, the schedule and the type of communication you and the firm agreed to AND what would the recourse be if the terms were not met.

    Don't let this turn you against having work done on your house. I think you have learned quite a bit from this experience and your next job will go much smoother!

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The use of front office marketing people to sell home improvement services is epidemic.

    What you must remember is that a contractor is not your agent and is not obligated to protect your interests no matter what services they claim to provide. If it is not fully described in the contract you probably won't get it.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hind sight is always perfect. Sapphire69 has described an approach that works IF you can be intimately involved. If you are not in the same city, basically you are screwed.

    I've built several houses, all done by reputable builders. Although they didn't like it one bit, I was on site EVERY day I was in town, at least for a few minutes. There is NO SUBSTITUTE for a) good references b) a thorough, detailed Statement of Work, including materials specifications and budgets and c) frequent, in person review of ongoing activity.

    On the flip side, many homeowners use their presence on the site to develop changes or we might as wells, then complain like crazy when the bill comes in. Don't do that. EVERY change must be in writing, and detailed, and have two signatures on the paper.

    The problem I see many times with budgets stems from the completely bogus budgets shown on HGTV and the DIY channel. One never knows how much, if any, labor is costed in, or how much and what type of materials have been donated for promotion on the show. In general, I find every budget (when it is mentioned) PARTICULARLY on kitchen remodels, to be about half what you might encounter.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I feel for you, and your tale makes my remodel irritations pale in comparison! Hind sight is 20/20. We've remodeled our small bathroom and now we're adding an addition as well remodeling some other parts of the house (we've also done some maintenance work). It's been different each time, different materials, different scope, workmen, etc. We caved this time and didn't get enough paperwork, but I'd be a little afraid of working with someone on the internet. However even if you choose someone local, face-to-face, with good references doesn't mean that the person won't change things, tell you something may or may not be correct (especially if you don't know), argue about products, not add something that you don't know could be important, etc.

  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry to read about your troubles. I don't have much else to add to the other responses but I hope other newbies will read this carefully.

    Going with a design-build firm with cool web site instead of getting someone through referrals was your biggest mistake. Not doing enough research ahead of time as to what things cost hurt you as well. And yes, they screwed you by not telling you that your budget was unrealistic. Then they upsold you, made careless errors and you didn't stand up for yourself. I would have made them eat the cost of the mis-measured water heater cab at the very least.

    I hope your remaining issues are taken care of soon. Good luck.

    Lesson for newbies? Don't hand the reins of a remodel over to any company thinking they will take care of you. You are ultimately in charge and it has to be that way.